Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread John Miles
Hi, I'm interested in doing some ionospheric research, but I don't want to break the bank with an $8,000 USD GPS disciplined Rubidium clock. Anyone have some ideas on cheaper alternatives? Suggest getting one of these, or another one like it:

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Bob Camp
Hi Are you interested in 24 hour stability or something longer than that? Bob On Sep 22, 2010, at 1:42 AM, Lester Veenstra wrote: From: q...@yahoogroups.com [mailto:q...@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of David Sent: Tuesday, September 21, 2010 10:55 PM To: q...@yahoogroups.com

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread jimlux
Lester Veenstra wrote: From: q...@yahoogroups.com [mailto:q...@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of David Sent: Tuesday, September 21, 2010 10:55 PM To: q...@yahoogroups.com Subject: [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference Hi, I'm interested in doing some ionospheric

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Peter Vince
Hello Lester, To expand on Bob's message a little, do you need medium to long-term accuracy (for a frequency counter reference for example), or something that is both accurate AND has low phase noise, suitable for multiplying up to GigaHertz, say, for communications? Particularly if the

[time-nuts] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Mark Sims
I don't think the firmware on the Tbolt makes much difference in performance.   (The older firmware even has a couple more features in it). Units with the 3.0 firmware are newer and have a much greater chance of having the poor temperature sensor which definitely has a bad effect on

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Bob Camp
Hi Not so simple decoder ring: 0 to 24 hours = use an auction site double oven OCXO ($50). 1 hour to a few days = use an auction site LPRO (or similar) rubidium ($50). 1 hour to forever = use a TBolt (or similar) made after 2001, but before 2005($100). The gotcha with any of the GPS devices is

Re: [time-nuts] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Bob Camp
Hi The 3.0 firmware is one way to make sure you don't get one of the early ocxo's. The later designs certainly worked better. I haven't seen any of the original red label ocxo's show up for quite a while, so they all may be gone by now. Bob -Original Message- From:

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Lester Veenstra
-Original Message- From: time-nuts-boun...@febo.com [mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] On Behalf Of Peter Vince Sent: Wednesday, September 22, 2010 2:27 PM To: les...@veenstras.com; Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement Subject: Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good,

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Lester Veenstra
-Original Message- From: time-nuts-boun...@febo.com [mailto:time-nuts-boun...@febo.com] On Behalf Of Bob Camp Sent: Wednesday, September 22, 2010 5:06 PM To: 'Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement' Subject: Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread John Miles
John, unless I am going mad, the ADEV plots for both auctions you mentioned look the same - maybe the bad one has been replaced since you posted your message? The black-and-white plot that everybody uses is from the original Thunderbolt data sheet, which was way conservative even for the

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Mark Spencer
Would a newer unit with the 3.00 firmware, the trimble branded OCXO and the older temperature sensor be one of the better (or perhaps best ?) TBOLT combinations ? - Original Message From: John Miles jmi...@pop.net To: les...@veenstras.com; Discussion of precise time and frequency

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Bob Camp
Hi That's my feeling. The firmware isn't the issue. The OCXO and the temp sensor are the important points. The firmware is just an easy way to get the right OCXO. Bob On Sep 22, 2010, at 7:00 PM, Mark Spencer mspencer12...@yahoo.ca wrote: Would a newer unit with the 3.00 firmware, the

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Ed Palmer
And if you buy a newer unit with the better oscillator, new firmware, and newer (but brain-dead) temperature sensor, it's trivial to replace the sensor. It took me longer to take the unit apart than to change the chip and I don't have a lot of experience with surface mount. Ed Bob Camp

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread russell
Is there anyway to tell without opening the box if you have: 1) better oscillator (=Trimble labeled) Anything visible from SW (Tboltmon or LH)? Any behavior fingerprint? 2) newer firmware (=rev 3.00)Does show up in SW. 3) newer brain dead temp sensor (=?).

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Bob Camp
HI Opening the box to be sure there's not a dead spider in there is always a good idea... The old oscillators all went out before firmware 3.0. Manufacturing dates past end of 2000 should all have a better oscillator. You could test it for phase noise and short term stability, but pulling the

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Bob Camp
Hi The black box TBolt is the real version. The one with the chromate box is the upside down version. It's pretty obvious which is which looking at things like the 9 pin D connector. Rumor has it that a very large customer designed their box backwards and the upside down part came into being

[time-nuts] Wenzel 245MHz OCXO Low noise power supply and mounting environment

2010-09-22 Thread Gerald Molenkamp
Hi All, I recently purchased a Wenzel 245MHz OCXO from ebay. It appears to work very well and shows good stability after 2 weeks on the bench. I would like to use it as the primary reference for a DDS 1st Lo in my homebrew HF transceiver. I have come to the conclusion the unit requires a

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Mark J. Blair
On Sep 22, 2010, at 5:57 PM, Bob Camp wrote: The temp sensor is the one that moves in real small steps. The bad one moves in (1/2 degree???) big steps. All of that (and much more) is visible if you bring up Lady Heather and see what's going on. My TBolt has the 3.0 firmware and the

Re: [time-nuts] Wenzel 245MHz OCXO Low noise power supply and mountingenvironment

2010-09-22 Thread John Miles
I am not able to measure Phase Noise as per spec, I am looking for assistance from this group on the best method for measuring phase noise and stability using what equipment I do have in my Lab. I have a TDS2022B with FFT, HP 53131 and Tek492BP. My standard's reference is one of Tom's

[time-nuts] WG mounting h/w (3)

2010-09-22 Thread Kit Scally
Robert, Many apologies for giving you the big snip (!) - replying to TN postings when receiving via Digest mode leaves room for such mishaps. I'm not familiar with 5/32 dowels or how well they fit in WG mounting holes. One major problem is European IEC US-MIL spec'd flanges have varying size

Re: [time-nuts] WG mounting h/w (3)

2010-09-22 Thread J. Forster
WG flanges are brass or aluminum. Dowel pins are case hardened steel. For all practical purposes, they do not wear. -John Robert, Many apologies for giving you the big snip (!) - replying to TN postings when receiving via Digest mode leaves room for such mishaps. I'm

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Ed Palmer
Does the temperature move around a little or is it a flat, straight line? If it never moves, it's probably the bad one. As Bob mentions below, the temperature only changes in large steps with the bad sensor. The good one has steps in the millidegree range. I got my chips from

[time-nuts] Cheap stable frequency sources

2010-09-22 Thread Perry Sandeen
Using 4 surplus Lucent rubidiums compared to a Lucnet GPS receiver I find a consistent error of between 110 and 860 pico-seconds using a HP 5370B after running them for about two weeks. By measuring the weekly drift one could calculate the drift. I measure the offset at about 20 milli-Hz. To

Re: [time-nuts] [qs1r] Looking for good, cheap, external reference

2010-09-22 Thread Mark J. Blair
On Sep 22, 2010, at 7:50 PM, Ed Palmer wrote: Does the temperature move around a little or is it a flat, straight line? If it never moves, it's probably the bad one. As Bob mentions below, the temperature only changes in large steps with the bad sensor. The good one has steps in

Re: [time-nuts] Cheap stable frequency sources

2010-09-22 Thread Hal Murray
You’d probably want to inhibit the circuit during the two periods between dawn and dusk to avoid what I believe is called the diurineal (sp) shift. In that small amount of time the Rb oscillator shouldn’t drift out of spec. diurnal I think it's more complicated than that. The problem

Re: [time-nuts] Wenzel 245MHz OCXO Low noise power supply andmounting environment

2010-09-22 Thread John Miles
Hi John, Actually he had 10+ for sale at $25 each free postage. Later that same day with a sudden spike in sales, the silly seller put them up to $80 and went back on several sales at $25. Now he has swapped them out with Vetron at $49 each and the excuse was the other Wenzel failed his

Re: [time-nuts] WG mounting h/w (3)

2010-09-22 Thread Don Latham
If I remember aright, every flange should mate to a choke. that's how to keep the joints from giving bad stuff... Don - Original Message - From: Kit Scally ksca...@bytecan.com.au To: time-nuts@febo.com Sent: Wednesday, September 22, 2010 8:34 PM Subject: [time-nuts] WG mounting h/w (3)