Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-05 Thread Scott Stobbe
FWIW, you can snub the switch node to dampen parasitic ringing in exchange of a loss in efficiency of a couple percent. I'm pretty sure I have seen this outlined in a few app notes. On Mon, Dec 5, 2016 at 1:22 PM, jimlux wrote: > On 12/5/16 9:13 AM, Dan Kemppainen wrote: > >> >> >>> Depending on

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-05 Thread jimlux
On 12/5/16 9:13 AM, Dan Kemppainen wrote: Depending on the application, another possible application is to sync up the DC/DC converter to the "main" clock source. This makes the switching noise then coherent to the system, which either makes it average out completely, or possible to filter it

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-05 Thread Dan Kemppainen
Depending on the application, another possible application is to sync up the DC/DC converter to the "main" clock source. This makes the switching noise then coherent to the system, which either makes it average out completely, or possible to filter it out in the digital domain using a deep notc

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-05 Thread Dan Kemppainen
On 12/5/2016 12:00 PM, time-nuts-requ...@febo.com wrote: This is exactly the PWM to PFM mode switch I described earlier. The 850mA are probably high enough that the DC/DC converter works in PWM mode, thus switching with a constant frequency, even if the load changes. On the other hand 200mA of

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-05 Thread Robert LaJeunesse
a surface mount oriented factory, but these are becoming antiques. Bob L. > Sent: Sunday, December 04, 2016 at 8:07 PM > From: jimlux > To: time-nuts@febo.com > Subject: Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805 > > ... The other thing is that SMD inducto

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-05 Thread Robert LaJeunesse
urement" > > Subject: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805 > > I found a cute little switching regulator that's a drop-in replacement > for an LM7805: http://www.ebay.com/itm/261243604047 > > I got a couple to play with, mainly to see how bad th

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-05 Thread Bob Camp
Hi The BLM18 gives you 300 ohms at zero current. It’s impedance at zero current per the data sheet. If you look at other parts of similar size, the impedance drops to nearly zero at the “rated current”. Great if you have a signal lead and no current. Not so great if you have an OCXO that is pull

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-05 Thread Tim Shoppa
Attila - I certainly do not differentiate between "ferrite bead" and "single turn toroidal choke". I think the SMT inductor manufacturers think of them in the same bucket too. what I think of as a "ferrite core for winding a multi turn inductor on", is invariably listed as a "ferrite bead" in t

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-05 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 4 Dec 2016 17:07:53 -0800 jimlux wrote: > > Wouldn't it be better to use a ferrite bead instead, for this application? > > The much lower series capacitance and thus higher self-resonance frequency > > should help damping the spurs. > > > sure, if you can get enough L. The other thing is

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Scott Stobbe
Well a sigma-delta modulator in loose terms is an error amplifier around a quantizer, so you get 1/loopgain rejection of quantization noise (in other words the noise is shaped out in frequency). Resulting in a noise spectrum that converges in 1/N versus 1/sqrt(N) for flat Gaussian noise, versus lob

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread jimlux
On 12/4/16 2:59 PM, Attila Kinali wrote: On Sun, 4 Dec 2016 13:28:44 -0800 jimlux wrote: I little series L and another C (so you have a pi low pass) can make a huge difference. If the load current is reasonably constant, then the drop across the series R of the L will be constant, so you can

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 4 Dec 2016 16:41:13 -0500 John Ackermann N8UR wrote: > The little OCXO I used for testing goes from about 850ma cold to 200ma > hot (at 5V) and I noticed a very different appearance of the spectrum as > the current dropped -- at high current, the switching spurs were quite > narrow, bu

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 4 Dec 2016 13:28:44 -0800 jimlux wrote: > I little series L and another C (so you have a pi low pass) can make a > huge difference. If the load current is reasonably constant, then the > drop across the series R of the L will be constant, so you can bump the > dc/dc output to compensa

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 4 Dec 2016 16:22:02 -0500 Scott Stobbe wrote: > If you wanted to be nutty you wouldn't go PWM at all, just like > fractional-N sythns don't just mash 2 divider values. You would sigma-delta > modulate your power stage. I don't know if you can buy one COTS, but there > are plenty of papers

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Bob Camp
Hi I doubt that there is a significant demand for 10 ma output switchers. The benefit of going from 12V to 2V as a switcher compared to linear is mighty small. As a guess, I’d say that anything much under a watt is not worth doing in this arena. That gets you up to at least 100 ma at the normal

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread John Ackermann N8UR
On 12/04/2016 04:34 PM, jimlux wrote: Even for time-nuts, I suspect we're not looking to eke out the last percent of efficiency from 96% to 97%, or handle wildly varying loads, etc. Nor are we usually looking for absolute minimum parts cost. The little OCXO I used for testing goes from about

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread jimlux
On 12/4/16 1:09 PM, Attila Kinali wrote: On Sun, 4 Dec 2016 15:45:55 -0500 Bob Camp wrote: Given that the parts to build one are fairly easy to get and that we likely have “nutty” EMI requirements. Maybe a small board that drops into a 78xx footprint is the better solution. I don't fully ag

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread jimlux
On 12/4/16 12:14 PM, John Ackermann N8UR wrote: That's a very good point... the design I'm testing the regulator in has a fair bit of C filtering, but no series L. I little series L and another C (so you have a pi low pass) can make a huge difference. If the load current is reasonably consta

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Scott Stobbe
If you wanted to be nutty you wouldn't go PWM at all, just like fractional-N sythns don't just mash 2 divider values. You would sigma-delta modulate your power stage. I don't know if you can buy one COTS, but there are plenty of papers on rolling your own. On Sun, Dec 4, 2016 at 4:09 PM, Attila Ki

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 4 Dec 2016 15:45:55 -0500 Bob Camp wrote: > Given that the parts to build one are fairly easy to get and that we likely > have “nutty” > EMI requirements. Maybe a small board that drops into a 78xx footprint is the > better solution. I don't fully agree. To go full "nutty" you would

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Bob Camp
Hi Given that the parts to build one are fairly easy to get and that we likely have “nutty” EMI requirements. Maybe a small board that drops into a 78xx footprint is the better solution. Bob > On Dec 4, 2016, at 3:39 PM, Adrian Godwin wrote: > > At Farnell, they're listed under Power Suppl

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Adrian Godwin
At Farnell, they're listed under Power Supplies rather than Switching Regulators (which is a subdivision of Semiconductors). It makes sense since one is a board product and the other a chip, but when the board product is a drop-in replacement for a TO220, less sense! On Sun, Dec 4, 2016 at 7:44

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Bob Camp
Hi The most common thing to miss on decoupling a switcher is that both the output *and* the input will generate crud that sprays all over the place. Series L on both the input and output are a really good idea. Microhenry (as opposed to milihenry) chokes are generally good enough. Values are

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread John Ackermann N8UR
That's a very good point... the design I'm testing the regulator in has a fair bit of C filtering, but no series L. On 12/04/2016 02:45 PM, Chris Albertson wrote: Surprisingly good as a drop-in replacement. Question: Suppose you are doing a new design and had space on the PCB for one more sma

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread jimlux
On 12/4/16 11:45 AM, Chris Albertson wrote: Surprisingly good as a drop-in replacement. Question: Suppose you are doing a new design and had space on the PCB for one more small passive part. I wonder how the performance of the switcher with an LC filter compares with the 7805.Yes, I think

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread jimlux
On 12/4/16 11:39 AM, John Ackermann N8UR wrote: Thanks for that pointer! When I searched Digikey, I wasn't able to find anything that was in the 3-lead TO-220 case. I will definitely check out the Murata units, as I suspect they perform better than this one. The Cui parts are also available

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Chris Albertson
Surprisingly good as a drop-in replacement. Question: Suppose you are doing a new design and had space on the PCB for one more small passive part. I wonder how the performance of the switcher with an LC filter compares with the 7805.Yes, I think this is fair. It is a trade off, It costs me

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread John Ackermann N8UR
And Digikey does stock the Murata part, for about $4.30. Why I couldn't find it when searching their site for switching regulators, I don't know. John On 12/04/2016 02:39 PM, John Ackermann N8UR wrote: Thanks for that pointer! When I searched Digikey, I wasn't able to find anything that

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Poul-Henning Kamp
In message <5844656d.5010...@febo.com>, John Ackermann N8UR writes: >I found a cute little switching regulator that's a drop-in replacement >for an LM7805: http://www.ebay.com/itm/261243604047 Traco has had the TSN and TSR series for some years now, and they perform nicely in all applic

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread John Ackermann N8UR
Thanks for that pointer! When I searched Digikey, I wasn't able to find anything that was in the 3-lead TO-220 case. I will definitely check out the Murata units, as I suspect they perform better than this one. John On 12/04/2016 02:01 PM, Adrian Godwin wrote: Thanks for this. I've seen

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread jimlux
On 12/4/16 10:50 AM, John Ackermann N8UR wrote: I found a cute little switching regulator that's a drop-in replacement for an LM7805: http://www.ebay.com/itm/261243604047 I got a couple to play with, mainly to see how bad the noise would be. Here are spectrum analyzer and PN shots comparing a ch

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Adrian Godwin
Thanks for this. I've seen something similar from Murata : http://uk.farnell.com/murata-power-solutions/oki-78sr-5-1-5-w36-c/converter-dc-dc-1-o-p-7-5w-1-5a/dp/2102101 Since they're a mainstream supplier of inductors they may have managed better performance - it would be interesting to compare.

Re: [time-nuts] Switching regulator replacement for 7805

2016-12-04 Thread Attila Kinali
On Sun, 4 Dec 2016 13:50:21 -0500 John Ackermann N8UR wrote: > I found a cute little switching regulator that's a drop-in replacement > for an LM7805: http://www.ebay.com/itm/261243604047 > > I got a couple to play with, mainly to see how bad the noise would be. > Here are spectrum analyzer an