Re: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-13 Thread Tim Funk
Given all the comments, I think we'll go with the path of least resistance and use a SF account. Then when and if the time comes, a merge can go back into Tomcat if there is a desire. -Tim Tim Funk wrote: As part of the Google SOC. Google accepted the tomcat-reverse-proxy project to be

Re: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-12 Thread jean-frederic clere
Tim Funk wrote: As part of the Google SOC. Google accepted the tomcat-reverse-proxy project to be executed by Anders Nyman ( anders.nyman at gmail d ot com ) The scope of the project is to let Tomcat act a reverse proxy by extending the balancer webapp. To make it easier to get the job

Re: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-12 Thread William A. Rowe, Jr.
At 01:25 PM 7/11/2005, you wrote: William A. Rowe, Jr. wrote: It's important for students involved with SoC to learn to use the tools of our organization; I don't agree with you. The Tomcat is not place for some 'sandbox' projects. If the ASF have some agreement with Google then it should have

Re: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-12 Thread Mladen Turk
William A. Rowe, Jr. wrote: At 01:25 PM 7/11/2005, you wrote: If the ASF have some agreement with Google then it should have created a 'SoC Google sandbox' not trying to force every project to create a 'Google sandbox'. So it's unusual, and we aren't handing away keys to the entire kingdom.

Re: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-12 Thread Remy Maucherat
William A. Rowe, Jr. wrote: At 01:25 PM 7/11/2005, you wrote: William A. Rowe, Jr. wrote: It's important for students involved with SoC to learn to use the tools of our organization; I don't agree with you. The Tomcat is not place for some 'sandbox' projects. If the ASF have some agreement

Re: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-12 Thread William A. Rowe, Jr.
At 03:48 AM 7/12/2005, Mladen Turk wrote: Well if Tim wants to mentor that project, then fine with me. I'm sure he will ensure the integrity of the Tomcat source outside that 'sandbox' repository. Exactly the point; there were no SoC participants who did not have mentors. If this slides into

[VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-11 Thread Tim Funk
As part of the Google SOC. Google accepted the tomcat-reverse-proxy project to be executed by Anders Nyman ( anders.nyman at gmail d ot com ) The scope of the project is to let Tomcat act a reverse proxy by extending the balancer webapp. To make it easier to get the job done this summer

RE: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-11 Thread Yoav Shapira
Hi, As part of the Google SOC. Google accepted the tomcat-reverse-proxy project to be executed by Anders Nyman ( anders.nyman at gmail d ot com ) The scope of the project is to let Tomcat act a reverse proxy by extending the balancer webapp. To make it easier to get the job done this

Re: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-11 Thread Mladen Turk
Tim Funk wrote: As part of the Google SOC. Google accepted the tomcat-reverse-proxy project to be executed by Anders Nyman ( anders.nyman at gmail d ot com ) [ ] Sounds good to me [ ] I'm indifferent [X] I don't like it. Here's why IMO the reverse proxy is a good thing to be done, and

Re: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-11 Thread William A. Rowe, Jr.
At 12:52 PM 7/11/2005, Mladen Turk wrote: I have developed, and I am developing the majority of the code without being connected to the CVS all the time. It's important for students involved with SoC to learn to use the tools of our organization; and it's equally important that we capture the

Re: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-11 Thread Mladen Turk
William A. Rowe, Jr. wrote: It's important for students involved with SoC to learn to use the tools of our organization; I don't agree with you. The Tomcat is not place for some 'sandbox' projects. If the ASF have some agreement with Google then it should have created a 'SoC Google sandbox'

Re: [VOTE] SOC temporary committer Anders Nyman

2005-07-11 Thread Remy Maucherat
Tim Funk wrote: As part of the Google SOC. Google accepted the tomcat-reverse-proxy project to be executed by Anders Nyman ( anders.nyman at gmail d ot com ) The scope of the project is to let Tomcat act a reverse proxy by extending the balancer webapp. To make it easier to get the job