Re: [OSM-talk] POIs from wikipedia

2008-01-10 Thread Nic Roets
This problem can elegantly be solved as a layer on the output e.g. a hyperlink / ballon on web based map. OSM only need to indicate which nodes already has wikipedia entries and what their identifiers are. Then we can prevent duplicates from being rendered. I suspect the most likely explanation

Re: [OSM-talk] POIs from wikipedia

2008-01-09 Thread Gervase Markham
Frederik Ramm wrote: Well no matter where they came from, being Wikipedia they're GNU FDL and if we incorporated them we'd have to switch to GNU FDL as well, at least that's how I read virulent licenses. Wikipedia are working with the FSF to make the FDL compatible with CC-BY-SA 3. I expect

Re: [OSM-talk] POIs from wikipedia

2008-01-09 Thread Robin Paulson
On 08/01/2008, Richard Fairhurst [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: while i was looking up some info on wikipedia [1], i noticed that a lot of pages have a lat/lon value to describe their location; this strikes me as something we could use to increase the amount of data in OSM These are almost

Re: [OSM-talk] POIs from wikipedia

2008-01-09 Thread Richard Fairhurst
Robin Paulson wrote: [co-ordinates on Wikipedia] On 08/01/2008, Richard Fairhurst [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: These are almost certainly derived from Google Maps et al, therefore unsuitable for OSM. really, that sounds like it would contravene wikipedia's rules and google's terms of use?

Re: [OSM-talk] POIs from wikipedia

2008-01-09 Thread Robin Paulson
On 10/01/2008, Richard Fairhurst [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: [co-ordinates on Wikipedia] really, that sounds like it would contravene wikipedia's rules and google's terms of use? and is it our responsibility to pre-guess what wp editors are doing? i think taking their data at face value is

[OSM-talk] POIs from wikipedia

2008-01-07 Thread Robin Paulson
while i was looking up some info on wikipedia [1], i noticed that a lot of pages have a lat/lon value to describe their location; this strikes me as something we could use to increase the amount of data in OSM it would require a mass download of data from all the pages that contain these values,

Re: [OSM-talk] POIs from wikipedia

2008-01-07 Thread Robin Paulson
On 08/01/2008, Robin Paulson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: while i was looking up some info on wikipedia [1], i noticed that a lot of pages have a lat/lon value to describe their location; this strikes me as something we could use to increase the amount of data in OSM it would require a mass

Re: [OSM-talk] POIs from wikipedia

2008-01-07 Thread Richard Fairhurst
Robin Paulson wrote: while i was looking up some info on wikipedia [1], i noticed that a lot of pages have a lat/lon value to describe their location; this strikes me as something we could use to increase the amount of data in OSM These are almost certainly derived from Google Maps et al,

Re: [OSM-talk] POIs from wikipedia

2008-01-07 Thread Anselm Hook
Maybe somebody should start the pragmatic street maps project - a On Jan 7, 2008 2:41 PM, Richard Fairhurst [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Robin Paulson wrote: while i was looking up some info on wikipedia [1], i noticed that a lot of pages have a lat/lon value to describe their location;

Re: [OSM-talk] POIs from wikipedia

2008-01-07 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, These are almost certainly derived from Google Maps et al, therefore unsuitable for OSM. Well no matter where they came from, being Wikipedia they're GNU FDL and if we incorporated them we'd have to switch to GNU FDL as well, at least that's how I read virulent licenses. Bye Frederik