Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread Roger Calvert
Round here (Cumbria), that would have sheep on it. When I did school geography, it was called Rough Pasture. Roger On 16/12/2019 14:13, Martin Wynne wrote: I'm happy to use "farmland" to mean cultivated land, whether for cash crops, pasture for livestock, haymaking, any farming activity. But

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread Martin Wynne
I'm happy to use "farmland" to mean cultivated land, whether for cash crops, pasture for livestock, haymaking, any farming activity. But I keep finding myself on land for which none of the available tags really seem to apply. There seems to be one missing. For example: http://85a.uk/bredon_9

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread SK53
I tend to map to field boundaries: it's all farmland in my view, just not necessarily productive. In particular strips of grass around arable may be a short-term consequence of various subsidy schemes, or game cover crops. Many ditches are there to improve the drainage of the fields so I'd see them

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread Philip Barnes
On Monday, 16 December 2019, Gareth L wrote: > I’m all for using a polygon per field, but am unsure what to do at the > boundaries. Do I make 2 field polygons meet? Or leave a gap as there’s a > track/hedge/fence/small coppice/ ditch/drain ? I’m probably not going to be > able to map the boundar

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread Andy Townsend
On 16/12/2019 11:59, Gareth L wrote: I’m all for using a polygon per field, but am unsure what to do at the boundaries. Do I make 2 field polygons meet? Or leave a gap as there’s a track/hedge/fence/small coppice/ ditch/drain ? I’m probably not going to be able to map the boundary particularly

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread Gareth L
I’m all for using a polygon per field, but am unsure what to do at the boundaries. Do I make 2 field polygons meet? Or leave a gap as there’s a track/hedge/fence/small coppice/ ditch/drain ? I’m probably not going to be able to map the boundary particularly accurately in a first pass, so would

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread SK53
One thing for me is that if walking in the winter knowing that a particular field which a footpath crosses is arable can be very useful. If have COPD (around 40% lung capacity) and walking across a recently ploughed field can push me past the level where my breathing can cope. Obviously I therefore

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread Tony OSM
Mapping Fields - preferred method I think is individual fields, or at least polygons which are based on road or natural boundaries. Mea Culpa - I have also mapped farmland as larger polygons. Large polygons make life difficult when a field changes use - near where I live it becomes scrub for s

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread Tony OSM
I have always thought that farmland as an English word means land used for production by growing things - cabbages, cows etc. Hierarchy then led to arable, pasture, horticulture. But what do you do with managed woodland eg coppiced or pollarded or left to semi-wild animal populations eg deer, s

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread Philip Barnes
On Monday, 16 December 2019, David Groom wrote: > -- Original Message -- > From: "Dave F via Talk-GB" > To: talk-gb@openstreetmap.org > Sent: 14/12/2019 15:54:13 > Subject: Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland? > > >On 14/12/2019 15:19, Martin Wynne wrote: > >> > >>Is this "farmland"? > >> > >>

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread Mateusz Konieczny
16 Dec 2019, 11:07 by revi...@pacific-rim.net: > -- Original Message -- > From: "Dave F via Talk-GB" <> talk-gb@openstreetmap.org> > > To: > talk-gb@openstreetmap.org > Sent: 14/12/2019 15:54:13 > Subject: Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland? > > >> On 14/12/2019 15:19, Martin Wynne wrote: >

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread David Woolley
On 16/12/2019 10:07, David Groom wrote: I see no benefit to mapping individual fields as separate polygons tagged as farmland if adjacent fields are also farmland. Could you explain why you think this is best? I see no reason why mapping individual fields would not be an objective for OSM.

Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland?

2019-12-16 Thread David Groom
-- Original Message -- From: "Dave F via Talk-GB" To: talk-gb@openstreetmap.org Sent: 14/12/2019 15:54:13 Subject: Re: [Talk-GB] What is farmland? On 14/12/2019 15:19, Martin Wynne wrote: Is this "farmland"? http://85a.uk/haws_hill_960x600.jpg I would say yes, as I believe both ar