Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-16 Thread bkil
Thank you for the links. Note that the page about the selling options raises more questions than it answers (how common are the listed options?). While it is incidental that auction houses may also be equipped with a stockyard if they also hold livestock auctions, this is not a necessity for some

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-15 Thread Graeme Fitzpatrick
On Tue, 16 Apr 2019 at 06:52, bkil wrote: > Warin did not mention how they are purchased, i.e., whether an auction > is being held Yep, as mentioned previously, livestock are (almost ?) always sold via auction. Have a look at https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=2082183102010269 which shows a

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-15 Thread Warin
Typically these are auction sales. On 16/04/19 06:57, Kevin Kenny wrote: On Mon, Apr 15, 2019 at 4:52 PM bkil wrote: Compared to marketplaces, I think stockyards would be interesting to a lot less map users (probably only to contracted partners who regularly bring in livestock). Not to

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-15 Thread Kevin Kenny
On Mon, Apr 15, 2019 at 4:52 PM bkil wrote: > Compared to marketplaces, I think stockyards would be interesting to a > lot less map users (probably only to contracted partners who regularly > bring in livestock). Not to mention anyone who lives downwind!

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-15 Thread bkil
Warin did not mention how they are purchased, i.e., whether an auction is being held, or if only market haggling is being done. Assuming the latter, what has been said is still consistent with amenity=marketplace + marketplace=livestock. This sounds like a different feature:

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-15 Thread Tony Shield
Hi You seem to be describing a stockyard that is associated with an auction. Could these be relevant starters for tags? Tony On 15/04/2019 00:23, Warin wrote: In Australia commercial livestock (sheep, cattle) are sold through these livestock markets. They may be transported for several

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-14 Thread Warin
In Australia commercial livestock (sheep, cattle) are sold through these livestock markets. They may be transported for several days to get to the market, rested there before sale to recover from their trip. As such the market can be large with feeding etc. Once sold they are then

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-14 Thread bkil
In Hungary, market auctions do not exist. Instead you go to the livestock market, purchase some chicks, then go to the producers' market to grab some grain for them. Many markets are open to a little haggling, though. We de have online auctions and also some official ones related to liquidation

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-13 Thread Joseph Eisenberg
I saw that proposal, but it seems to be discussing auction houses that sell goods from estates, or collectibles, rather than a commodity auction. For a livestock auction, I would suggest using amenity=auction or amenity=auction_house with auction=livestock. But there do seem to be some

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-13 Thread Graeme Fitzpatrick
On Sun, 14 Apr 2019 at 11:40, Joseph Eisenberg wrote: > In the USA these often operate as auctions, > I think every livestock sale, anywhere, is done as an auction-type sale, with the particular animal / whole pen going to the highest bidder? (at least everyone I've seen, either in person or on

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-13 Thread Joseph Eisenberg
In the USA these often operate as auctions, but shop=auction is rarely used and doesn’t seem right. On Sun, Apr 14, 2019 at 4:45 AM bkil wrote: > I also have a need for this, so please share what scheme you come up > with, or you could even submit a proposal. I recommend this one: > >

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-13 Thread bkil
I also have a need for this, so please share what scheme you come up with, or you could even submit a proposal. I recommend this one: amenity=marketplace + marketplace=livestock + livestock=cattle;poultry;pig + opening_hours My second guess would be to use produce=cattle;poultry;pig, although

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-12 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
sent from a phone > On 11. Apr 2019, at 09:27, Philip Barnes wrote: > > Cattle Market, or Livestock Market are the British terms for these. what about the key, amenity? shop? man_made? “building” is about the building, not the feature (function), landuse is a property of the land. From

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-11 Thread Philip Barnes
Cattle Market, or Livestock Market are the British terms for these. Cattle Market is the more general term although the signs these days will say Livestock Market so that is probably the most accurate. Landuse I would have thought would be commercial. Phil (trigpoint) On Thursday, 11

Re: [Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-10 Thread Graeme Fitzpatrick
On Thu, 11 Apr 2019 at 13:58, Warin <61sundow...@gmail.com> wrote: > Any suggestions fora live stock sale yard? > > Not a farm. Don't really like landuse=commercial. > I put one in as building=industrial with description Stock Sales Yard as I couldn't find anything better :-(

[Tagging] tags for a live stock sale yard

2019-04-10 Thread Warin
Any suggestions fora live stock sale yard? Not a farm. Don't really like landuse=commercial. Way 532692207 is one. It really is associated with agriculture... ___ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org