Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-24 Thread christopher hoover
Magnus wrote: Having 1-10 kW per rack is not uncommon these days, so forced convection needs to be done That and more. A fully loaded 42U rack of HP C-class blades runs 8 kW idle and peaks at 24 kW. This can be air cooled (easily) in a properly designed and commissioned run-of-the-mill

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-23 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message blu125-w32eb9626acf899c8949ffce...@phx.gbl, Mark Sims writes: Many failed electrolytic caps on PC motherboards and in PC power supplies can be traced to a case of industrial espionage gone wrong. [...] While this tale is true, the fact is that even without incompetence, electrolytics

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Tom Van Baak
One comment, and one idea on airflow... I've noticed that none of my high-end frequency standards use fans at all. That includes every Rb, Cs, and H-maser. This does not mean they are all cool to the touch, but my guess is it's better to allow temperature gradients to exist than use fans in an

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Rick Karlquist
Tom Van Baak wrote: One comment, and one idea on airflow... I've noticed that none of my high-end frequency standards use fans at all. That includes every Rb, Cs, and H-maser. This does not mean they are all cool to the touch, but my guess is it's better to allow temperature gradients to

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread David Forbes
At 10:13 AM -0700 5/22/09, Tom Van Baak wrote: One comment, and one idea on airflow... I'm sure we could discuss for some time what airflow is too much or too little or where to place the thermal probes or how to take IR scans or how then interpret them. But it seems to me the bottom line is

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message 4267588cdd7544d48a9a119584228...@pc52, Tom Van Baak writes: I'm sure this requires no small effort in thermal engineering on their part. The major part of this effort was to reduce the power usage to maximize battery lifetime. The plot you get is then simply accuracy (or jitter or

[time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Mark Sims
When I swapped my 5370A AC fans for DC fans I was concerned that the inverter in the fan motors might have some effect on the performance of the instrument... after all, it is measuring stuff at the part per trillion level. I was rather surprised to see that, if anything, the internal

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message blu125-w59049fd49ae9ec2fa1474ce...@phx.gbl, Mark Sims writes: I was rather surprised to see that, if anything, the internal jitter went down a couple of picoseconds That could easily be reduced microphonics in the OCXO because the new fan does not rattle around as much. --

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Hal Murray
rich...@karlquist.com said: First of all, the 5071A has to be able to run on a battery, so you can do the flying clock experiment. Did you have any trouble convincing the airlines and/or FAA that it was safe to take an atomic clock on a plane? I'd be more worried about the big batteries than

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Magnus Danielson
Hi! Regarding the comments below on the 5370: there are always two questions with temperature: meeting spec and reliability. Instruments vary as to which is a bigger issue. Some have temperature proof measurement techniques that will work virtually until something burns up, so you can get

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Hal Murray
The reason for the fans is to prevent premature failures of the silicon devices due to thermal degradation. The life of a silicon chip is halved for every 10C temperature increase, more or less. I was going to make a similar comment, but got sidetracked poking around google. I didn't find

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Magnus Danielson
Hal Murray skrev: The reason for the fans is to prevent premature failures of the silicon devices due to thermal degradation. The life of a silicon chip is halved for every 10C temperature increase, more or less. I was going to make a similar comment, but got sidetracked poking around

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread David Forbes
Hal Murray wrote: The reason for the fans is to prevent premature failures of the silicon devices due to thermal degradation. The life of a silicon chip is halved for every 10C temperature increase, more or less. I was going to make a similar comment, but got sidetracked poking around

[time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Mark Sims
The power dissipated in a modern CPU chip (watts per sq cm) far exceeds that of a cooking hotplate. There are some videos on YouTube showing CPU's literally exploding when they loose cooling for just a short time. ECL is a rather chilly iceberg in comparison...

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Rick Karlquist
M. Warner Losh wrote: In message: 20090522185851.4137db...@ip-64-139-1-69.sjc.megapath.net Hal Murray hmur...@megapathdsl.net writes: : : rich...@karlquist.com said: : Did you have any trouble convincing the airlines and/or FAA that it was safe : to take an atomic clock on a

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message 4a170da2.3080...@rubidium.dyndns.org, Magnus Danielson writes: Hal Murray skrev: There are being books written about this. One that I have found being a fairly short but useful one is the ATT Reliability Manual. It is worth pointing out that a very large fraction of all electronics

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message 971f24636bd13158d9fe412ec6c9c885.squir...@webmail.sonic.net, Rick Karlquist writes: The old photos of Len Cutler watching the airline porters carrying the clock up the stairs to the plane give the impression that the airline was honored to be asked to participate. According to a SAS

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Magnus Danielson
Poul-Henning Kamp skrev: In message 4a170da2.3080...@rubidium.dyndns.org, Magnus Danielson writes: Hal Murray skrev: There are being books written about this. One that I have found being a fairly short but useful one is the ATT Reliability Manual. It is worth pointing out that a very large

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Magnus Danielson
Mark Sims skrev: The power dissipated in a modern CPU chip (watts per sq cm) far exceeds that of a cooking hotplate. There are some videos on YouTube showing CPU's literally exploding when they loose cooling for just a short time. ECL is a rather chilly iceberg in comparison... The

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Rick Karlquist
Poul-Henning Kamp wrote: It is worth pointing out that a very large fraction of all electronics failures are not semiconductors but electrolytic capacitors. People are often astonished when I tell them, that a long life electrolytic capacitor is one which will last one year at its rated

[time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-22 Thread Mark Sims
Many failed electrolytic caps on PC motherboards and in PC power supplies can be traced to a case of industrial espionage gone wrong. Somebody sole the formula for the caps from a Japanese company and sold it to a competitor. That competitor allegedly cranked out over a billion of the caps

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Richard (Rick) Karlquist
Mark Sims wrote: I have done quite a bit of work replacing fans in old equipment with modern fans. I have never seen a case where replacing a hurricane level fan with a whisper quiet fan made any real difference in the cooling inside the unit... typically one sees less than +/- 5C

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message 4a15808f.4090...@karlquist.com, Richard (Rick) Karlquist writes: Modern fans obey the same laws of physics as the original equipment. They don't magically produce more airflow for less noise. Agreed: there is no magic to it. But a lot has happened in aerodynamics since Hermann Papst

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Lux, James P
-Original Message- From: time-nuts-boun...@febo.com [mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] On Behalf Of Richard (Rick) Karlquist Sent: Thursday, May 21, 2009 9:26 AM To: Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement Subject: Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more (actually 5370A

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Didier Juges
pointed out by others. Didier -Original Message- From: time-nuts-boun...@febo.com [mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] On Behalf Of Poul-Henning Kamp Sent: Thursday, May 21, 2009 12:12 PM To: Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement Subject: Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Hal Murray
This is incorrect. ECL components require a minimum airflow velocity that is rather high. The purpose of the large fan is to maintain this velocity. If a smaller fan is used, the ECL components will get hotter, even though the air flowing past them is not much hotter. When you say the fan

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Rick Karlquist
Hal Murray wrote: How much ECL is used in a 5070? A bunch How tightly are they packed? You need a high cooling velocity even if just one chip. How much of the heat goes directly from the chip to the air rather than from chip to board to air? A substantial amount of cooling is from DIP to

[time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Mark Sims
Hello Karl, When I tested my quiet 12V fans in the 5370As, I placed 6 thermocouples around the guts of the machine. I made a point of sticking a couple of them on heatsinked chips. The new fan made no significant difference in the readings on any of the thermocouples. All the readings

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Jim Hall
When I worked in RD at HP's Microwave Division (1972 ~ 1976) and HP LaserJet Division (1976 ~ 2000) we designed all our products to meet specifications across a temperature range of -20 to +55 degrees Centigrade. I would assume this was a standard requirement across most if not all HP products

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Bruce Griffiths
The ECL and EECL chips are located on A22 (arming board), A19 + A20 (interpolator boards), A18, A17 (count chain assembly) A8 (reference buffer), A21 (multiplier assembly). The interpolator boards are more or less directly in line with the ducted airflow from the fan as are the reference buffer

[time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Mark Sims
A8? Reference buffer? Gee, I thought was the electrostatic dust magnet ;-) That puppy can grow more fuzz than a sheepdog. In all the machines I have worked on, it was utterly disgusting. BTW, the best way to locate where to drill the access hole for the oscillator tuning pot is to look

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-21 Thread Jim Palfreyman
I came home one day to find *that* smell in my workshop. It turned out to be my HP 3325B. It had been on for ages and it had also been a warm day. I looked at the back and found the intake completely blocked up with dust. It seems to still work, but I need to open it right up and check it out

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-20 Thread Lux, James P
: [time-nuts] 5070B once more (actually 5370A fans) Yes, I have replaced the fans in four 5370A and 5370B counters with modern 12V brushless DC motor units connected to the 10V supply. VERY nice and quiet. I did before and after thermocouple tests in the chassis. The temperatures

[time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-20 Thread Mark Sims
Yes, I have replaced the fans in four 5370A and 5370B counters with modern 12V brushless DC motor units connected to the 10V supply. VERY nice and quiet. I did before and after thermocouple tests in the chassis. The temperatures were basically unchanged (+/- 3C). Variances could easily

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-20 Thread Roy Phillips
, 2009 4:53 PM Subject: [time-nuts] 5070B once more (actually 5370A fans) Yes, I have replaced the fans in four 5370A and 5370B counters with modern 12V brushless DC motor units connected to the 10V supply. VERY nice and quiet. I did before and after thermocouple tests in the chassis

Re: [time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-20 Thread Pete Lancashire
When I have been concerned with 'stealing' power, I have used a switching power supply wall wart. Small and are usually quite efficient. One model a Sony (branded), the chip inside even had a opto isolated control pin so it could be turned on/off via logic. -pete Yes, I have replaced the

[time-nuts] 5070B once more.... (actually 5370A fans)

2009-05-20 Thread Mark Sims
I have done quite a bit of work replacing fans in old equipment with modern fans. I have never seen a case where replacing a hurricane level fan with a whisper quiet fan made any real difference in the cooling inside the unit... typically one sees less than +/- 5C difference anywhere inside