RE: Classpath Issues, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations...

2002-10-10 Thread Shapira, Yoav
Hi, Wow, what a long message ;) I don't have time to reply to everything, but the general answer is: tomcat is a servlet/JSP container at this point. Not a J2EE container. Inter-operating with remote J2EE servers, at least for us, has proven easy. We've never used tomcat 3.x, only 4.x, so I

RE: Classpath Issues, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations...

2002-10-10 Thread Andrew Gilbert
of J2EE ownership and maintenance. Hopefully someone at Sun is listening... -Original Message- From: Shapira, Yoav [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Thursday, October 10, 2002 9:28 AM To: Tomcat Users List Subject: RE: Classpath Issues, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations

RE: Classpath Issues, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations...

2002-10-10 Thread Andrew Gilbert
, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations... Yoav and JeanFrancios, Thank you both for your replies. They were helpful and somewhat reassuring. At the general level: We are aware that Tomcat is not a full J2EE container. But servlets calling EJB's is bread

RE: Classpath Issues, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations...

2002-10-10 Thread Andrew Gilbert
-Original Message- From: Andrew Gilbert Sent: Thursday, October 10, 2002 3:39 PM To: Tomcat Users List Cc: 'Craig R. McClanahan'; 'Jean-Francois Arcand'; 'Shapira, Yoav'; Tim Segall Subject: RE: Classpath Issues, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations... Craig, I

RE: Classpath Issues, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations...

2002-10-10 Thread Andrew Gilbert
Issues, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations... Should I understand this all to say that Tomcat is not at all J2EE 1.3 compliant? That's a fair one-liner summary. The more correct answer is that Tomcat complies with all of the mandatory Servlet 2.3 and JSP 1.2

Classpath Issues, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations...

2002-10-09 Thread Andrew Gilbert
We are finding this a particularly frustrating experience, and it seems to be a weak point either/or both in specification and implementation (or a fatal flaw in our basic approach - but would add we are consistent at least with the intent of the EJB specs). Would appreciate input and

Re: Classpath Issues, Tomcat 4.X and J2EE Interoperability frustrations...

2002-10-09 Thread Jean-Francois Arcand
Andrew Gilbert wrote: We are finding this a particularly frustrating experience, and it seems to be a weak point either/or both in specification and implementation (or a fatal flaw in our basic approach - but would add we are consistent at least with the intent of the EJB specs). Would