Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-18 Thread News
You are correct, we are talking about unclassified and tertiary roads. Although this problem also occurs on secondary, primary and trunk roads, a classification is a measure of importance and not always quality. But where did the turning lane come from? or even lanes in many cases? Here is an

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-18 Thread Steve Doerr
On 18/06/2013 16:45, News wrote: You are correct, we are talking about unclassified and tertiary roads. Although this problem also occurs on secondary, primary and trunk roads, a classification is a measure of importance and not always quality. But where did the turning lane come from? or

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-18 Thread Philip Barnes
On Tue, 2013-06-18 at 16:50 +0100, Steve Doerr wrote: On 18/06/2013 16:45, News wrote: You are correct, we are talking about unclassified and tertiary roads. Although this problem also occurs on secondary, primary and trunk roads, a classification is a measure of importance and not

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-18 Thread Philip Barnes
On Tue, 2013-06-18 at 16:45 +0100, News wrote: You are correct, we are talking about unclassified and tertiary roads. Although this problem also occurs on secondary, primary and trunk roads, a classification is a measure of importance and not always quality. But where did the turning

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-18 Thread Johan C
For my Garmin both B5065 examples are routed correct by Mapsource. If the OSRM heuristics are wrong, than OSRM should get a ticket to make its engine better. Cheers, Johan 2013/6/18 Philip Barnes p...@trigpoint.me.uk On Tue, 2013-06-18 at 16:45 +0100, News wrote: You are correct, we are

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-18 Thread Philip Barnes
On Tue, 2013-06-18 at 19:23 +0200, Johan C wrote: For my Garmin both B5065 examples are routed correct by Mapsource. If the OSRM heuristics are wrong, than OSRM should get a ticket to make its engine better. That is just one of many examples, does this one work? http://osrm.at/3Is

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-18 Thread Johan C
No, it doesn't. Two reasons for that: 1. the road names in your example are wrong, see: http://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/oswebsite/opendata/viewer/ . If the correct road names are applied, the routing engine will know that one road is connected through an interchange to another road 2. it's

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-17 Thread fly
On 16.06.2013 22:50, Rob Nickerson wrote: @Rob: Did you ever try to describe the junction with the Lane and Road Attributes? No, I didn't. And as I've been busy with organising SOTM I didn't even fully read the tag proposal (hence I didn't vote). I hope you agree that my general comment about

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-17 Thread Philip Barnes
On Mon, 2013-06-17 at 17:35 +0200, fly wrote: On 16.06.2013 22:50, Rob Nickerson wrote: @Rob: Did you ever try to describe the junction with the Lane and Road Attributes? No, I didn't. And as I've been busy with organising SOTM I didn't even fully read the tag proposal (hence I didn't

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-16 Thread Rob Nickerson
@Rob: Did you ever try to describe the junction with the Lane and Road Attributes? No, I didn't. And as I've been busy with organising SOTM I didn't even fully read the tag proposal (hence I didn't vote). I hope you agree that my general comment about reading through and attempting to address the

[Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-15 Thread Rob Nickerson
Hi, The next steps with any tag proposal that reaches a hung jury is to read through the comments and update the proposal to address the issues raised. In this case I think the wiki page needs to be clearer about what this tag is for (a few photo/aerial image examples would help), and how it

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-15 Thread Eckhart Wörner
Hi Rob, Am Samstag, 15. Juni 2013, 13:33:24 schrieb Rob Nickerson: The next steps with any tag proposal that reaches a hung jury is to read through the comments and update the proposal to address the issues raised. In this case I think the wiki page needs to be clearer about what this tag

Re: [Tagging] Through_route next steps

2013-06-15 Thread fly
On 15.06.2013 17:00, Eckhart Wörner wrote: Hi Rob, Am Samstag, 15. Juni 2013, 13:33:24 schrieb Rob Nickerson: The next steps with any tag proposal that reaches a hung jury is to read through the comments and update the proposal to address the issues raised. In this case I think the wiki