Re: [Tigervnc-devel] File transfer

2009-04-14 Thread Peter Åstrand
I agree. Also, it wasn't just the implementation that was broken - the special protocol had many problems as well. I would say that the design was flawed from the start: If a file transfer feature should at all be included in a VNC implementation, it should at least be based on some existing

Re: [Tigervnc-devel] File transfer

2009-04-14 Thread Matt Campbell
Hello Peter: Thank you for your comments. The file transfer feature in the VNC4 branch of TightVNC always felt flimsy to me. The UI was especially inadequate for keyboard-only users. I made several modifications to the UI, which I would contribute back to that branch of TightVNC if it were

Re: [Tigervnc-devel] File transfer

2009-04-14 Thread DRC
Well, except for that fact that it would require building TigerVNC against OpenSSL, which has its own set of issues. Why not just set up a separate SFTP or SSh server on the Windows server? I use the Cygwin SSh daemon to accomplish this, but there are others that are easier to set up. There are

[Tigervnc-devel] File transfer

2009-04-13 Thread Matt Campbell
Hello all: I noticed that file transfer was removed from TigerVNC about a month ago. Why was this done, and is there any plan to bring file transfer back? If the decision has already been explained, I'd appreciate a link to the original explanation. Thanks, Matt

Re: [Tigervnc-devel] File transfer

2009-04-13 Thread DRC
We may have discussed it before the list was created, because I can't seem to find the thread in the archives. However, IIRC, the reason was mainly that the feature was broken and we didn't have anyone who cared about it enough to fix it and maintain it. File transfer only exists in the Windows