[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting question

2010-01-03 Thread Joel Hughes
Hi all, thanks for your responses. John, I did take a look at the stream api but was put off by the big disclaimer saying it could change very frequently and be down for extended periods. Also, I was kinda trying to avoid the issue I was seeing in search where certain tweets were not being

Re: [twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting question

2010-01-03 Thread Mark McBride
You probably wouldn't use the streaming API 20k times/hr. You would open one connection and consume data from it during that hour. ---Mark http://twitter.com/mccv On Sun, Jan 3, 2010 at 12:15 AM, Joel Hughes joelhug...@gmail.com wrote: Hi all, thanks for your responses. John, I did

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting question

2010-01-02 Thread Zaudio
Hey Kyle, Is that true re the rate limits? I've always assumed that ANY request on an IP is xounted against that IP's rate limit - so comes of the 20,000; and each user has their own rate limit... normally 150 per hour. So an authenticated request comes off both the user's and and IP's rate

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting question

2010-01-01 Thread Kyle Mulka
My experience with rate limiting shows that each authenticated request is counted against that user's limit on your IP. So, you get 20,000 requests per IP, per user, per hour assuming all your requests are authenticated. Any unauthenticated requests go towards the 20,000 request limit per IP, per

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-13 Thread Dewald Pretorius
Craig, I just ran a test, and I can also confirm what you have found. Unauthenticated calls decrease per IP 20,000 Authenticated calls decrease per-IP per-user 20,000 Dewald On Aug 13, 4:27 pm, CaMason stasisme...@googlemail.com wrote: The behaviour at the moment is definitely as-described

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-13 Thread Chad Etzel
Hi There, What you all have been confirming is correct. The intended behavior is 20k per IP unauthenticated, and 20k per IP *per user* authenticated. This is not a bug. -Chad On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 4:43 PM, Abraham Williams4bra...@gmail.com wrote: I've been reading I have confirmed emails

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-13 Thread Bill Kocik
Holy Thanks, Chad. :) On Aug 13, 4:58 pm, Chad Etzel c...@twitter.com wrote: Hi There, What you all have been confirming is correct. The intended behavior is 20k per IP unauthenticated, and 20k per IP *per user* authenticated. This is not a bug. -Chad On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 4:43

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-13 Thread jim.renkel
Just to make things crystal clear, it should be stated that the 20k rate limits apply only to GET requests to the so-called REST-API. Other request types (I.e., POST) and / or other APIs (I.e., search, streaming) have other rate limits. Jim Renkel On Aug 13, 3:58 pm, Chad Etzel c...@twitter.com

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-13 Thread Dewald Pretorius
YabadabaFrigginDoo!! I have no idea what kind of application would need to continuously make 5 authenticated calls per second on a particular Twitter account, but hey, if you can think of one, you know you won't be rate limited. Dewald On Aug 13, 5:58 pm, Chad Etzel c...@twitter.com wrote: Hi

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-13 Thread Andrew Badera
On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 5:44 PM, Dewald Pretoriusdpr...@gmail.com wrote: YabadabaFrigginDoo!! I have no idea what kind of application would need to continuously make 5 authenticated calls per second on a particular Twitter account, but hey, if you can think of one, you know you won't be

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-13 Thread Dewald Pretorius
In fact, with an API response time of 0.3 seconds, you won't even run out of rate limit if your authenticated GET script goes into an endless loop. Dewald On Aug 13, 6:44 pm, Dewald Pretorius dpr...@gmail.com wrote: YabadabaFrigginDoo!! I have no idea what kind of application would need to

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-12 Thread Bill Kocik
Hi Chad - Now that the DDoS attacks are (sort of) behind us, can we seek some closure on this? I'm dying to know the official, undisputed, written- in-stone, we-can-finally-stop-arguing-about-it answer to the following (which I think simplifies the question): If my IP is whitelisted and I have

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread srikanth reddy
With a whitelisted IP you can make 20k auth calls per hour for each user. Once you reach this limit for a user you cannot make any auth calls from that IP in that duration. But the user can still use his 150 limit from other apps.

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Robert Fishel
Wowzers (bonus points for getting the reference) It appears as if each user does get 20k (according to the linked threads) this is I think what they intended and makes apps a LOT easier to develop as you can now do rate limiting (ie caching and sleeping etc...) based on each user and not on an

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Dewald Pretorius
Bob, Don't base your app on the assumption that it is 20,000 calls per hour per user. You get 20,000 GET calls per whitelisted IP address, period. It does not matter if you use those calls for one Twitter account or 10,000 Twitter accounts. If the API is currently behaving differently, then it

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Robert Fishel
Well it seems as though Twitter is saying that 20k calls per user is the intended functionality. Chad or someone else can you confirm this? Also if the correct functionality is 20k per ip per hour will you then fail over to 150 per user per hour or is it cut off? Thanks -Bob On Thu, Aug 6,

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Chad Etzel
Hi Inspector Gadget, er... Bob, Yes, the current whitelisted IP rate-limit allows 20k calls per hour *per user* on Basic Auth or OAuth or a combination thereof. Go, go gadget data! -Chad Twitter Platform Support On Thu, Aug 6, 2009 at 12:13 PM, Robert Fishelbobfis...@gmail.com wrote: Well

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Chad Etzel
Good questions. I agree the phrasing surrounding this topic in the documentation is not extremely clear. I am digging for answers. -Chad On Thu, Aug 6, 2009 at 12:44 PM, Jesse Stayjesses...@gmail.com wrote: Chad, did that change recently?  I was told by Alex and others there that it was 20,000

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Dewald Pretorius
Chad, Are you 100% sure of that? I mean, in terms of rate limiting that simply does not make sense. For my site, TweetLater.com, it would mean I have an effective hourly rate limit, per IP address, of 2 BILLION IP GET calls per hour! (20,000 per user for 100,000 users). It sounds wrong to me.

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Chad Etzel
Hi Dewald, I asked The Powers That Be about it, and that was the response I got. However, I am double and triple checking because that does sound too good to be true :) -Chad On Thu, Aug 6, 2009 at 1:01 PM, Dewald Pretoriusdpr...@gmail.com wrote: Chad, Are you 100% sure of that? I mean,

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Jesse Stay
Chad, did that change recently? I was told by Alex and others there that it was 20,000 calls per hour, period, per IP. When did that change and why weren't we notified? This will save me a lot of money if it is indeed true. Jesse On Thu, Aug 6, 2009 at 12:37 PM, Chad Etzel c...@twitter.com

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Dewald Pretorius
That would be the same as having no rate limit at all, because really, which app would beed to make 20,000 GET calls per hour on one Twitter account? If that's how it is enforced currently, then that is the reason why the API often gets so overloaded and slow. Dewald On Aug 6, 2:04 pm, Chad

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Dewald Pretorius
Just some background. I talked with Doug about this a few months ago, because I observed in the Rate Limit Header of get calls that the 20,000 number decremented by user, not by IP address in aggregate. Doug informed me that he was going to hand the issue over to Matt, who was on vacation at

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread Jesse Stay
I got the same response from Alex awhile back (and I think confirmed by Doug). And I'm seeing the same results, as well. I'm pretty sure it's 20,000 per IP without regard to user. Jesse On Thu, Aug 6, 2009 at 1:24 PM, Dewald Pretorius dpr...@gmail.com wrote: Just some background. I talked

[twitter-dev] Re: Rate Limiting Question

2009-08-06 Thread srikanth reddy
@Dewald Pretorius For my site, TweetLater.com, it would mean I have an effective hourly rate limit, per IP address, of 2 BILLION IP GET calls per hour! I believe 20k limit per user is the desirable behavior, but i don't think twitter will allow you to make infinite calls in which case they will