Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace?

2002-08-20 Thread Bob Herrmann
Humm. Are the examples Tomcat specific or should they work in any JSP2.0 and Servlet 2.4 container? If they are generic then perhaps keeping them separate would encourage their reuse with other JSP/Servlet projects. Shouldn't every jsp server have a decent Snoop.jsp ? Cheers, -bob On Mon,

Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace?

2002-08-20 Thread Mark Roth
The examples, just as in Tomcat 4, are small, portable JSP / Servlet examples to illustrate how to use these technologies. Because Tomcat forms the basis of the RI for Servlet/JSP, and because it is so easy to use, many developers download it to try their hand at Servlet/JSP development. I

Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace?

2002-08-20 Thread Remy Maucherat
Mark Roth wrote: It would be great to restore the examples (both JSP and Servlet) so that they are deployed on startup and so they are easily accessible. In the current build they are broken links. I also would like to commit a number of additional JSP examples that illustrate the new

Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace?

2002-08-20 Thread Mark Roth
I'm open to that possibility, as long as we're able to have then automatically deployed in Tomcat 5 builds. Vote: [ ] A. jakarta-tomcat-catalina [ ] B. jakarta-tomcat-jasper [ ] C. jakarta-tomcat-5 [X] D. jakarta-servletapi-5 Given JB and Remy's comments, I

Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace?

2002-08-20 Thread Bob Herrmann
On Tue, 2002-08-20 at 11:42, Remy Maucherat wrote: Mark Roth wrote: It would be great to restore the examples (both JSP and Servlet) so that they are deployed on startup and so they are easily accessible. In the current build they are broken links. I also would like to commit a

Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace?

2002-08-20 Thread Remy Maucherat
Mark Roth wrote: I'm open to that possibility, as long as we're able to have then automatically deployed in Tomcat 5 builds. Yes, I was planning to do that of course. The webapps will be built by the scripts from the jakarta-servletapi-5 repository, and the result will be copied to the

Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace?

2002-08-20 Thread Patrick Luby
Remy, Remy Maucherat wrote: I just got a bit lazy after finishing the repackaging in j-s-5, and thought I would do it the next day :-D I don't think it is lazy to put this off. Instead, I think we are all trying to tackle higher priority issues first. Speaking of higher priority

Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace?

2002-08-20 Thread Remy Maucherat
Patrick Luby wrote: Remy, Remy Maucherat wrote: I just got a bit lazy after finishing the repackaging in j-s-5, and thought I would do it the next day :-D I don't think it is lazy to put this off. Instead, I think we are all trying to tackle higher priority issues first.

Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace?

2002-08-20 Thread costinm
Regarding examples/: One think I would like to see is removal of all webapp-related config from server.xml, and moving it to webapps/examples.xml ( there is already code to support it ). Not sure how it would work with the current jmx code ( the saving part), but hopefully that will be replaced

Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace? NEW?

2002-08-20 Thread Ian Darwin
On August 20, 2002 11:42 am, you wrote: The examples are portable and independent of Tomcat, so I want them to go into jakarta-servletapi-5. I posted some time ago about that, and I was planning to do it. Maybe a separate cvs repo? jakarta-servlet-examples? Before I started getting involved

Re: VOTE: Restoring Tomcat examples: Which workspace?

2002-08-19 Thread Mark Roth
Vote: [X] A. jakarta-tomcat-catalina [ ] B. jakarta-tomcat-jasper [ ] C. jakarta-tomcat-5 Incidentally, my vote is A, but I'm flexible. - Mark On Mon, 2002-08-19 at 16:47, Mark Roth wrote: It would be great to restore the examples (both JSP and Servlet) so that they are