Re: [Talk-ca] Building Import

2019-03-28 Thread Begin Daniel
Someone has compared Bing and Canvec data in rural areas? Sent from Galaxy S7 From: OSM Volunteer stevea Sent: Wednesday, March 27, 2019 11:52:02 PM To: Talk-ca Cc: keith hartley Subject: Re: [Talk-ca] Building Import Ah, good dialog ensues. Municipality by mun

Re: [Talk-ca] Building Import

2019-03-28 Thread John Whelan
Are you talking about the older CANVEC data or the data that Stats has released which is really municipal data? Thanks John Begin Daniel wrote on 2019-03-28 8:31 AM: Someone has compared Bing and Canvec data in rural areas? Sent from Galaxy S7

Re: [Talk-ca] Building Import

2019-03-28 Thread Begin Daniel
Buildings where there is no available municipal data Sent from Galaxy S7 From: John Whelan Sent: Thursday, March 28, 2019 9:32:32 AM To: Begin Daniel Cc: Talk-ca; keith hartley Subject: Re: [Talk-ca] Building Import Are you talking about the older CANVEC data or

Re: [Talk-ca] Building Import

2019-03-28 Thread Roman Auriti
Why is it that FME seems to be a tool that's OK to use for OSM when someone replied that they could use PostGIS and was shut down by someone else replying 'I'm not installing postgesql for you to accept simplification'? Does anyone else find it a little ironic that the community would move forward

Re: [Talk-ca] Building Import

2019-03-28 Thread Nate Wessel
I agree that the use of closed software for this is not ideal, though I think it's far from the most worrying thing about this whole process. Perhaps that says more about the rest of the process though... I'm glad we're at least talking about cleaning up the data now! If anyone is interested,

Re: [Talk-ca] Building Import

2019-03-28 Thread john whelan
The trade off is if it can be used elsewhere then there is a benefit for using open source software however if it's only going to be used once here and we have someone who knows the proprietary software very well the data that ends up in OSM doesn't really care how it was produced. This is more a

Re: [Talk-ca] Building Import

2019-03-28 Thread Roman Auriti
Thanks for sharing those, Nate. I like using PostGIS and I would be happy to help the community clean geometries. Is there anyone in Calgary on the mailing list? On Thu, Mar 28, 2019 at 8:20 AM john whelan wrote: > The trade off is if it can be used elsewhere then there is a benefit for > using