[Touch-packages] [Bug 1738034] Re: Muted Sound Indicator randomly remains red when no sound is playing

2018-07-23 Thread teo1978
> You keep saying these random behaviors. But I am unable to > reproduce any of them on 18.04 & 18.10. Can you explain, how to reproduce in > a concise way? If there was a reliable way of reproducing it, it wouldn't be random. Here's what happens to me: CASE 1: - I mute the volume when no soun

[Touch-packages] [Bug 1738034] Re: Muted Sound Indicator randomly remains red when no sound is playing

2018-07-22 Thread Khurshid Alam
> NOPE, because sometimes it does go back to normal without any action. > Both becoming red and going back to normal are COMPLETELY UTTERLY RANDOM. You keep saying these random behaviors. But I am unable to reproduce any of them on 18.04 & 18.10. Can you explain, how to reproduce in a concise way

[Touch-packages] [Bug 1738034] Re: Muted Sound Indicator randomly remains red when no sound is playing

2018-07-22 Thread teo1978
> That is expected behavior. It turns red only to notify user that volume is muted NOPE, because sometimes it does go back to normal without any action. It's RANDOM, and that cannot possibly be expected behavior. ** Changed in: indicator-sound (Ubuntu) Status: Invalid => Confirmed ** Chan

[Touch-packages] [Bug 1738034] Re: Muted Sound Indicator randomly remains red when no sound is playing

2018-07-22 Thread teo1978
> sound indicator couldn't possibly cover all scenarios why music has stopped playing It can easily do so. It can become red when the amplitude of the output waveform is non-zero and volume is muted, and go back to normal when either the amplitude of the output goes to zero or the volume is unmute

[Touch-packages] [Bug 1738034] Re: Muted Sound Indicator randomly remains red when no sound is playing

2018-07-22 Thread teo1978
Oh, and by the way, often it does not even become red in the first place when some sound starts playing while the volume is muted. Both becoming red and going back to normal are COMPLETELY UTTERLY RANDOM. (or there's some logic behind it that is so convoluted that it is incomprehensible and rende

[Touch-packages] [Bug 1738034] Re: Muted Sound Indicator randomly remains red when no sound is playing

2018-07-20 Thread Khurshid Alam
> The issue is that the icon doesn't go back to normal and REMAINS red when the sound is finished playing. That is expected behavior. It turns red only to notify user that volume is muted. It requires immediate action. Once user unmute the volume it will go back to normal. Music may stop playing

[Touch-packages] [Bug 1738034] Re: Muted Sound Indicator randomly remains red when no sound is playing

2018-07-20 Thread teo1978
Sorry for my deleted comment, since you said "it's most likely THE issue with..." I thought you were referring to some specific issue that you failed to mention. I assume you meant "most likely AN issue with". Anyway, The icon is EXPECTED to become red when a sound plays and the volume is muted.

[Touch-packages] [Bug 1738034] Re: Muted Sound Indicator randomly remains red when no sound is playing

2018-07-20 Thread teo1978
The icon is EXPECTED to become red when a sound plays and the volume is muted. The issue is that the icon doesn't go back to normal and REMAINS red when the sound is finished playing. I find it hard to believe this is an issue with an icon-theme, but if that is the case, could you please point to

[Touch-packages] [Bug 1738034] Re: Muted Sound Indicator randomly remains red when no sound is playing

2018-07-19 Thread Khurshid Alam
It's most likely the issue with icon-theme issue. For me it turns red or blue depending or icon-theme. See https://i.imgur.com/zWYqIrl.png ** Also affects: ubuntu-themes (Ubuntu) Importance: Undecided Status: New ** Changed in: indicator-sound (Ubuntu) Status: Confirmed => Invali