Re: DAS as a component extension or a component, was: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
On Nov 9, 2006, at 2:59 PM, Rick wrote: I'm not convinced that DAS really requires it but I'll let them be the judge of that. Just from what I remembered I didn't see the need so I questioned it. I just think when possible it best to integrate at the highest level of the stack that suits

Re: DAS as a component extension or a component, was: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Rick
I'm not convinced that DAS really requires it but I'll let them be the judge of that. Just from what I remembered I didn't see the need so I questioned it. I just think when possible it best to integrate at the highest level of the stack that suits your needs. Jim, you lost me and peeked my int

DAS as a component extension or a component, was: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
On Nov 9, 2006, at 11:34 AM, cr22rc wrote: My understanding is you would need to implement classes from tuscany-spi to implement your container. This is surely specific to Tuscany. The work that was started by Luciano was as I understood it a Pojo that was an SCA component. That should b

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread cr22rc
My understanding is you would need to implement classes from tuscany-spi to implement your container. This is surely specific to Tuscany. The work that was started by Luciano was as I understood it a Pojo that was an SCA component. That should be able to work in any other SCA implementation. T

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread ant elder
On 11/9/06, Luciano Resende <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi Guys Amita have started work to expose DAS as an SCA container, and we are looking what would be the best way to get collaboration on continuing the task. One of the ways we were thinking was to clean-up what is available today and ge

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Luciano Resende
I think the best possible solution would be what we have discussed as "Declarative DAS", where we would extend the programming model to expose services that interact with a persistent layer in a declarative fashion hiding the implementation details from the service developer, you can see some disc

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Kevin Williams
I absolutely want the best possible solution to integration and this discussion is helping quit a bit. I may misunderstand but, if we develop implementation.das and an associated container, wont this be usable in another SCA implementation? -- Kevin Rick wrote: I quickly skimmed the threads

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Rick
I quickly skimmed the threads on this and I didn't pick up what the advantage was it making this a "container". The only thing I seen was a tighter integration between DAS and SCA. But as I understand it me this is really a tighter integration between DAS and Tuscany implementation of SCA. In

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-08 Thread Jim Marino
Hi Luciano, Is the DAS container a component or binding? If it is in the former, I would think it should go under container/container.das, otherwise binding/binding/das/ Also, the dependency in the module should be against a version of DAS and not the DAS project directly so that it is tr

Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-08 Thread Luciano Resende
Hi Guys Amita have started work to expose DAS as an SCA container, and we are looking what would be the best way to get collaboration on continuing the task. One of the ways we were thinking was to clean-up what is available today and get it into the trunk, so we could share and continue contri