Re: [OSM-talk] undiscussed (?) mechanical edit on diet:vegan and diet:vegetarian

2014-05-21 Thread John Packer
I would question whether vegan or vegetarian are types of cuisine. You can have vegetarian restaurants serving very different cuisines, tagging such as cuisine=indian diet=vegetarian, cuisine=british diet=vegetarian. If you use cuisine=vegetarian then you loose that important information.

Re: [OSM-talk] undiscussed (?) mechanical edit on diet:vegan and diet:vegetarian

2014-05-21 Thread SomeoneElse
John Packer wrote: The tags cuisine=vegetarian and cuisine=vegan are already explicitly deprecated. Says who? People who edit the wiki or people who edit the map? Any change to previously-used keys needs to be talked about in public so that someone who's got a map that depends on the

[OSM-talk] undiscussed (?) mechanical edit on diet:vegan and diet:vegetarian

2014-05-21 Thread John Packer
Andy wrote: John Packer wrote: The tags cuisine=vegetarian and cuisine=vegan are already explicitly deprecated. Says who? People who edit the wiki or people who edit the map? Any change to previously-used keys needs to be talked about in public so that someone who's got a map that

[OSM-talk] undiscussed (?) mechanical edit on diet:vegan and diet:vegetarian

2014-05-20 Thread Michael Reichert
Hi, I have discovered a mechanical edit of 100 restaurants worldwide by user BuganiniQ. https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/22303143 comment=update diet:vegen/diet:vegetarian: set to only according to cuisine; remove redundant tags created_by=osmapi/0.2.24 Has this edit been discussed

Re: [OSM-talk] undiscussed (?) mechanical edit on diet:vegan and diet:vegetarian

2014-05-20 Thread SomeoneElse
Michael Reichert wrote: Hi, I have discovered a mechanical edit of 100 restaurants worldwide by user BuganiniQ. https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/22303143 comment=update diet:vegen/diet:vegetarian: set to only according to cuisine; remove redundant tags created_by=osmapi/0.2.24 Has this

Re: [OSM-talk] undiscussed (?) mechanical edit on diet:vegan and diet:vegetarian

2014-05-20 Thread Michael Reichert
Hi, Am 20.05.2014 12:26, schrieb SomeoneElse: Michael Reichert wrote: Hi, I have discovered a mechanical edit of 100 restaurants worldwide by user BuganiniQ. https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/22303143 comment=update diet:vegen/diet:vegetarian: set to only according to cuisine;

Re: [OSM-talk] undiscussed (?) mechanical edit on diet:vegan and diet:vegetarian

2014-05-20 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
2014-05-20 12:42 GMT+02:00 Michael Reichert naka...@gmx.net: No, not every mechanical edit. There is no sharp border. The example you gave correct errors. Such edits should not have to be discussed. But the changeset I gave changed tagging and IMHO did not fix errors (see the linked wiki

Re: [OSM-talk] undiscussed (?) mechanical edit on diet:vegan and diet:vegetarian

2014-05-20 Thread colliar
Am 20.05.2014 13:04, schrieb Martin Koppenhoefer: 2014-05-20 12:42 GMT+02:00 Michael Reichert naka...@gmx.net mailto:naka...@gmx.net: No, not every mechanical edit. There is no sharp border. The example you gave correct errors. Such edits should not have to be discussed. But the

[OSM-talk] undiscussed (?) mechanical edit on diet:vegan and diet:vegetarian

2014-05-20 Thread John Packer
For a more complete picture: This user (BuganiniQ) first added diet:vegetarian=yes and diet:vegan=yes to places with cuisine=vegan, and diet:vegetarian=yes to places with cuisine=vegetarian. It does not seem too much of a stretch to do that. Then later he corrected these tags to diet:vegan=only

Re: [OSM-talk] undiscussed (?) mechanical edit on diet:vegan and diet:vegetarian

2014-05-20 Thread Philip Barnes
On Tue, 2014-05-20 at 13:25 -0300, John Packer wrote: For a more complete picture: This user (BuganiniQ) first added diet:vegetarian=yes and diet:vegan=yes to places with cuisine=vegan, and diet:vegetarian=yes to places with cuisine=vegetarian. It does not seem too much of a stretch to do