Re: "wireguard" implementation improperly merged and needs revert

2020-08-24 Thread Jason A. Donenfeld
Hi Nia, On Mon, Aug 24, 2020 at 5:57 PM nia wrote: > > Hi Jason, > > > We still need to protect the unique identity and reputation of > > WireGuard (our "brand"). This ensures that when people see the > > WireGuard name or logo, they know it is something we, the > > WireGuard developers, have wor

Re: "wireguard" implementation improperly merged and needs revert

2020-08-24 Thread nia
Hi Jason, > We still need to protect the unique identity and reputation of > WireGuard (our "brand"). This ensures that when people see the > WireGuard name or logo, they know it is something we, the > WireGuard developers, have worked on." Personally, I would be in favour of entirely rebranding

Re: "wireguard" implementation improperly merged and needs revert

2020-08-23 Thread Thor Lancelot Simon
On Sat, Aug 22, 2020 at 08:35:39PM +0200, Jason A. Donenfeld wrote: > > In its current form, there are implementation flaws and violations > that I do not consider acceptable, and deploying this kind of thing is > highly irresponsible and harmful to your users. Can you please explain what these (

"wireguard" implementation improperly merged and needs revert

2020-08-22 Thread Jason A. Donenfeld
Hi Taylor/Ozaki-san/NetBSD developers, I'm very excited that NetBSD is enthusiastic about WireGuard. Having more deployment of WireGuard is always great to hear. And NetBSD is really a terrific project. I've been enthusiastic about using it for rump kernels for many years, and adding WireGuard cap

Re: "wireguard" implementation improperly merged and needs revert

2020-08-22 Thread Taylor R Campbell
[followups to tech-net to reduce cross-posting noise] Hi, Jason! Sorry about not reaching out. The history is that the code has been kicking around the NetBSD world since Ozaki-san first wrote it in 2018, without getting merged into src. It felt a shame to let it wallow in that state indefinite

Re: "wireguard" implementation improperly merged and needs revert

2020-08-22 Thread Jason Thorpe
> On Aug 22, 2020, at 11:35 AM, Jason A. Donenfeld wrote: > > it needs to be done right, Can you be specific about what is wrong? -- thorpej