Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-15 Thread Henri Gomez
Costin Manolache wrote: I would like to propose a new mailing list. The list will be closed to commiters only. The main purpose will be discussions of security and other special issues. This should avoid [Cc] threads. The main target should be active commiters - so it should start

RE: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-15 Thread Reddy.Thirumal
I agree with the proposal * ** *** ** * ** *** ** * ** *** ** * This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. Any views or opinions presented are solely those of the author, and do not

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-15 Thread Bob Schulze
[X] I agree with the proposal [ ] I don't agree with the proposal Fine for another non-committer. PLS cont. to read the dev list too ;-) Bob Costin Manolache wrote: I would like to propose a new mailing list. The list will be closed to commiters only. The main purpose will be discussions

RE: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-15 Thread Larry Isaacs
-Original Message- From: Costin Manolache [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Monday, October 14, 2002 1:24 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list I would like to propose a new mailing list. The list will be closed to commiters only. The main purpose

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-15 Thread Glenn Nielsen
Costin Manolache wrote: I would like to propose a new mailing list. The list will be closed to commiters only. The main purpose will be discussions of security and other special issues. This should avoid [Cc] threads. The main target should be active commiters - so it should start

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-15 Thread Ian Darwin
The list will be closed to commiters only. The main purpose will be discussions of security and other special issues. This should avoid [Cc] threads. The main target should be active commiters - so it should start empty. This is a majority vote. [X ] I agree with the proposal

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Remy Maucherat
Costin Manolache wrote: I would like to propose a new mailing list. The list will be closed to commiters only. The main purpose will be discussions of security and other special issues. This should avoid [Cc] threads. The main target should be active commiters - so it should start

RE: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Jason Corley
Though I'm not a committer and thus can't vote I think a legitimate concern created by a list like this would be that the real bulk of threads that should occur on the tomcat developer list might migrate into this closed list and away from the more public view. Just a thought to consider.

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Sam Ruby
The proposal needs to identify a moderator. The moderator will be the one who approves subscription requests (as well as filtering out spam). - Sam Ruby -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Bill Barker
- Original Message - From: Costin Manolache [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, October 14, 2002 10:24 AM Subject: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list I would like to propose a new mailing list. The list will be closed to commiters only. The main purpose will be

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Costin Manolache
Sam Ruby wrote: The proposal needs to identify a moderator. The moderator will be the one who approves subscription requests (as well as filtering out spam). I can do that. ( unless someone else wants to ). -- Costin -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Costin Manolache
Bill Barker wrote: I would like to propose a new mailing list. The list will be closed to commiters only. The main purpose will be discussions of security and other special issues. This should avoid [Cc] threads. The main target should be active commiters - so it should start empty.

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Chuck Murcko
There's currently a call for project committers to be on the [EMAIL PROTECTED] list. This list intends to be the clearinghouse for all ASF project related security issues, not just httpd. Costin, Craig, et al.: the deal seems to be that each major project version have someone who's a

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Pier Fumagalli
On 14/10/02 19:45, Sam Ruby [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The proposal needs to identify a moderator. The moderator will be the one who approves subscription requests (as well as filtering out spam). And AFAIK, we've roughly always said no to extra mailing list (but -dev -cvs and -users) to keep

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Costin Manolache
Chuck Murcko wrote: There's currently a call for project committers to be on the [EMAIL PROTECTED] list. This list intends to be the clearinghouse for all ASF project related security issues, not just httpd. Costin, Craig, et al.: the deal seems to be that each major project version have

RE: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Costin Manolache
Jason Corley wrote: Though I'm not a committer and thus can't vote I think a legitimate concern created by a list like this would be that the real bulk of threads that should occur on the tomcat developer list might migrate into this closed list and away from the more public view. Just a

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Chuck Murcko
On Monday, October 14, 2002, at 01:40 PM, Costin Manolache wrote: Chuck Murcko wrote: There's currently a call for project committers to be on the [EMAIL PROTECTED] list. This list intends to be the clearinghouse for all ASF project related security issues, not just httpd. Costin, Craig,

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Bojan Smojver
On Tue, 2002-10-15 at 03:24, Costin Manolache wrote: I would like to propose a new mailing list. The list will be closed to commiters only. The main purpose will be discussions of security and other special issues. This should avoid [Cc] threads. The main target should be active

Re: [VOTE] tomcat-commiters list

2002-10-14 Thread Jean-Francois Arcand
Costin Manolache wrote: I would like to propose a new mailing list. The list will be closed to commiters only. The main purpose will be discussions of security and other special issues. This should avoid [Cc] threads. The main target should be active commiters - so it should start empty.