Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-23 Thread nuts
On Sat, 22 Mar 2014 07:40:27 - David J Taylor david-tay...@blueyonder.co.uk wrote: From: Hal Murray There is a newer system getting phased in: ADS-B http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_dependent_surveillance-broadcast The plane broadcasts it's position and velocity every second.

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-23 Thread nuts
On Sat, 22 Mar 2014 06:58:22 -0700 (PDT) J. Forster j...@quikus.com wrote: I'm not so sure it is worth much as parts, except possibly on the black market. I believe the aircraft industry is big on tracking every part, cradle to grave. After all an under spec bolt can cause a very expensive

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-23 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message 20140323014515.0fffd232@linux-wh01, nuts writes: These salvage yards knew the content of each bird down to a science, and thus know when to start the process. We had an interesting event in Denmark related to that: Somebody hadn't heard about Mag-Thor, and tried to drive a truckload

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-23 Thread David J Taylor
From: nuts Note that the ADS-B mentioned is just a fancy version of the transponder that was turned off. I ran into your R Pi page about halfway in the process of doing my Beaglebone Black RTLSDR page. I have RTLSDR and dump1090 running on Angstrom Linux. I bought the GPS you suggested and will

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-23 Thread Rex Moncur
There is a newer system getting phased in: ADS-B For info MH370 did transmit ADS-B signals up to 17:21 UTC on 7 March when it seems it was either switched off or disabled. You can still see the track it took up to this time using the playback facility on Flight Radar 24 by say starting

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-23 Thread iov...@inwind.it
Da: rmon...@bigpond.net.au Data: 23/03/2014 10.58 For info MH370 did transmit ADS-B signals up to 17:21 UTC on 7 March when it seems it was either switched off or disabled. You can still see the track it took up to this time using the playback facility on Flight Radar 24 by say starting at

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-23 Thread Brian Lloyd
On Sun, Mar 23, 2014 at 3:37 AM, nuts n...@lazygranch.com wrote: Note that the ADS-B mentioned is just a fancy version of the transponder that was turned off. I guess it depends on your concept of what a transponder does. Yes, ADS-B does transmit in the same band as the standard transponder

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-23 Thread nuts
FR24 got a bit picky with their latest generation receiver since so many of the first generation units walked. What they have been doing lately is giving them to flight schools, which are a bit more responsible than your average schmuck. You can monitor any of these decoders with

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-23 Thread Bob Camp
Hi While you would *think* that LTE and PCS signals would be locked to “something good”, that’s not always the case. If you decide to use something like this for timing, it’s best to check things out carefully. Symmetricom learned this the hard way on one of their boxes …. Bob On Mar 23,

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Hal Murray
jleik...@leikhim.com said: In retrospect it is kind of crazy that fleet owners will put tracking devices on $100K semi trucks and cranes yet $100 million aircraft have to rely upon 60 year old technology (Transponders) and ACARS to keep track of them. I don't question the utility of TCAS and

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread David J Taylor
From: Hal Murray There is a newer system getting phased in: ADS-B http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_dependent_surveillance-broadcast The plane broadcasts it's position and velocity every second. The SDR folks are having fun with it. With one of the USB TV receiver gizmos and a

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message 532d1009.6040...@leikhim.com, Joe Leikhim writes: In retrospect it is kind of crazy that fleet owners will put tracking devices on $100K semi trucks and cranes yet $100 million aircraft have to rely upon 60 year old technology (Transponders) and ACARS to keep track of them. Pilots

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Jim Lux
On 3/21/14 8:52 PM, nuts wrote: On Thu, 20 Mar 2014 14:42:42 -0400 Joe Leikhim jleik...@leikhim.com wrote: I just red somewhere that the last ping was the only one recorded by Inmarsat system, Pings up to that point were presumed to occur due to known reporting intervals. So there is no track.

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Brian Lloyd
On Fri, Mar 21, 2014 at 11:22 PM, Joe Leikhim jleik...@leikhim.com wrote: In retrospect it is kind of crazy that fleet owners will put tracking devices on $100K semi trucks and cranes yet $100 million aircraft have to rely upon 60 year old technology (Transponders) and ACARS to keep track of

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Magnus Danielson
On 22/03/14 09:01, Poul-Henning Kamp wrote: In message 532d1009.6040...@leikhim.com, Joe Leikhim writes: In retrospect it is kind of crazy that fleet owners will put tracking devices on $100K semi trucks and cranes yet $100 million aircraft have to rely upon 60 year old technology

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread J. Forster
I'm not so sure it is worth much as parts, except possibly on the black market. I believe the aircraft industry is big on tracking every part, cradle to grave. After all an under spec bolt can cause a very expensive crash. YMMV, -John == In retrospect it is kind of crazy

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Scott McGrath
Actually traceability of parts for maintenance has nothing to do with unions and national security. It has everything to do with failure analysis. If a part fails it's entire path from manufacturer to maintanance and repair shops can be traced so if a part starts experiencing failures at Sn

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Chris Albertson
Can you imagine how much an aircraft like that is worth in spare parts alone? It is worth more as scrap metal. There is no market for untraced spare parts for large passenger jets. I was just going to say the same thing. Selling parts from a stolen 777 is like being an art thieve who just

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Magnus Danielson
On 22/03/14 21:19, Chris Albertson wrote: Can you imagine how much an aircraft like that is worth in spare parts alone? It is worth more as scrap metal. There is no market for untraced spare parts for large passenger jets. I was just going to say the same thing. Selling parts from a stolen

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Brooke Clarke
Hi Brian: MH370 had both ACARS and ADS-B, they have not been of any help. ACARS can send it's data using (in order) VHF, Inmarsat, HF. The problem is that ACARS quit sending information. MH370 did not have a contract wtih Inmarsat. ADS-B is built using W.W.II IFF technology (1090/1030 MHz, i.e.

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message 532e01ee.3040...@pacific.net, Brooke Clarke writes: There are two scenarios regarding MH370: [...] Three: 3) Somebody stole the plane for some reason. -- Poul-Henning Kamp | UNIX since Zilog Zeus 3.20 p...@freebsd.org | TCP/IP since RFC 956 FreeBSD committer |

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-22 Thread Bill Hawkins
At this time, the most likely story was written by a pilot and appeared in Wired magazine. Google MH370 smoke and look for the Wired reference. Bill Hawkins -Original Message- From: Poul-Henning Kamp Sent: Saturday, March 22, 2014 5:44 PM In message 532e01ee.3040...@pacific.net, Brooke

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-21 Thread nuts
On Thu, 20 Mar 2014 14:42:42 -0400 Joe Leikhim jleik...@leikhim.com wrote: I just red somewhere that the last ping was the only one recorded by Inmarsat system, Pings up to that point were presumed to occur due to known reporting intervals. So there is no track. The Inmarsat data is a red

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-21 Thread Joe Leikhim
In retrospect it is kind of crazy that fleet owners will put tracking devices on $100K semi trucks and cranes yet $100 million aircraft have to rely upon 60 year old technology (Transponders) and ACARS to keep track of them. I don't question the utility of TCAS and Transponders, it is just the

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-20 Thread David I. Emery
On Wed, Mar 19, 2014 at 09:28:38PM -0700, nuts wrote: A lot of these satellites have footprints for each antenna. I don't know if the footprints are narrow enough to track a plane. I do believe there is an time offset for each aircraft sent on the forward control channel from the ground

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-20 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message 279331507.5734621395275538874.JavaMail.actor@webmail5, iovane@inw ind.it writes: My question was on what would be the expected accuracy of the circle's radius. Projected onto the surface of the earth, the uncertainty leaves a band approx 740km wide. -- Poul-Henning Kamp | UNIX

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-20 Thread Jim Lux
On 3/20/14 12:07 AM, Poul-Henning Kamp wrote: In message 279331507.5734621395275538874.JavaMail.actor@webmail5, iovane@inw ind.it writes: My question was on what would be the expected accuracy of the circle's radius. Projected onto the surface of the earth, the uncertainty leaves a band

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-20 Thread Stanley
Would think they have many other aircraft with known position stationary or moving with location known to help improve the estimate. Stanley - Original Message - From: Jim Lux jim...@earthlink.net To: time-nuts@febo.com Sent: Thursday, March 20, 2014 8:05 AM Subject: Re: [time-nuts

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-20 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message 40280C39FE7D43C79313A1755BCAF58D@StanleyPC, Stanley writes: Would think they have many other aircraft with known position stationary or moving with location known to help improve the estimate. They might have been able to do that while the plane responded, but now that the plane is

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-20 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message 532ae780.4020...@earthlink.net, Jim Lux writes: On 3/20/14 12:07 AM, Poul-Henning Kamp wrote: Is there a document that describes the system somewhere? I've seen various descriptions of what's going on. Do they use timing or amplitude measurements? It is a timing measurement and

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-20 Thread Jim Lux
On 3/20/14 8:53 AM, Poul-Henning Kamp wrote: In message 40280C39FE7D43C79313A1755BCAF58D@StanleyPC, Stanley writes: Would think they have many other aircraft with known position stationary or moving with location known to help improve the estimate. They might have been able to do that while

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-20 Thread Stanley
Subject: Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing On 3/20/14 8:53 AM, Poul-Henning Kamp wrote: In message 40280C39FE7D43C79313A1755BCAF58D@StanleyPC, Stanley writes: Would think they have many other aircraft with known position stationary or moving with location known to help improve the estimate

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-20 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message B55E2883CD3E43878AE5CB77C259E572@StanleyPC, Stanley writes: Missing plane this ping was not lost why would others be lost ? This ping was retrieved long after (days) it was received why would it be the only one ? The point is that they might have been able to do more precise pings in

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-20 Thread Joe Leikhim
I just red somewhere that the last ping was the only one recorded by Inmarsat system, Pings up to that point were presumed to occur due to known reporting intervals. So there is no track. The Inmarsat data is a red herring. The plane could have ditched into the water 85 minutes after the

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-19 Thread Bill Hawkins
They only got one ping from INMARSAT at 64E above the Indian Ocean. There was no other ping to triangulate the position. One ping projects a circle on the Earth. The maximum flying range of the plane determined the ends of the NE and SE arcs of that circle. The news only gets stranger as time

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-19 Thread iov...@inwind.it
My question was on what would be the expected accuracy of the circle's radius. Antonio I8IOV Messaggio originale Da: b...@iaxs.net Data: 20/03/2014 1.21 They only got one ping from INMARSAT at 64E above the Indian Ocean. There was no other ping to triangulate the position. One ping

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-19 Thread J. Forster
It depends on how accurately the bird can measure the round-trip time: 1 us = ca 500' 10 us = ca 1 mile 100us = ca 10 miles 1 ms = ca 100 miles The arcs are loci of constant round trip time, projected on the globe. -John === My question was on what would be the expected

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-19 Thread iov...@inwind.it
Messaggio originale Da: j...@quikus.com Data: 20/03/2014 1.47 It depends on how accurately the bird can measure the round-trip time: 1 us = ca 500' 10 us = ca 1 mile 100us = ca 10 miles 1 ms = ca 100 miles The arcs are loci of constant round trip time, projected on the globe. This is

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-19 Thread Brooke Clarke
Hi Antonio: It's my understanding that the satellite sends a ping to each aircraft in it's low gain antenna pattern once every hour by aircraft ID number. The aircraft replies with a very short data packet that's time stamped (but without any location or other info other than the ID). The

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-19 Thread Jim Lux
On 3/19/14 5:21 PM, Bill Hawkins wrote: They only got one ping from INMARSAT at 64E above the Indian Ocean. There was no other ping to triangulate the position. One ping projects a circle on the Earth. The maximum flying range of the plane determined the ends of the NE and SE arcs of that

Re: [time-nuts] Aircraft ping timing

2014-03-19 Thread nuts
A lot of these satellites have footprints for each antenna. I don't know if the footprints are narrow enough to track a plane. ___ time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@febo.com To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts