Re: [Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs

2013-11-10 Thread Richard Welty
On 11/10/13 1:37 AM, Elliott Plack wrote: In Baltimore County, MD, we have 0 incorporated towns with nearly 1M people. There are however plenty of informal towns that have become CDPs. I believe the Census uses ZCTAs to construct the CDPs, so they're based on ZIP Codes, which in turn are based

Re: [Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs

2013-11-09 Thread Greg Troxel
Paul Norman penor...@mac.com writes: From: Richard Welty [mailto:rwe...@averillpark.net] Subject: Re: [Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs the latter, i think. there are parts of the US where the CDP boundaries do contribute to the map. I think there's two different cases that need

Re: [Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs

2013-11-09 Thread Serge Wroclawski
On Sat, Nov 9, 2013 at 7:03 PM, Greg Troxel g...@ir.bbn.com wrote: (I realize that in Alaska there are some areas where CDPs seem to matter.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bethesda%2C_Maryland - Serge ___ Talk-us mailing list

Re: [Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs

2013-11-09 Thread Elliott Plack
In Baltimore County, MD, we have 0 incorporated towns with nearly 1M people. There are however plenty of informal towns that have become CDPs. I believe the Census uses ZCTAs to construct the CDPs, so they're based on ZIP Codes, which in turn are based on postal routes. I think humans tend to

Re: [Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs

2013-11-08 Thread Steven Johnson
CDPs are used by Census and other Federal agencies, OMB in particular. They are used as a tool to administer programs, for example Federal block grants. I'm not sure they have much use beyond that. State/tribal/county/municipal boundaries OTOH are much more useful and likely to reflect a consensus

Re: [Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs

2013-11-08 Thread Paul Norman
From: Richard Welty [mailto:rwe...@averillpark.net] Subject: Re: [Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs the latter, i think. there are parts of the US where the CDP boundaries do contribute to the map. I think there's two different cases that need to be distinguished between. One is where

Re: [Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs

2013-11-06 Thread Greg Troxel
Richard Welty rwe...@averillpark.net writes: first of all, CDPs. there's been an ongoing discussion about whether they belong in OSM at all, or whether they deserve their admin_level 8 classification. i have mixed feelings about the first, and am pretty sure we need a new way of classifying

Re: [Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs

2013-11-06 Thread Richard Welty
On 11/6/13 4:52 PM, Greg Troxel wrote: Are you aware of any regulatory impact of crossing a CDP boundary (ignoring impacts of crossing other boundaries that coincide)? I am not, and I have no idea where the CDP boundaries are around me. CDP boundaries are worse, really, than that. i

[Talk-us] Admin borders in the US: CDPs

2013-11-03 Thread Richard Welty
first of all, CDPs. there's been an ongoing discussion about whether they belong in OSM at all, or whether they deserve their admin_level 8 classification. i have mixed feelings about the first, and am pretty sure we need a new way of classifying them if we keep them. here's some more fuel for the