Re: [Tagging] sport=shooting & Shooting Range

2015-04-13 Thread John Willis
That's true - because the proper tag for it was not created yet and this is a case of tagging for the renderer. A sports center may have an indoor range in a larger building, or the outdoor sports center is not mapped fully. But if it is sport=archery + leisure=pitch it should be changed to l

Re: [Tagging] sport=shooting & Shooting Range

2015-04-13 Thread Brad Neuhauser
I get your, er, point, although I don't think you would want to randomly wander into a batting cage or hockey rink in the middle of practice either. :) The bigger issue is there are over 1300 sport=archery tags, and both on the wiki and in actual usage, leisure=pitch (or sports_centre) is what's u

Re: [Tagging] sport=shooting & Shooting Range

2015-04-13 Thread John Willis
>> > I've usually seen leisure=pitch used with archery. Scanning through the few > features tagged with leisure=range, they appear to all be shooting ranges. > The only big difference between them is the noise level and the length of the projectile. They both have designated stands for the pe

Re: [Tagging] sport=shooting & Shooting Range

2015-04-13 Thread Brad Neuhauser
> > > Usually we have names for the area where things take place (pitch, track, > pool) and the sport (sport=*) > > A range is one of those places. Usually there are no mixed ranges (archery > and rifles, etc) are separate > > So leisure=range + sport=archery for an archery range or sport=shooting

Re: [Tagging] sport=shooting & Shooting Range

2015-04-12 Thread John Willis
> > I would tag > sport=shooting as an area for preference .. that being the physical area > where the shooting takes place. > It should be used with some other tag .. say leisure=pitch? Pity the wiki > does not specify it! Usually we have names for the area where things take place (pitch, trac

Re: [Tagging] sport=shooting & Shooting Range

2015-04-12 Thread Warin
On 13/04/2015 2:15 AM, Andreas Goss wrote: I had already looked at this in the past and stumbled on it again with paintball today. http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:sport%3Dshooting What's the best way to tag a shooting range? shooting=range make no sense to me. When sport= isn't a physi

Re: [Tagging] sport=shooting & Shooting Range

2015-04-12 Thread John Willis
There are archery ranges as well - do we want to follow the pitch model and have it defined by sport Leisure=range Sport=archery / sport=archery Or Leisure=archery_range Leisure=shooting_range ? FYI, these can be completely indoor facilities, so you should be able to put them on building=ye

Re: [Tagging] sport=shooting & Shooting Range

2015-04-12 Thread Janko Mihelić
+1 shooting=range looks uncompatible with anything I've seen. A tag that naturally comes to mind is leisure=shooting_range. There are onla 6 of those, compared to 145 shooting=range, but I think that tag is bad enough to deprecate it. Janko ned, 12. tra 2015. 18:17 Andreas Goss je napisao: > I

Re: [Tagging] sport=shooting & Shooting Range

2015-04-12 Thread John Willis
Leisure=range Sport=* Any place where you setup targets to practice marksmanship (with possibility of death if entered) should be a range. But maybe they are tying to pattern it after golf where the facilities and greens and whatnot are tagged as golf=* ~~~ Paintball would be... More similar

[Tagging] sport=shooting & Shooting Range

2015-04-12 Thread Andreas Goss
I had already looked at this in the past and stumbled on it again with paintball today. http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:sport%3Dshooting What's the best way to tag a shooting range? shooting=range make no sense to me. When sport= isn't a physical tag then how can a subtag be one? So sh