Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Amy Roh]

Sorry for the late vote.  I've been on vacation last two weeks.  ;-)

> 
>
> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
> 3. [ ] Other:
>
> B) Catalina 2.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
> 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 4. [ ] Other:
>
> C) Coyote 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
> 2. [ ] No, use:
>
> D) Tomcat 5.0
> 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 3. [X] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
> 4. [ ] Other:
>
> E) Jasper 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
> 2. [ ] No, use:
>
> 

Amy

>
> Thanks for voting ;-)
>
> Remy
>
> --
> To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
> For additional commands, e-mail: 


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Bill Barker]

> 
> 
> 
> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
> 3. [ ] Other:
> 
> B) Catalina 2.0
> 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
> 2. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> C) Coyote 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> D) Tomcat 5.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> E) Jasper 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
> 2. [ ] No, use: 
> 
> 



--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Kin-Man Chung]

> 
> 
> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
> 3. [ ] Other:
> 
> B) Catalina 2.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
> 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> C) Coyote 2.0
> 1. [ ] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> D) Tomcat 5.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> E) Jasper 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> 


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Glenn Nielsen]

>>A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
>>1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
>>2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
>>3. [ ] Other:
>>
>>B) Catalina 2.0
>>1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
>>2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
>>3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
>>4. [ ] Other:
>>
>>C) Coyote 2.0
>>1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
>>2. [ ] No, use:
>>
>>D) Tomcat 5.0
>>1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
>>2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
>>3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
>>4. [X] Other: jakarta-tomcat-5

 >>

>>E) Jasper 2.0
>>1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
>>2. [ ] No, use:
>>
>>
>>


--
Glenn Nielsen [EMAIL PROTECTED] | /* Spelin donut madder|
MOREnet System Programming   |  * if iz ina coment.  |
Missouri Research and Education Network  |  */   |
--


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

RE: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Ignacio J. Ortega]

> 
> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
> 3. [ ] Other:
> 
> B) Catalina 2.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
> 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> C) Coyote 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> D) Tomcat 5.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 

Agree in call 5 not 5.0..

> E) Jasper 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> 




Saludos ,
Ignacio J. Ortega


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Remy Maucherat]

[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
>>D) Tomcat 5.0
>>1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
>>2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
>>3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
>>4. [ ] Other:
> 
> 
> That's a hard one... 
> 
> I would like it to go in jakarta-tomcat, but the current CVS organization
> is a mess and would create more problems. 
> 
> I'm actually more on jakarta-tomcat-5 ( without the .0 - since
> 5.1 will be in this CVS too )

Yes, that makes sense (the current 4.0 in the repository name is 
awkward), and it's an easy change. Unless somebody has something against 
it, I'll consider vote 1. to be "jakarta-tomcat-5".

Remy


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

RE: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Larry Isaacs]

A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
3. [ ] Other:

B) Catalina 2.0
1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
4. [ ] Other:

C) Coyote 2.0
1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
2. [ ] No, use:

D) Tomcat 5.0
1. [2] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
4. [1] Other: jakarta-tomcat-5

I agree with Costin that it is confusing to be
building Tomcat 4.1.x in the jakarta-tomcat-4.0
repository.

E) Jasper 2.0
1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
2. [ ] No, use:



Larry

--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

OFF TOPIC: RE: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Marx, Mitchell E (Mitch), ALCNS]

As a lay person trying to learn, can I ask a question about the benefits
of repository vs branch?  
Since I haven't really used CVS, I don't know the +/-, but would have
proposed:

> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
Use new jakarta-servletapi-5.0
 
> B) Catalina 2.0
Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina-2.0

> C) Coyote 2.0
use new jakarta-tomcat-connectors-2.0
 
> D) Tomcat 5.0
Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0

> E) Jasper 2.0
use new jakarta-tomcat-jasper-2.0

Which would seem more consistent, for someone just trying to dip in for
the first time.  

Mitchell Evan Marx[EMAIL PROTECTED]
AT&T IP Network Configuration & Provisioning Development



-Original Message-
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
Sent: Thursday, July 11, 2002 9:37 AM
To: Tomcat Developers List
Subject: Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories


On Thu, 11 Jul 2002, Remy Maucherat wrote:

> 
> 
> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
> 3. [ ] Other:
 
> B) Catalina 2.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
> 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 4. [ ] Other:

> C) Coyote 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
> 2. [ ] No, use:
 
> D) Tomcat 5.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
> 4. [ ] Other:

That's a hard one... 

I would like it to go in jakarta-tomcat, but the current CVS
organization
is a mess and would create more problems. 

I'm actually more on jakarta-tomcat-5 ( without the .0 - since
5.1 will be in this CVS too )


> E) Jasper 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> 


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:
<mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
For additional commands, e-mail:
<mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[costinm]

On Thu, 11 Jul 2002, Remy Maucherat wrote:

> 
> 
> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
> 3. [ ] Other:
 
> B) Catalina 2.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
> 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 4. [ ] Other:

> C) Coyote 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
> 2. [ ] No, use:
 
> D) Tomcat 5.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
> 4. [ ] Other:

That's a hard one... 

I would like it to go in jakarta-tomcat, but the current CVS organization
is a mess and would create more problems. 

I'm actually more on jakarta-tomcat-5 ( without the .0 - since
5.1 will be in this CVS too )


> E) Jasper 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> 


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Patrick Luby]

Remy,

Below are my votes. I like the idea of using repositories without 
versions numbers for the Catalina, Jasper, and Tomcat code. It always 
seemed to me to be a pain to create a new CVS repository every time 
there is a new release instead of just creating a branch for the old 
release.

Patrick

Remy Maucherat wrote:

> 
> 
> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
> 3. [ ] Other:
> 
> B) Catalina 2.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
> 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> C) Coyote 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> D) Tomcat 5.0
> 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 3. [X] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> E) Jasper 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> 


-- 

Patrick Luby Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sun Microsystems Phone: 408-276-7471
901 San Antonio Road, USCA14-303
Palo Alto, CA 94303-4900



--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Henri Gomez]

Quoting Remy Maucherat <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:

> 
> 
> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
> 3. [ ] Other:

> B) Catalina 2.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
> 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> C) Coyote 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> D) Tomcat 5.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> E) Jasper 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> 

Which make Tomcat 5.0 a glue for edge packages (I feel it more modular)
 

--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[jean-frederic clere]

Remy Maucherat wrote:
> New repositories are needed to host the new Tomcat 5.0 code, including 
> the new servlet & JSP API, Catalina, Coyote 2.0 and protocol handlers, 
> Jasper.
> 
> A) For the Servlet & JSP API, I think a new separate repository is 
> needed (jakarta-servletapi-5 to follow the current conventions). Or we 
> could put it in the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi (and the old 2.1 API goes 
> in a branch).
> 
> B) For Catalina, we could either use a new repository, named either 
> j-t-catalina or j-t-5.0, or use the HEAD of j-t-4.0 (the current code 
> would then be branched).
> 
> C) Coyote 2.0 will be in the HEAD of j-t-c. Coyote 1.0 will be put in a 
> separate branch.
> 
> D) Tomcat specific glue code (if some is needed) would go in either 
> j-t-5.0, the HEAD of j-t-4.0, or the HEAD of j-t.
> 
> E) Jasper 2+ goes in the HEAD of j-t-j. The current Jasper 2 will go in 
> a branch.
> 
> 
> 
> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
> 3. [ ] Other:
> 
> B) Catalina 2.0
> 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
> 2. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> C) Coyote 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> D) Tomcat 5.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> E) Jasper 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> 
> 
> Thanks for voting ;-)
> 
> Remy
> 
> 
> -- 
> To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
> 
> For additional commands, e-mail: 
> 
> 
> 




--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

Re: [5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Remy Maucherat]

> 
> 
> A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
> 3. [ ] Other:
> 
> B) Catalina 2.0
> 1. [X] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
> 2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> C) Coyote 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> D) Tomcat 5.0
> 1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
> 2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
> 3. [X] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
> 4. [ ] Other:
> 
> E) Jasper 2.0
> 1. [X] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
> 2. [ ] No, use:
> 
> 

Remy


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: 

[5.0] [VOTE] New branches and repositories

[Remy Maucherat]

New repositories are needed to host the new Tomcat 5.0 code, including 
the new servlet & JSP API, Catalina, Coyote 2.0 and protocol handlers, 
Jasper.

A) For the Servlet & JSP API, I think a new separate repository is 
needed (jakarta-servletapi-5 to follow the current conventions). Or we 
could put it in the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi (and the old 2.1 API goes 
in a branch).

B) For Catalina, we could either use a new repository, named either 
j-t-catalina or j-t-5.0, or use the HEAD of j-t-4.0 (the current code 
would then be branched).

C) Coyote 2.0 will be in the HEAD of j-t-c. Coyote 1.0 will be put in a 
separate branch.

D) Tomcat specific glue code (if some is needed) would go in either 
j-t-5.0, the HEAD of j-t-4.0, or the HEAD of j-t.

E) Jasper 2+ goes in the HEAD of j-t-j. The current Jasper 2 will go in 
a branch.



A) Servlet 2.4 & JSP 2.0 API
1. [ ] Use new jakarta-servletapi-5
2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-servletapi
3. [ ] Other:

B) Catalina 2.0
1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-catalina
2. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
4. [ ] Other:

C) Coyote 2.0
1. [ ] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-connectors
2. [ ] No, use:

D) Tomcat 5.0
1. [ ] Use new jakarta-tomcat-5.0
2. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-4.0
3. [ ] Use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat
4. [ ] Other:

E) Jasper 2.0
1. [ ] Yes, use the HEAD of jakarta-tomcat-jasper
2. [ ] No, use:



Thanks for voting ;-)

Remy


--
To unsubscribe, e-mail:   
For additional commands, e-mail: