First. What is to be mapped?
The presence of animals?
Or
The animal output of a agricultural feature?
Once I have that answer I can respond to that issue rather than provide
multiple answers that confuse.
The first post talks of both presence and output, while the subject says
presence.
Re: produce,
It's much harder for a mapper to find out if a herd of goats is used
to produce milk, meat or cheese than to just tag "there are goats
here", even if you are doing a local survey. Unless the farm has a
sign like "Farmer Joe's Eggs", it's not easy to tell if chickens are
raised for
sent from a phone
> On 19. Aug 2019, at 15:28, Joseph Eisenberg
> wrote:
>
> If we remove the animal=yes tags, there are about 247 uses of animal=*
> on landuse=farmyard, landuse=meadow, and landuse=farmland combined, so
> it's not huge.
animal=yes/no would already be a quite useful
sent from a phone
> On 19. Aug 2019, at 15:20, Joseph Eisenberg
> wrote:
>
> similar and in many places it can be hard to distinguish hay meadow
> from grazing pasture during most of the year.
the presence of a fence aiming at keeping the animals inside may be an
indication, although not
sent from a phone
> On 19. Aug 2019, at 13:13, Warin <61sundow...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> So the produce key is used for the output, if that is live animals then they
> can be tagged that way.
> If the output is milk then produce=milk not produce=cow.
+1, similarly for chicken, which are
sent from a phone
> On 19. Aug 2019, at 12:35, marc marc wrote:
>
> 16% of landuse=farmyard have a anima=* tag.
> I didn't understand what argument to hope that the
> current most used tag would change in favor of a marginal tag.
generally I would expect a farmyard to contain several
sent from a phone
> On 19. Aug 2019, at 12:17, Joseph Eisenberg
> wrote:
>
> Unfortunately, the key animal=* has also been used for zoo animals
> (see elephant, etc) and some of the values are rare, proposed separate
> features like animal=wellness and animal=cemetery.
I would not see a
Le 19.08.19 à 15:28, Joseph Eisenberg a écrit :
>>> The tag livestock=*
>>> used 132 times
>>
>> 16% of landuse=farmyard have a animal=* tag.
>
> I think you misread taginfo.
you're right.
> If we remove the animal=yes tags
in stead of a replay, can you explain
why those valid datas need to be
>> The tag livestock=*
>> used 132 times
>
> 16% of landuse=farmyard have a animal=* tag.
I think you misread taginfo. There are over 800,000 landuse=farmyard
features, and only 1764 have an animal=* tag, so that is 0.22% - the
16% on the right means that 16% of uses of animal are found on
1) Landuse=meadow has been used for pastures for a very long time, and
the wiki page and definition make it clear that this is fine.
Previously landuse=pasture was proposed, but rejected since it's quite
similar and in many places it can be hard to distinguish hay meadow
from grazing pasture
Le 19.08.19 à 13:34, Paul Allen a écrit :
> On Mon, 19 Aug 2019 at 12:16, Warin wrote:
>I like property tags that can be used anywhere appropriate.
>
> The authors of at least one editor disagree with you there.
> Unless all of the possible
> values are applicable to all objects for which
On Mon, 19 Aug 2019 at 12:16, Warin <61sundow...@gmail.com> wrote:
That is a negative for me, I like property tags that can be used anywhere
> appropriate.
>
The authors of at least one editor disagree with you there. Unless all of
the possible
values are applicable to all objects for which
On Mon, 19 Aug 2019 at 11:21, Joseph Eisenberg
wrote:
> Landuse=meadow can be tagged with meadow=pasture or
> =paddock, but again this does not specify the type of animal in the
> pasture.
>
There are two problems with that statement.
1) In normal usage, a pasture is not a category of meadow.
On 19/08/19 20:17, Joseph Eisenberg wrote:
What is the best tag to specify the livestock animals in a farmyard or meadow?
I checked, and currently a number of farmyards are tagged with
farmyard=*, but most values describe the feature, like
farmyard=feedlot. Landuse=meadow can be tagged with
Le 19.08.19 à 12:17, Joseph Eisenberg a écrit :
> The tag animal=* has been 2137 times
> animal=yes (unhelpful!)
I wonder why it's useless.
if the contributor does not know if they are cows or calves,
this allows him to enter "there are farm animals there" and any
application can easily target
What is the best tag to specify the livestock animals in a farmyard or meadow?
I checked, and currently a number of farmyards are tagged with
farmyard=*, but most values describe the feature, like
farmyard=feedlot. Landuse=meadow can be tagged with meadow=pasture or
=paddock, but again this does
16 matches
Mail list logo
