Re: [OSM-legal-talk] OdbL: Section 4.6, Does data/methods have to be released on public Produced Work?

2020-10-19 Thread Lars-Daniel Weber via legal-talk
Dear Kathleen, thanks for your response. > Even assuming the polygons are from a Derivative Database, I don't see a > reason for the data to be released under > https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/wiki/Licence/Community_Guidelines/Trivial_Transformations_-_Guideline The process doesn't seem to be

[OSM-legal-talk] OdbL: Section 4.6, Does data/methods have to be released on public Produced Work?

2020-10-16 Thread Lars-Daniel Weber via legal-talk
Hi there, https://www.wohnlagenkarte.de/ displays location quality of residential areas. Those residential areas haven been produced using OSM data; the polygon area results from at least three surrounding paths and streets. Since the polygons are derived from OSM data and released in public,

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] map drawn based on OSM tiles

2019-10-07 Thread Lars-Daniel Weber via legal-talk
From: "Kathleen Lu via legal-talk" > So if what is extracted is solely what was in the database, then the > extraction is not > material that the tile license covered (the tile license cannot actually > change the license of the data, which is ODbL, as that would be > impermissible under ODbL).