Re: [TLS] Draft 18 review: Downgrade protection

2016-11-23 Thread Olivier Levillain
Hi, > Thanks for your comments. I do want this section to be clear. > > It would be very helpful if you formatted this as a PR. That would make it > easier to understand the changes in this text. The text has been proposed as PR 775 (https://github.com/tlswg/tls13-spec/pull/775). olivier

Re: [TLS] Draft 18 review: Downgrade protection

2016-11-22 Thread Eric Rescorla
Hi Olivier, Thanks for your comments. I do want this section to be clear. It would be very helpful if you formatted this as a PR. That would make it easier to understand the changes in this text. Thanks, -Ekr On Tue, Nov 22, 2016 at 11:01 AM, Olivier Levillain <

[TLS] Draft 18 review: Downgrade protection

2016-11-22 Thread Olivier Levillain
Hi list, I am sorry for the very late answer concerning draft 18, but we (ANSSI) have several remarks after proof-reading the current specification. We are sorry for the multiple long messages. If the WG is interested by some of our concerns/proposals, we would be glad to propose some PRs. =