Re: [Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset

2013-01-08 Thread nicholas ingalls
** ** *From:* nicholas ingalls [mailto:nicholas.inga...@gmail.com] *Sent:* Thursday, 2013-01-03 15:24 *To:* Andrew Buck; talk-ca@openstreetmap.org *Subject:* Re: [Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset ** ** Yeah I did a bit more research afterwards to double check, including going and getting gps

Re: [Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset

2013-01-08 Thread James Ewen
On Tue, Jan 8, 2013 at 12:34 PM, nicholas ingalls nicholas.inga...@gmail.com wrote: In reference to the orientation problems, I generally orient according to gps tracks and I also use the road centre lines from the fredericton open data portal to ensure areas are correct. (I know the data

Re: [Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset

2013-01-08 Thread nicholas ingalls
What is the official word on the practice of checking non-approved data sources, not for inclusion in OSM, but to ensure what is being included is correct? That is honestly a good question! I guess to me this would be a bit of a grey area, nowhere is the practice explicitly mentioned. I agree

Re: [Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset

2013-01-07 Thread Connors, Bernie (SNB)
, 2013-01-01 19:23 To: talk-ca@openstreetmap.org Subject: [Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset Hello all, I've been recently drawing all of the buildings in Fredericton in preparation for going around and collecting the addresses. I'd noticed that all the buildings in Fredericton were offset

Re: [Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset

2013-01-07 Thread Connors, Bernie (SNB)
] Sent: Wednesday, 2013-01-02 15:59 To: nicholas ingalls Cc: talk-ca@openstreetmap.org Subject: Re: [Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset Hi, I am not from the area, but I did want to post my 2 cents about this issue. Your idea of how the offset got started sounds correct. I would caution you though

Re: [Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset

2013-01-03 Thread nicholas ingalls
Yeah I did a bit more research afterwards to double check, including going and getting gps more gps traces and the current (Bing) imagery appears to be dead on. I also checked it with some centre lines from another data source (Not importing just to check the imagery) and they also verified that

Re: [Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset

2013-01-02 Thread Andrew Buck
Hi, I am not from the area, but I did want to post my 2 cents about this issue. Your idea of how the offset got started sounds correct. I would caution you though that GPS traces can be offset, too, due to atmospheric effects. To really get a good trace with no offset you need to do a few

[Talk-ca] Fredericton WMS Offset

2013-01-01 Thread nicholas ingalls
Hello all, I've been recently drawing all of the buildings in Fredericton in preparation for going around and collecting the addresses. I'd noticed that all the buildings in Fredericton were offset. Naturally I assumed that the original mappers in Fredericton had done this offset on purpose. I