Re: [tor-dev] How many exits exit from an IP address different than their OR address? (10.7%)

2016-01-17 Thread David Fifield
On Sun, Jan 17, 2016 at 10:24:47PM +, cacahuatl wrote: > On Sun, Jan 17, 2016 at 01:01:03PM +0100, coderman wrote: > > misguided because it won't work as you expect, the right way to check > > is to build circuits and see where they exit from. you can do this > > yourself! > > Tor Project

Re: [tor-dev] How many exits exit from an IP address different than their OR address? (10.7%)

2016-01-17 Thread coderman
On 1/14/16, Virgil Griffith wrote: > In our quantifications of relay diversity, knowing the IP addresses that > traffic exits from is important. Ways to have this information correctly > reported would be very helpful. i want to be very clear: asking relays to report their

Re: [tor-dev] How many exits exit from an IP address different than their OR address? (10.7%)

2016-01-13 Thread grarpamp
On Tue, Jan 12, 2016 at 9:58 AM, coderman wrote: > this is the proper situation. only question is who would have a > compelling use for separating outbound OR connections and outbound > Exit traffic, as per #17975? Bandwidth peering contracts preferential to push or eyeball

Re: [tor-dev] How many exits exit from an IP address different than their OR address? (10.7%)

2016-01-13 Thread coderman
On 1/13/16, grarpamp wrote: > On Tue, Jan 12, 2016 at 9:58 AM, coderman wrote: >> ... only question is who would have a >> compelling use for separating outbound OR connections and outbound >> Exit traffic, as per #17975? > > Bandwidth peering contracts

Re: [tor-dev] How many exits exit from an IP address different than their OR address? (10.7%)

2016-01-13 Thread grarpamp
On Wed, Jan 13, 2016 at 4:27 AM, coderman wrote: >>> ... only question is who would have a >>> compelling use for separating outbound OR connections and outbound >>> Exit traffic, as per #17975? >> >> Bandwidth peering contracts preferential to push or eyeball traffic. >

Re: [tor-dev] How many exits exit from an IP address different than their OR address? (10.7%)

2016-01-13 Thread Virgil Griffith
In our quantifications of relay diversity, knowing the IP addresses that traffic exits from is important. Ways to have this information correctly reported would be very helpful. -V On Thu, 14 Jan 2016 at 03:01 grarpamp wrote: > On Wed, Jan 13, 2016 at 4:27 AM, coderman

Re: [tor-dev] How many exits exit from an IP address different than their OR address? (10.7%)

2016-01-12 Thread Fabio Pietrosanti (naif) - lists
On 1/12/16 4:43 AM, David Fifield wrote: > I wanted to know how many exits exit from an address that is different > from their OR address. The answer is about 10.7%, 109/1018 exits. The > interesting part is that of those 109 mismatches, 87 have an exit > address that differs from the OR address

Re: [tor-dev] How many exits exit from an IP address different than their OR address? (10.7%)

2016-01-12 Thread Tim Wilson-Brown - teor
> On 12 Jan 2016, at 21:01, Fabio Pietrosanti (naif) - lists > wrote: > > > > On 1/12/16 4:43 AM, David Fifield wrote: >> I wanted to know how many exits exit from an address that is different >> from their OR address. The answer is about 10.7%, 109/1018 exits. The >>

Re: [tor-dev] How many exits exit from an IP address different than their OR address? (10.7%)

2016-01-12 Thread coderman
On 1/12/16, Tim Wilson-Brown - teor wrote: > ... > The current tor implementation simply calls connect() if OutBoundBindAddress > is not set for the destination address family. > This means that the connection will be made from a source address based on > the routing table

[tor-dev] How many exits exit from an IP address different than their OR address? (10.7%)

2016-01-11 Thread David Fifield
I wanted to know how many exits exit from an address that is different from their OR address. The answer is about 10.7%, 109/1018 exits. The interesting part is that of those 109 mismatches, 87 have an exit address that differs from the OR address in all four octets; i.e., the IP addresses used by