Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-02-13 Thread Bob Camp
Hi Wow, that guy did a *lot* of work on all that. Congratulations to the him and those kind enough to translate it. Per an off list request there’s at least one additional circuit to add to his list: Wire the RF as shown on page 17 of the MAdS slides but: 1) Use an RPD-1 (or modern

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-02-12 Thread Attila Kinali
On Tue, 20 Jan 2015 08:39:13 +0100 Attila Kinali att...@kinali.ch wrote: 2-3 years ago, i got a presentation of an italian amateur radio on how to measure phase noise of osciallators using this technique in quite detail. Only draw back is that the presentation is in italian. If someone wants

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-02-08 Thread Magnus Danielson
Hej Attila, On 02/06/2015 01:22 PM, Attila Kinali wrote: Moin Magnus, On Wed, 21 Jan 2015 07:07:54 +0100 Magnus Danielson mag...@rubidium.dyndns.org wrote: For oscillators, they should have been turned on long enough such that any drift is negligible. Alternatively you process out the

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-02-06 Thread Attila Kinali
Moin Magnus, On Wed, 21 Jan 2015 07:07:54 +0100 Magnus Danielson mag...@rubidium.dyndns.org wrote: For oscillators, they should have been turned on long enough such that any drift is negligible. Alternatively you process out the quadratic trend out of it. The later should be accompanied by

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-27 Thread steph.rey
Bob Camp Envoyé : dimanche 25 janvier 2015 19:01 À : Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi The approach in the original NIST paper below was sort of a “best guess” about how to do the limiting

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-26 Thread Bruce Griffiths
the IF ? Stephane -Message d'origine- De : time-nuts [mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] De la part de Bob Camp Envoyé : dimanche 25 janvier 2015 19:01 À : Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-26 Thread Stéphane Rey
and frequency measurement Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi The approach in the original NIST paper below was sort of a “best guess” about how to do the limiting and filtering. When the paper was presented, a number of us questioned how that part

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-25 Thread Charles Steinmetz
Stephane wrote: I'm now trying to evaluate various architectures of 2-channels squarers and a DMDT. For that I'm designing a PCB with 4 squarers : simple 74ac04 gate biased at VCC/2, a LT1016 comparator, the transistor based differential amplifier from Winzel and the one from Charles. Note

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-25 Thread Stéphane Rey
 : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Stephane wrote: I'm now trying to evaluate various architectures of 2-channels squarers and a DMDT. For that I'm designing a PCB with 4 squarers : simple 74ac04 gate biased at VCC/2, a LT1016 comparator, the transistor

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-24 Thread Stéphane Rey
: 'Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement' Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi, Following the tests results in the previous email, today I've performed additional measurements showing that the repeatability of the GPSDO DUT is not great

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-24 Thread Stéphane Rey
: time-nuts [mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] De la part de Stéphane Rey Envoyé : mardi 20 janvier 2015 23:15 À : 'Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement' Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi, Following the tests results

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-24 Thread Bob Camp
23:15 À : 'Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement' Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi, Following the tests results in the previous email, today I've performed additional measurements showing that the repeatability

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-24 Thread Magnus Danielson
] De la part de Stéphane Rey Envoyé : mardi 20 janvier 2015 23:15 À : 'Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement' Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi, Following the tests results in the previous email, today I've performed additional

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-24 Thread Adrian
Hi Stéphane, have you read W. Riley's paper on a DMTD system? http://www.wriley.com/A%20Small%20DMTD%20System.pdf Cheers, Adrian Stéphane Rey schrieb: Hi guys. After several experiments I could discover that the bad ADEV from the two GPSDO DUT are due to GPS lock losses. This is probably

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-21 Thread Magnus Danielson
John, On 01/20/2015 01:55 AM, John Miles wrote: John, Your new three-corner hat feature is really cool. Already tried it, even if I did not spend quality time on setting source labels correctly. Whenever I have a setup capable of running it, I will test-spin it again. I suspect that when you

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-20 Thread Attila Kinali
On Mon, 19 Jan 2015 08:59:58 -0500 Bob Camp kb...@n1k.org wrote: The most basic way to do phase noise in the basement is with a single mixer setup running into some sort of audio FFT device. A sound card can be used or an audio spectrum analyzer. Parts are $100 to get one setup once you can

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-20 Thread Stéphane Rey
: time-nuts [mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] De la part de Stéphane Rey Envoyé : lundi 19 janvier 2015 22:32 À : 'Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement' Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi Here are the results of today's

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-19 Thread John Miles
John, Your new three-corner hat feature is really cool. Already tried it, even if I did not spend quality time on setting source labels correctly. Whenever I have a setup capable of running it, I will test-spin it again. I suspect that when you make separate measurements, the noise of

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-19 Thread Bob Camp
and frequency measurement' Cc : mag...@rubidium.se Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Bonsoir Stéphane, On 01/18/2015 10:34 PM, Stéphane Rey wrote: Thanks a lot Bob and Magnus for your very helpful comments. The HP5370a was indeed in TI

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-19 Thread Magnus Danielson
Bonsoir Stéphane, On 01/18/2015 10:34 PM, Stéphane Rey wrote: Thanks a lot Bob and Magnus for your very helpful comments. The HP5370a was indeed in TI mode. By the way what is the difference with +/-TI, the button just aside... But I guess I understand where I've missed something : I've

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-19 Thread Stéphane Rey
; 'Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement' Cc : mag...@rubidium.se Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Bonsoir Stéphane, On 01/18/2015 10:34 PM, Stéphane Rey wrote: Thanks a lot Bob and Magnus for your very helpful comments. The HP5370a

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-19 Thread steph.rey
and frequency measurement' Cc : mag...@rubidium.se Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Bonsoir Stéphane, On 01/18/2015 10:34 PM, Stéphane Rey wrote: Thanks a lot Bob and Magnus for your very helpful comments. The HP5370a was indeed in TI mode

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-18 Thread John Miles
One way to get around problems with things like GPSDO’s is to have multiple standards and use them for different ranges of Tau. OCXO’s have good ADEV close in. Picking up a few and comparing them is pretty cheap. Rb’s have better ADEV at longer tau ( 300 sec). Comparing three or four is not

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-18 Thread Bob Camp
Hi I’m a little concerned about the measurement setup here. Based on the quoted text, there have been a few messages in the thread that have not showed up here. = The “start” input on the counter is defined below. The “stop” input is not defined. Is the counter running in time

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-18 Thread Charles Steinmetz
Stephane wrote: I need to make a squarer. I was hesitating between several methods : using a CMOS gate, but this will increase the flicker noise from what I've read, using an amplifier and clamping diodes or a fast comparator which might create some noise around the trigger point... Any

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-18 Thread Stéphane Rey
- De : time-nuts [mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] De la part de Bob Camp Envoyé : dimanche 18 janvier 2015 14:44 À : Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi Ok, I didn’t think I’d seen the plots

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-18 Thread Bob Camp
Hi Ok, I didn’t think I’d seen the plots before. I agree that the plots look like “counter limited” data. That’s a fine explanation at the shorter Tau’s. I also agree that some sort of periodic “stuff” is getting into one of the signals and creating the ripple. What I’m wondering about (and

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-18 Thread Magnus Danielson
Hi Bob, On 01/18/2015 04:25 AM, Bob Camp wrote: Hi I’m a little concerned about the measurement setup here. Based on the quoted text, there have been a few messages in the thread that have not showed up here. The messages got accidentally posted in the wrong thread. = The “start”

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-18 Thread Magnus Danielson
Bob, On 01/18/2015 02:44 PM, Bob Camp wrote: Hi Ok, I didn’t think I’d seen the plots before. I agree that the plots look like “counter limited” data. That’s a fine explanation at the shorter Tau’s. I also agree that some sort of periodic “stuff” is getting into one of the signals and

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-18 Thread Bob Camp
[mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] De la part de Bob Camp Envoyé : dimanche 18 janvier 2015 14:44 À : Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi Ok, I didn’t think I’d seen the plots before

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-18 Thread Magnus Danielson
Bonjour Stéphane, On 01/18/2015 03:37 PM, Stéphane Rey wrote: Hello, First, please do apologize for the confusion answering in the bad email. That's things I'm absolutely able to do when replying at 3 am ! Again, sorry for that and thanks Magnus for having corrected this. Ah well, that's

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-18 Thread Stéphane Rey
de Magnus Danielson Envoyé : dimanche 18 janvier 2015 16:47 À : time-nuts@febo.com Cc : mag...@rubidium.se Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Bonjour Stéphane, On 01/18/2015 03:37 PM, Stéphane Rey wrote: Hello, First, please do apologize

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-17 Thread Magnus Danielson
Bonsoir Stéphane, (For Stéphane's unedited reply, look in the Current state thread) On 01/17/2015 12:36 AM, Stéphane Rey wrote: Hi, I've took the time to read carefully your long and detailed message Magnus and this was very interesting. I've learned many things that have enabled me to

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-14 Thread Stéphane Rey
-Message d'origine- De : time-nuts [mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] De la part de Magnus Danielson Envoyé : mercredi 14 janvier 2015 08:04 À : time-nuts@febo.com Cc : mag...@rubidium.se Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Bonjour Stéphane, On 01

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-14 Thread Stéphane Rey
Will investigate further today -Message d'origine- De : time-nuts [mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] De la part de John Miles Envoyé : mercredi 14 janvier 2015 07:26 À : 'Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement' Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-14 Thread Magnus Danielson
Bonjour Stéphane, On 01/14/2015 02:16 AM, Stéphane Rey wrote: Hi Magnus, For some reason I've missed this message and the one from Jim until now ! This answers many of the questions I had. For my defense, I've 3000 messages since the last 3 months on the list !!! ah, yes, I'd like to get

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-13 Thread Stéphane Rey
Envoyé : vendredi 9 janvier 2015 23:57 À : Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement Objet : Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Hi If your only instrument is a counter. — and — You never measure past 1x10^-10 with that counter — and — Measurements

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-13 Thread Stéphane Rey
: Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters Stephane, On 01/09/2015 12:53 PM, steph.rey wrote: Dear all, I'm trying to measure Alan Deviations using Timelab and some frequency counters. The device under test is a GPSDO using a TCXO as référence I've

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-13 Thread John Miles
- Can I use Frequency difference mode from Timelab to monitor time intervals ? If no is there a way to use the time interval measurement from the counter with Timelab to plot ADEV ? If you feed in frequency samples, it will convert them to phase-difference samples internally, so the program

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-09 Thread Magnus Danielson
Stephane, On 01/09/2015 12:53 PM, steph.rey wrote: Dear all, I'm trying to measure Alan Deviations using Timelab and some frequency counters. The device under test is a GPSDO using a TCXO as référence I've an HP58503B GPSDO which feeds my counters. I've tried an HP5342A, 0-18 GHz, 1 Hz

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-09 Thread Bob Camp
Hi If your only instrument is a counter. — and — You never measure past 1x10^-10 with that counter — and — Measurements that bounce around with a standard deviation of the difference between readings of 1x10^-10 are ok. — then — No, you don’t need anything better than a 1x10^-10 ADEV.

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-09 Thread steph.rey
Hi Bob, Many thanks for your prompt and detailled answer. My question on applications wasn't on good ADEV where I perfetcly understand the need, but actually what could be the applications of measuring BAD ADEV (10e-7). That was my point asking what king of application can we cover by

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-09 Thread Jim Lux
On 1/9/15 7:42 AM, steph.rey wrote: Hi Bob, Many thanks for your prompt and detailled answer. My question on applications wasn't on good ADEV where I perfetcly understand the need, but actually what could be the applications of measuring BAD ADEV (10e-7). That was my point asking what king of

[time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-09 Thread steph.rey
Dear all, I'm trying to measure Alan Deviations using Timelab and some frequency counters. The device under test is a GPSDO using a TCXO as référence I've an HP58503B GPSDO which feeds my counters. I've tried an HP5342A, 0-18 GHz, 1 Hz resolution and a Philipps PM6654C, 0.01Hz resolution.

Re: [time-nuts] question Alan deviation measured with Timelab and counters

2015-01-09 Thread Bob Camp
Hi Welcome to the world of trying to measure this stuff … On Jan 9, 2015, at 6:53 AM, steph.rey steph@wanadoo.fr wrote: Dear all, I'm trying to measure Alan Deviations using Timelab and some frequency counters. The device under test is a GPSDO using a TCXO as référence I've an