Re: [tor-relays] descriptor-id calc tool?

2017-03-02 Thread nusenu
>> The introduction points are not chosen by calculating the descriptor-id >> and finding the 3 HSDirs next to it (by sorted fingerprint). > > tldr: HSDir != IntroPoint. > > Introduction points are chosen by random by an onion service and unknown > in advance. What is known in advance is only

Re: [tor-relays] descriptor-id calc tool?

2017-03-02 Thread Ivan Markin
On Thu, Mar 02, 2017 at 01:11:00PM +, nusenu wrote: > nusenu: > > Shouldn't the first 2 or 3 hex digits of your output (after converting > > them to hex) without time option and the actual intro point FPs match > > when run at roughly the same time? > > > > example for duckduckgo: > > > >

Re: [tor-relays] descriptor-id calc tool?

2017-03-02 Thread nusenu
nusenu: > > > Ivan Markin: >> On Tue, Feb 28, 2017 at 02:09:00AM +, nusenu wrote: > Is there a tool out there that tells me which HSDir is/will probably be > responsible for a given onion address (and at what time)? There's no tool, unless you can reverse SHA1. (Or

Re: [tor-relays] descriptor-id calc tool?

2017-03-02 Thread nusenu
Ivan Markin: > On Tue, Feb 28, 2017 at 02:09:00AM +, nusenu wrote: Is there a tool out there that tells me which HSDir is/will probably be responsible for a given onion address (and at what time)? >>> >>> There's no tool, unless you can reverse SHA1. >>> (Or brute-force a set of

Re: [tor-relays] descriptor-id calc tool?

2017-02-28 Thread Ivan Markin
On Tue, Feb 28, 2017 at 02:09:00AM +, nusenu wrote: > >> Is there a tool out there that tells me which HSDir is/will probably be > >> responsible for a given onion address (and at what time)? > > > > There's no tool, unless you can reverse SHA1. > > (Or brute-force a set of popular onion

Re: [tor-relays] descriptor-id calc tool?

2017-02-27 Thread nusenu
nusenu: >>> Is there a tool out there that tells me which HSDir is/will probably be >>> responsible for a given onion address (and at what time)? >> >> There's no tool, unless you can reverse SHA1. >> (Or brute-force a set of popular onion addresses.) > > I probably was not very clear in my

[tor-relays] descriptor-id calc tool?

2017-02-27 Thread nusenu
>> Is there a tool out there that tells me which HSDir is/will probably be >> responsible for a given onion address (and at what time)? > > There's no tool, unless you can reverse SHA1. > (Or brute-force a set of popular onion addresses.) I probably was not very clear in my question. I'm not