Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Sergio Manzi]

I agree.

In Italy too there are so many different limits depending on "who you are" 
(/how fat your account is.../), in which bank you have your account and from 
which bank's ATM you are whitdrawning, per-account daily/monthly limits, etc.

And I really can't imagine _how one could know_ the ATM's absolute maximum 
whitdrawal limit (/unless you are a bank employee, maybe/)...

I see it hardly usable here...

Sergio


On 2019-02-25 11:44, Marc Gemis wrote:
> Any tagging proposal should make it very clear that it is the limit of
> the ATM. A tag that should not be used in Belgium.


smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Marc Gemis]

AFAIK, the limit in Belgium depends on the card. You can within
certain limits set by the issuer, change your limit. Furthermore,
there is a daily and weekly limit as well (see e.g.
https://www.kbc.be/particulieren/nl/product/betalen/betaalkaarten/bankkaarten/bankkaart.html
in Dutch).
Any tagging proposal should make it very clear that it is the limit of
the ATM. A tag that should not be used in Belgium.

Regarding fees, it depends on your account, the ATM you use, the brand
of the bank and the number of times you have used ATM's in a certain
period.

Banks and shops prefer that you pay with your debit or credit card in
the shop I think, that's why they make it more expensive to withdraw
money from an ATM.
More and more shops also offer payment via Smart Phones.

m.

On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 1:27 PM <0174  wrote:
>
> Hi,
>
> Frederik Ramm wrote:
> I'd say we stick to stuff that is explicitly signposted on the machine -
> if the machine says what the limit is or what the network is or what
> currencies it has, then map that, but don't map data gathered by
> interacting with the machine.
>
> one use case:
>
> I was recently in Nepal and the ATMs there have very low withdrawal limit (c. 
> 10,000 to 25,000 NPR, that is about 200 €) and always a fee. Withdrawing 
> larger sums of money i.e. for several weeks of trekking can get quite 
> expensive if one chooses an ATM with low limit.
> There are many ATMs in cities and towns, but since the limit is not written 
> on the ATM, the only was to find the good ones is to use them (and to risk 
> losing your card).
>
> That's one reason why I would suggest to not dismiss tagging with info taken 
> from interacting with the ATM. I suppose sometimes the max. amount can differ 
> based on the card issuer, but I believe we should reflect such cases in the 
> tagging scheme. Sometimes there is no other way and this information could 
> help a lot.
>
> <0174
>
>
> čt 14. 2. 2019 v 12:52 odesílatel Joseph Eisenberg 
>  napsal:
>>
>> Here in Indonesia the ATMs are universally limited to dispensing no more 
>> than 25 bills, and they only offer one type. So you can get 2,500,000 in one 
>> withdrawal if they dispense 100,000 Rupiah bills, or 125 if they 
>> dispense 50k bills.
>>
>> The size of bill dispensed is often shown on a sticker (at least for newer 
>> ATMs)
>>
>> (100,000 rupiah converts to about $7 US)
>> On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 5:08 PM seirra blake  
>> wrote:
>>>
>>> some providers already make it publicly available knowledge. for example in 
>>> the UK link ATM has an app, and you can use it to find nearby ATMs. most of 
>>> the things it tells you are pretty standard, but some things that may need 
>>> new tags are pin management services, audio assistance and £5 notes 
>>> (because otherwise you're limited to denominations of 10). I was thinking 
>>> with these tags included, link ATM may feel encouraged to import their data 
>>> and maintain it on OSM allowing them to save costs on their end and have a 
>>> more detailed map. when I tried proposing minimum denominations before on 
>>> here though it got shot down very fast.
>>>
>>> On 2/14/19 7:17 AM, Colin Smale wrote:
>>>
>>> Tagging min and max withdrawals on the ATM is asking for confusion. The 
>>> normal limits are set by the card issuer, and I can see many people 
>>> mistakenly putting their personal card limits into these tags on the ATM.
>>>
>>> More relevant here would be the denomination mix. ATMs have a fixed number 
>>> of canisters (maybe 2/3/4), each of which can hold a single type of note. 
>>> Which denominations are loaded depends on historical usage patterns. 
>>> Stocking low denomination notes might be good for user convenience, but bad 
>>> for the possibility of running out of money in a busy location. Knowing the 
>>> normal mix for a particular ATM, in particular the smallest denomination, 
>>> is useful for knowing which amounts can be dispensed, and which not.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> So instead of min_withdrawal on the ATM, I would suggest min_denomination.
>>>
>>> In the case of multi-currency ATMs there will need to be a 
>>> currency-specific variant, like min_denomination:EUR=20
>>>
>>> Problem is, it will probably require data from multiple transactions from 
>>> small to large to work out the mix and we need to keep mappers merging the 
>>> data from their experience, and not overwriting the valid data from a 
>>> previous ATM user, while recognising that the denomination mix can change, 
>>> even according to the days of the week (weekends might be different to 
>>> weekdays in city centres).
>>>
>>> On 2019-02-14 07:29, OSMDoudou wrote:
>>>
>>> The minimum can also differ.
>>>
>>> Some banks allow their young customers to withdraw small amounts, like 5 
>>> EUR, whereas adults and even young customers with cards from other banks 
>>> will not be allowed to withdraw less than 20 EUR.
>>>
>>> So, it may create confusion between mappers because what you see as options 
>>> on the 

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[<0174]

Hi,

Frederik Ramm wrote:




*I'd say we stick to stuff that is explicitly signposted on the machine -
if the machine says what the limit is or what the network is or what
currencies it has, then map that, but don't map data gathered by
interacting with the machine. *

one use case:

I was recently in Nepal and the ATMs there have very low withdrawal limit
(c. 10,000 to 25,000 NPR, that is about 200 €) and always a fee.
Withdrawing larger sums of money i.e. for several weeks of trekking can get
quite expensive if one chooses an ATM with low limit.
There are many ATMs in cities and towns, but since the limit is not written
on the ATM, the only was to find the good ones is to use them (and to risk
losing your card).

That's one reason why I would suggest to not dismiss tagging with info
taken from interacting with the ATM. I suppose sometimes the max. amount
can differ based on the card issuer, but I believe we should reflect such
cases in the tagging scheme. Sometimes there is no other way and this
information could help a lot.

<0174


čt 14. 2. 2019 v 12:52 odesílatel Joseph Eisenberg <
joseph.eisenb...@gmail.com> napsal:

> Here in Indonesia the ATMs are universally limited to dispensing no more
> than 25 bills, and they only offer one type. So you can get 2,500,000 in
> one withdrawal if they dispense 100,000 Rupiah bills, or 125 if they
> dispense 50k bills.
>
> The size of bill dispensed is often shown on a sticker (at least for newer
> ATMs)
>
> (100,000 rupiah converts to about $7 US)
> On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 5:08 PM seirra blake 
> wrote:
>
>> some providers already make it publicly available knowledge. for example
>> in the UK link ATM has an app, and you can use it to find nearby ATMs. most
>> of the things it tells you are pretty standard, but some things that may
>> need new tags are pin management services, audio assistance and £5 notes
>> (because otherwise you're limited to denominations of 10). I was thinking
>> with these tags included, link ATM may feel encouraged to import their data
>> and maintain it on OSM allowing them to save costs on their end and have a
>> more detailed map. when I tried proposing minimum denominations before on
>> here though it got shot down very fast.
>> On 2/14/19 7:17 AM, Colin Smale wrote:
>>
>> Tagging min and max withdrawals on the ATM is asking for confusion. The
>> normal limits are set by the card issuer, and I can see many people
>> mistakenly putting their personal card limits into these tags on the ATM.
>>
>> More relevant here would be the denomination mix. ATMs have a fixed
>> number of canisters (maybe 2/3/4), each of which can hold a single type of
>> note. Which denominations are loaded depends on historical usage patterns.
>> Stocking low denomination notes might be good for user convenience, but bad
>> for the possibility of running out of money in a busy location. Knowing the
>> normal mix for a particular ATM, in particular the smallest denomination,
>> is useful for knowing which amounts can be dispensed, and which not.
>>
>>
>> So instead of min_withdrawal on the ATM, I would suggest min_denomination.
>>
>> In the case of multi-currency ATMs there will need to be a
>> currency-specific variant, like min_denomination:EUR=20
>>
>> Problem is, it will probably require data from multiple transactions from
>> small to large to work out the mix and we need to keep mappers merging the
>> data from their experience, and not overwriting the valid data from a
>> previous ATM user, while recognising that the denomination mix can change,
>> even according to the days of the week (weekends might be different to
>> weekdays in city centres).
>>
>> On 2019-02-14 07:29, OSMDoudou wrote:
>>
>> The minimum can also differ.
>>
>> Some banks allow their young customers to withdraw small amounts, like 5
>> EUR, whereas adults and even young customers with cards from other banks
>> will not be allowed to withdraw less than 20 EUR.
>>
>> So, it may create confusion between mappers because what you see as
>> options on the ATM may depend on your card and your affiliation with the
>> bank.
>>
>> This impairs verifiability on the ground of the information.
>> On 2/14/19, 03:45 Warin <61sundow...@gmail.com> <61sundow...@gmail.com>
>> wrote:
>>>
>>> The maximum may also be limited by the card provider. Need some careful
>>> words on the proposal to say it is the limit of the ATM provider.
>>>
>>>
>>> On 14/02/19 13:31, Joseph Eisenberg wrote:
>>>
>>> Withdrawals are not the only type of ATM transaction.
>>>
>>>
>>> So use
>>> withdraw_min=*
>>> withdraw_max=
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> ** ??? *The currency is set by some other tag that I forget now. That
>>> needs to be mentioned in the proposal.
>>> As a user .. I have no idea what the limits are. I suspect I may know
>>> the lower limit, but not the upper.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Perhaps max_withdrawal would be clearer?
>>> On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 10:57 AM Nathan Wyand <
>>> propaga...@nathanwyand.com> wrote:
>>>
 Hello 

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Joseph Eisenberg]

Here in Indonesia the ATMs are universally limited to dispensing no more
than 25 bills, and they only offer one type. So you can get 2,500,000 in
one withdrawal if they dispense 100,000 Rupiah bills, or 125 if they
dispense 50k bills.

The size of bill dispensed is often shown on a sticker (at least for newer
ATMs)

(100,000 rupiah converts to about $7 US)
On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 5:08 PM seirra blake 
wrote:

> some providers already make it publicly available knowledge. for example
> in the UK link ATM has an app, and you can use it to find nearby ATMs. most
> of the things it tells you are pretty standard, but some things that may
> need new tags are pin management services, audio assistance and £5 notes
> (because otherwise you're limited to denominations of 10). I was thinking
> with these tags included, link ATM may feel encouraged to import their data
> and maintain it on OSM allowing them to save costs on their end and have a
> more detailed map. when I tried proposing minimum denominations before on
> here though it got shot down very fast.
> On 2/14/19 7:17 AM, Colin Smale wrote:
>
> Tagging min and max withdrawals on the ATM is asking for confusion. The
> normal limits are set by the card issuer, and I can see many people
> mistakenly putting their personal card limits into these tags on the ATM.
>
> More relevant here would be the denomination mix. ATMs have a fixed number
> of canisters (maybe 2/3/4), each of which can hold a single type of note.
> Which denominations are loaded depends on historical usage patterns.
> Stocking low denomination notes might be good for user convenience, but bad
> for the possibility of running out of money in a busy location. Knowing the
> normal mix for a particular ATM, in particular the smallest denomination,
> is useful for knowing which amounts can be dispensed, and which not.
>
>
> So instead of min_withdrawal on the ATM, I would suggest min_denomination.
>
> In the case of multi-currency ATMs there will need to be a
> currency-specific variant, like min_denomination:EUR=20
>
> Problem is, it will probably require data from multiple transactions from
> small to large to work out the mix and we need to keep mappers merging the
> data from their experience, and not overwriting the valid data from a
> previous ATM user, while recognising that the denomination mix can change,
> even according to the days of the week (weekends might be different to
> weekdays in city centres).
>
> On 2019-02-14 07:29, OSMDoudou wrote:
>
> The minimum can also differ.
>
> Some banks allow their young customers to withdraw small amounts, like 5
> EUR, whereas adults and even young customers with cards from other banks
> will not be allowed to withdraw less than 20 EUR.
>
> So, it may create confusion between mappers because what you see as
> options on the ATM may depend on your card and your affiliation with the
> bank.
>
> This impairs verifiability on the ground of the information.
> On 2/14/19, 03:45 Warin <61sundow...@gmail.com> <61sundow...@gmail.com>
> wrote:
>>
>> The maximum may also be limited by the card provider. Need some careful
>> words on the proposal to say it is the limit of the ATM provider.
>>
>>
>> On 14/02/19 13:31, Joseph Eisenberg wrote:
>>
>> Withdrawals are not the only type of ATM transaction.
>>
>>
>> So use
>> withdraw_min=*
>> withdraw_max=
>>
>>
>>
>> ** ??? *The currency is set by some other tag that I forget now. That
>> needs to be mentioned in the proposal.
>> As a user .. I have no idea what the limits are. I suspect I may know the
>> lower limit, but not the upper.
>>
>>
>>
>> Perhaps max_withdrawal would be clearer?
>> On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 10:57 AM Nathan Wyand 
>> wrote:
>>
>>> Hello mappers,
>>>
>>> I frequently use OSM to find ATM's near me, but many of these machines
>>> place limits on how much can be withdrawn in 1 transaction. This can make
>>> it inconvenient and expensive to withdraw money, requiring several
>>> transactions. Another issue is that many machines only carry $20 notes,
>>> which forces people to withdraw more or less than they actually desire. I
>>> am considering two tags for use alongside 'amenity=atm':
>>>
>>> *min_transaction* (the minimum amount of cash that can be withdrawn in
>>> one transaction...typically the smallest denomination of notes in the
>>> machine)
>>> *max _transaction* (the maximum amount of cash that can be withdrawn in
>>> one transaction)
>>>
>>> This is my first time proposing a tag, and I would love to hear your
>>> input and and advice. Thank you!
>>>
>>> -Nathan
>>> ___
>>> Tagging mailing list
>>> Tagging@openstreetmap.org
>>> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
>>
>>
>>
>> ___
>> Tagging mailing 
>> listTagging@openstreetmap.orghttps://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
>>
>>
>> ___ Tagging mailing list
>> Tagging@openstreetmap.org
>> 

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[seirra blake]

some providers already make it publicly available knowledge. for example 
in the UK link ATM has an app, and you can use it to find nearby ATMs. 
most of the things it tells you are pretty standard, but some things 
that may need new tags are pin management services, audio assistance and 
£5 notes (because otherwise you're limited to denominations of 10). I 
was thinking with these tags included, link ATM may feel encouraged to 
import their data and maintain it on OSM allowing them to save costs on 
their end and have a more detailed map. when I tried proposing minimum 
denominations before on here though it got shot down very fast.


On 2/14/19 7:17 AM, Colin Smale wrote:


Tagging min and max withdrawals on the ATM is asking for confusion. 
The normal limits are set by the card issuer, and I can see many 
people mistakenly putting their personal card limits into these tags 
on the ATM.


More relevant here would be the denomination mix. ATMs have a fixed 
number of canisters (maybe 2/3/4), each of which can hold a single 
type of note. Which denominations are loaded depends on historical 
usage patterns. Stocking low denomination notes might be good for user 
convenience, but bad for the possibility of running out of money in a 
busy location. Knowing the normal mix for a particular ATM, in 
particular the smallest denomination, is useful for knowing which 
amounts can be dispensed, and which not.


So instead of min_withdrawal on the ATM, I would suggest min_denomination.

In the case of multi-currency ATMs there will need to be a 
currency-specific variant, like min_denomination:EUR=20


Problem is, it will probably require data from multiple transactions 
from small to large to work out the mix and we need to keep mappers 
merging the data from their experience, and not overwriting the valid 
data from a previous ATM user, while recognising that the denomination 
mix can change, even according to the days of the week (weekends might 
be different to weekdays in city centres).


On 2019-02-14 07:29, OSMDoudou wrote:


The minimum can also differ.

Some banks allow their young customers to withdraw small amounts, 
like 5 EUR, whereas adults and even young customers with cards from 
other banks will not be allowed to withdraw less than 20 EUR.


So, it may create confusion between mappers because what you see as 
options on the ATM may depend on your card and your affiliation with 
the bank.


This impairs verifiability on the ground of the information.
On 2/14/19, 03:45 Warin <61sundow...@gmail.com> wrote:

The maximum may also be limited by the card provider. Need some
careful words on the proposal to say it is the limit of the ATM
provider.


On 14/02/19 13:31, Joseph Eisenberg wrote:
Withdrawals are not the only type of ATM transaction. 


So use
withdraw_min=*
withdraw_max=/*

???

/The currency is set by some other tag that I forget now. That
needs to be mentioned in the proposal.
As a user .. I have no idea what the limits are. I suspect I may
know the lower limit, but not the upper.




Perhaps max_withdrawal would be clearer?
On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 10:57 AM Nathan Wyand
mailto:propaga...@nathanwyand.com>>
wrote:

Hello mappers,

I frequently use OSM to find ATM's near me, but many of
these machines place limits on how much can be withdrawn in
1 transaction. This can make it inconvenient and expensive
to withdraw money, requiring several transactions. Another
issue is that many machines only carry $20 notes, which
forces people to withdraw more or less than they actually
desire. I am considering two tags for use alongside
'amenity=atm':

*min_transaction* (the minimum amount of cash that can be
withdrawn in one transaction...typically the smallest
denomination of notes in the machine)
*max _transaction* (the maximum amount of cash that can be
withdrawn in one transaction)

This is my first time proposing a tag, and I would love to
hear your input and and advice. Thank you!

-Nathan
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org 
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging



___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging



___ Tagging mailing
list Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging


___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org 
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging


___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Colin Smale]

On 2019-02-14 08:35, Joseph Eisenberg wrote:

> I'm surprised to hear this about ATMs in Europe. 
> 
> In Southeast Asia and in the USA, usually the ATM will only allow a certain 
> max withdrawal. It's also uncommon to have more than one denomination (though 
> some do have 2 types).
> 
> Perhaps this tag can't be used in all countries, but it could still be useful 
> in places where the ATM itself has a max withdrawal limit.

The ATM itself does have a maximum withdrawal amount. Apart from any
financial limits it will have a limit on the number of notes to be
issued in a single withdrawal (typically 40), as there are mechanical
limitations within the device. The maximum amount is therefore
determined by the cassette mix and should not be expressed as a currency
amount.___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Colin Smale]

On 2019-02-14 08:28, Martin Koppenhoefer wrote:

> Am Do., 14. Feb. 2019 um 08:19 Uhr schrieb Colin Smale 
> : 
> 
>> Tagging min and max withdrawals on the ATM is asking for confusion. The 
>> normal limits are set by the card issuer,
> 
> by the network. Most (?) cards nowadays can use several different networks, 
> some atms ask which one you want to use.

The network may have limits for fraud management purposes, but normally
it's the card issuer (bank) who sets the limits. They could actually be
set at the level of the individual card. Some issuers might allow you to
choose your own limits, within certain boundaries, so you can manage
your own exposure. 

However if the ATM cannot connect to the card issuer for whatever
reason, stand-in authorisation and limits may kick in at various levels,
or the transaction might be rejected anyway. 

Where you are offered a choice of accounts/networks to use, that
information is held on the card itself (in the chip). The chip can be
programmed with multiple "applications" and the terminal is free to
offer a choice where it is able to process more than one.___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Frederik Ramm]

Hi,

On 14.02.19 08:17, Colin Smale wrote:
> Problem is, it will probably require data from multiple transactions
> from small to large to work out the mix

That's what I see as an issue too. Something that is only verifiable if
you are a customer and can make a large number of withdrawals to test,
stretches our concept of verifiable. If I don't get a specific
denomination from the machine, or if I am set an upper limit for my
withdrawal, will another person experience the same on the next day,
when they have more money on their account and the machine has been
refilled in the mean time?

I'd say we stick to stuff that is explicitly signposted on the machine -
if the machine says what the limit is or what the network is or what
currencies it has, then map that, but don't map data gathered by
interacting with the machine.

Bye
Frederik

-- 
Frederik Ramm  ##  eMail frede...@remote.org  ##  N49°00'09" E008°23'33"

___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Joseph Eisenberg]

I’m surprised to hear this about ATMs in Europe.

In Southeast Asia and in the USA, usually the ATM will only allow a certain
max withdrawal. It’s also uncommon to have more than one denomination
(though some do have 2 types).

Perhaps this tag can’t be used in all countries, but it could still be
useful in places where the ATM itself has a max withdrawal limit.
On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 4:29 PM Martin Koppenhoefer 
wrote:

>
>
> Am Do., 14. Feb. 2019 um 08:19 Uhr schrieb Colin Smale <
> colin.sm...@xs4all.nl>:
>
>> Tagging min and max withdrawals on the ATM is asking for confusion. The
>> normal limits are set by the card issuer,
>>
>
> by the network. Most (?) cards nowadays can use several different
> networks, some atms ask which one you want to use.
>
> Cheers,
> Martin
>
> ___
> Tagging mailing list
> Tagging@openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
>
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Martin Koppenhoefer]

Am Do., 14. Feb. 2019 um 08:19 Uhr schrieb Colin Smale <
colin.sm...@xs4all.nl>:

> Tagging min and max withdrawals on the ATM is asking for confusion. The
> normal limits are set by the card issuer,
>

by the network. Most (?) cards nowadays can use several different networks,
some atms ask which one you want to use.

Cheers,
Martin
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Colin Smale]

Tagging min and max withdrawals on the ATM is asking for confusion. The
normal limits are set by the card issuer, and I can see many people
mistakenly putting their personal card limits into these tags on the
ATM. 

More relevant here would be the denomination mix. ATMs have a fixed
number of canisters (maybe 2/3/4), each of which can hold a single type
of note. Which denominations are loaded depends on historical usage
patterns. Stocking low denomination notes might be good for user
convenience, but bad for the possibility of running out of money in a
busy location. Knowing the normal mix for a particular ATM, in
particular the smallest denomination, is useful for knowing which
amounts can be dispensed, and which not.

So instead of min_withdrawal on the ATM, I would suggest
min_denomination. 

In the case of multi-currency ATMs there will need to be a
currency-specific variant, like min_denomination:EUR=20 

Problem is, it will probably require data from multiple transactions
from small to large to work out the mix and we need to keep mappers
merging the data from their experience, and not overwriting the valid
data from a previous ATM user, while recognising that the denomination
mix can change, even according to the days of the week (weekends might
be different to weekdays in city centres). 

On 2019-02-14 07:29, OSMDoudou wrote:

> The minimum can also differ.
> 
> Some banks allow their young customers to withdraw small amounts, like 5 EUR, 
> whereas adults and even young customers with cards from other banks will not 
> be allowed to withdraw less than 20 EUR.
> 
> So, it may create confusion between mappers because what you see as options 
> on the ATM may depend on your card and your affiliation with the bank. 
> 
> This impairs verifiability on the ground of the information.
> 
> On 2/14/19, 03:45 Warin <61sundow...@gmail.com> wrote: 
> The maximum may also be limited by the card provider. Need some careful words 
> on the proposal to say it is the limit of the ATM provider. 
> 
> On 14/02/19 13:31, Joseph Eisenberg wrote: Withdrawals are not the only type 
> of ATM transaction. 
> So use 
> withdraw_min=*
> withdraw_max=*
> 
> ???
> 
> The currency is set by some other tag that I forget now. That needs to be 
> mentioned in the proposal. 
> As a user .. I have no idea what the limits are. I suspect I may know the 
> lower limit, but not the upper. 
> 
> Perhaps max_withdrawal would be clearer?
> 
> On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 10:57 AM Nathan Wyand  
> wrote: 
> Hello mappers,
> 
> I frequently use OSM to find ATM's near me, but many of these machines place 
> limits on how much can be withdrawn in 1 transaction. This can make it 
> inconvenient and expensive to withdraw money, requiring several transactions. 
> Another issue is that many machines only carry $20 notes, which forces people 
> to withdraw more or less than they actually desire. I am considering two tags 
> for use alongside 'amenity=atm':
> 
> MIN_TRANSACTION (the minimum amount of cash that can be withdrawn in one 
> transaction...typically the smallest denomination of notes in the machine)
> MAX _TRANSACTION (the maximum amount of cash that can be withdrawn in one 
> transaction)
> 
> This is my first time proposing a tag, and I would love to hear your input 
> and and advice. Thank you!
> 
> -Nathan ___
> Tagging mailing list
> Tagging@openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging 
> 
> ___
> Tagging mailing list
> Tagging@openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

 ___ Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging 
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Warin]

On 14/02/19 17:40, Martin Koppenhoefer wrote:



sent from a phone


On 14. Feb 2019, at 07:29, OSMDoudou 
<19b350d2-b1b3-4edb-ad96-288ea1238...@gmx.com> wrote:

The minimum can also differ.

Some banks allow their young customers to withdraw small amounts, like 5 EUR, 
whereas adults and even young customers with cards from other banks will not be 
allowed to withdraw less than 20 EUR.


the minimum also depends on the notes that are currently available, if the atm 
has issued all its 20 eur notes you will have 50 as a minimum (in an atm that 
has no 5 or 10 eur bank notes).


The maximum also depends on the amount of money remaining...
asking for 500 and getting 10 * 50 is fine  getting 20*20 gets very bulky 
and the machine has then run out of money...


___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Martin Koppenhoefer]

sent from a phone

> On 14. Feb 2019, at 07:29, OSMDoudou 
> <19b350d2-b1b3-4edb-ad96-288ea1238...@gmx.com> wrote:
> 
> The minimum can also differ.
> 
> Some banks allow their young customers to withdraw small amounts, like 5 EUR, 
> whereas adults and even young customers with cards from other banks will not 
> be allowed to withdraw less than 20 EUR.


the minimum also depends on the notes that are currently available, if the atm 
has issued all its 20 eur notes you will have 50 as a minimum (in an atm that 
has no 5 or 10 eur bank notes).

Cheers, Martin 
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[OSMDoudou]

The minimum can also differ.

Some banks allow their young customers to withdraw small amounts, like 5 EUR, whereas adults and even young customers with cards from other banks will not be allowed to withdraw less than 20 EUR.

So, it may create confusion between mappers because what you see as options on the ATM may depend on your card and your affiliation with the bank. 

This impairs verifiability on the ground of the information.

On 2/14/19, 03:45 Warin <61sundow...@gmail.com> wrote:

  
The maximum may also be limited by the
  card provider. Need some careful words on the proposal to say it
  is the limit of the ATM provider. 
  
  
  On 14/02/19 13:31, Joseph Eisenberg wrote:


  
  Withdrawals are not the only type of ATM transaction. 


So use 
withdraw_min=*
withdraw_max=*

???

  The currency is set by some other tag that I forget now. That
  needs to be mentioned in the proposal. 
  As a user .. I have no idea what the limits are. I suspect I may
  know the lower limit, but not the upper. 
  
  
  

  Perhaps max_withdrawal would be clearer?
  
On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 10:57 AM Nathan Wyand
  
  wrote:


   Hello mappers,

I frequently use OSM to find ATM's near me, but many of
these machines place limits on how much can be withdrawn in
1 transaction. This can make it inconvenient and expensive
to withdraw money, requiring several transactions. Another
issue is that many machines only carry $20 notes, which
forces people to withdraw more or less than they actually
desire. I am considering two tags for use alongside
'amenity=atm':

min_transaction (the minimum amount of cash that can
be withdrawn in one transaction...typically the smallest
denomination of notes in the machine)
max _transaction (the maximum amount of cash that can
be withdrawn in one transaction)

This is my first time proposing a tag, and I would love to
hear your input and and advice. Thank you!

-Nathan
  
  ___
  Tagging mailing list
  Tagging@openstreetmap.org
  https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

  
  
  
  
  ___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging




  
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging


___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Nathan Wyand]

So I think I'm on board with using withdraw/withdrawal as opposed to 
transaction. The reason I formatted it as 'max_???' and 'min_???' is 
because there are already two tags in use with that ordering.


I would also be sure to clarify that the limits are imposed by the ATM 
provider and not the card provider.


Putting '$20' in my initial message was just for example, and the value 
should always be a plain integer.


On 02/13/2019 09:45 PM, Warin wrote:
The maximum may also be limited by the card provider. Need some 
careful words on the proposal to say it is the limit of the ATM provider.



On 14/02/19 13:31, Joseph Eisenberg wrote:

Withdrawals are not the only type of ATM transaction.


So use
withdraw_min=*
withdraw_max=/*

???

/The currency is set by some other tag that I forget now. That needs 
to be mentioned in the proposal.
As a user .. I have no idea what the limits are. I suspect I may know 
the lower limit, but not the upper.



//


Perhaps max_withdrawal would be clearer?
On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 10:57 AM Nathan Wyand 
mailto:propaga...@nathanwyand.com>> wrote:


Hello mappers,

I frequently use OSM to find ATM's near me, but many of these
machines place limits on how much can be withdrawn in 1
transaction. This can make it inconvenient and expensive to
withdraw money, requiring several transactions. Another issue is
that many machines only carry $20 notes, which forces people to
withdraw more or less than they actually desire. I am considering
two tags for use alongside 'amenity=atm':

*min_transaction* (the minimum amount of cash that can be
withdrawn in one transaction...typically the smallest
denomination of notes in the machine)
*max _transaction* (the maximum amount of cash that can be
withdrawn in one transaction)

This is my first time proposing a tag, and I would love to hear
your input and and advice. Thank you!

-Nathan
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org 
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging



___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging





___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging


___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Warin]

The maximum may also be limited by the card provider. Need some careful 
words on the proposal to say it is the limit of the ATM provider.



On 14/02/19 13:31, Joseph Eisenberg wrote:

Withdrawals are not the only type of ATM transaction.


So use
withdraw_min=*
withdraw_max=/*

???

/The currency is set by some other tag that I forget now. That needs to 
be mentioned in the proposal.
As a user .. I have no idea what the limits are. I suspect I may know 
the lower limit, but not the upper.



//


Perhaps max_withdrawal would be clearer?
On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 10:57 AM Nathan Wyand 
mailto:propaga...@nathanwyand.com>> wrote:


Hello mappers,

I frequently use OSM to find ATM's near me, but many of these
machines place limits on how much can be withdrawn in 1
transaction. This can make it inconvenient and expensive to
withdraw money, requiring several transactions. Another issue is
that many machines only carry $20 notes, which forces people to
withdraw more or less than they actually desire. I am considering
two tags for use alongside 'amenity=atm':

*min_transaction* (the minimum amount of cash that can be
withdrawn in one transaction...typically the smallest denomination
of notes in the machine)
*max _transaction* (the maximum amount of cash that can be
withdrawn in one transaction)

This is my first time proposing a tag, and I would love to hear
your input and and advice. Thank you!

-Nathan
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org 
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging



___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging



___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Re: [Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Joseph Eisenberg]

Withdrawals are not the only type of ATM transaction.

Perhaps max_withdrawal would be clearer?
On Thu, Feb 14, 2019 at 10:57 AM Nathan Wyand 
wrote:

> Hello mappers,
>
> I frequently use OSM to find ATM's near me, but many of these machines
> place limits on how much can be withdrawn in 1 transaction. This can make
> it inconvenient and expensive to withdraw money, requiring several
> transactions. Another issue is that many machines only carry $20 notes,
> which forces people to withdraw more or less than they actually desire. I
> am considering two tags for use alongside 'amenity=atm':
>
> *min_transaction* (the minimum amount of cash that can be withdrawn in
> one transaction...typically the smallest denomination of notes in the
> machine)
> *max _transaction* (the maximum amount of cash that can be withdrawn in
> one transaction)
>
> This is my first time proposing a tag, and I would love to hear your input
> and and advice. Thank you!
>
> -Nathan
> ___
> Tagging mailing list
> Tagging@openstreetmap.org
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
>
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

[Tagging] transaction parameters for ATMs

[Nathan Wyand]

Hello mappers,

I frequently use OSM to find ATM's near me, but many of these machines 
place limits on how much can be withdrawn in 1 transaction. This can 
make it inconvenient and expensive to withdraw money, requiring several 
transactions. Another issue is that many machines only carry $20 notes, 
which forces people to withdraw more or less than they actually desire. 
I am considering two tags for use alongside 'amenity=atm':


*min_transaction* (the minimum amount of cash that can be withdrawn in 
one transaction...typically the smallest denomination of notes in the 
machine)
*max _transaction* (the maximum amount of cash that can be withdrawn in 
one transaction)


This is my first time proposing a tag, and I would love to hear your 
input and and advice. Thank you!


-Nathan
___
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging