[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-26 Thread bcbc
Here are a few from the last week that I've personally been involved with. http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=1494021 http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=1491780 http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=1492209 http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=1490763

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-26 Thread bcbc
A search of ubuntuforums.org with the following search string: Boot sector info: Grub 2 is installed in the boot sector (quotes included) returned 154 results. -- Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/576724 You received this bug notification because you

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-26 Thread Erick Brunzell
I know I'd mentioned previously how updates that triggered reconfiguration of grub 2 in Squeeze follows the safer and saner behavior of displaying only drives rather than drives and partitions, but I recently did a reinstall of Karmic and it does likewise. So this only effects Lucid, and having

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-24 Thread Peter Lenny
Unfortunately, there's a thread at http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=1469755 entitled How many users have dual boot unavailable after upgrading to Lucid? and marked Solved... -- Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/576724 You received this bug

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-24 Thread sojourner
unfortunately the situation is even worse than portrayed here so far , the order of the drives as displayed by the installer is not the same as the BIOS order or the order as presented in Gparted (which I use for all formating and partitioning ) or even consistent from one release to the next . I

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-24 Thread Tom Pino
As you can see from the comments on this bug this is something of a pain. I am guessing but i really think about a third of the problems with booting MS installs that show up on the forums is due to the installation of grub on the MS boot sector. While I do not have that problem as I will not

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-22 Thread bcbc
Just to add to Erick's comment, I am still seeing users being hit by this problem on a daily basis. Although this report says 9 people affected I can assure you it's much higher. Unfortunately most of these people are new users attracted to Ubuntu and it's not very good advertising. So, isn't it

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-21 Thread Paul Murphy
I got caught by this too, dual hard drives one XP one Ubuntu, followed the recommendadtion and lost XP A week of searching and then help... Hopefully this is a simple fix -- Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/576724 You received this bug notification

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-17 Thread arjun
I'm also affected by this. It messed up my windows boot sector because it suggested i install to all if I am unsure. -- Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/576724 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-16 Thread Erick Brunzell
This is a perfect example of the problem: http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=1484965 BTW I've linked less than 10% of these examples that I've personally helped to fix. Please, please help us. -- Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/576724 You

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-16 Thread Erick Brunzell
Apologies in advance if I overstepped my bounds here, but I subscribed Colin Watson in hopes that he can shed some insight on this. I promise I won't make such behavior a common practice but I feel this is giving Ubuntu a real black eye so to speak, and I trust Colin's judgment based on previous

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-16 Thread Erick Brunzell
In post #4 I'd mentioned this being a duplicate, here's another: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/grub2/+bug/552056 That one's much older, prior to my being aware of the issue. Sadly I overlooked the issue earlier :^( After seeing the earliest reports of this I even tried a

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-15 Thread Erick Brunzell
I was just fiddling with Debian Squeeze trying to figure out an unrelated issue but it required my changing from legacy grub to grub2, and IMO their approach at this is much safer and saner. I posted a screenshot in this thread at the forums (post #16):

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-13 Thread chris
This bug makes my dual-boot not work anymore. I've been trying all the recommended fixes, but still have no luck. If anyone has any other suggestions, please look over my thread and let me know. Thank you! http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=1480451 -- Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-12 Thread Erick Brunzell
Still getting these: http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?p=9289108#post9289108 To quote the OP there: During the upgrade it complained about grub not working. It said if i didnt know what drive to mount i had to select all of them, which i did. These are constant. I really can't imagine a

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-10 Thread dino99
this installer is a pure nightmare: in douth never trust it some neurons are hardly needed and this installer with its silly comments breaking everything around, might be redesigned. The grub installer need to remove/purge the previous grub release if it exist, then select the ubuntu partition

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-09 Thread Justin
I was affected on my most recent upgrade as well. http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?p=9270190#post9270190 -- Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/576724 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-08 Thread quixote
I've been helping plenty of people over on the forums who install/upgrade to Lucid and are faced with a nonfunctional computer on the next boot because they misunderstood something in the grub install or upgrade process. It's not always this particular bug, but all user interface issues in grub

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-08 Thread arpanaut
I have to agree with Erick that the suggestion if in doubt select all is an incorrect direction to give and is causing various degrees of problems for many. Especially those with Windows and are installing grub to many partitions rather than just to the MBR of their first boot hard drive. I was

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-08 Thread Erick Brunzell
Just a couple of examples: http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?p=9257870#post9257870 http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?p=9261910#post9261910 That was just in the past 12 hours or so and there were more :^( Recently received this PM: Well my challenge is within swedish forums

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-08 Thread Erick Brunzell
I suspect this is actually a duplicate of this bug report: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/grub2/+bug/571893 I would however prefer the devs decide. -- Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/576724 You received this bug notification because you

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-08 Thread Takkat
I agree that bug #571893 is a duplicate of this one here. We do experience the same trouble here with grub in wrong places when upgrading. -- Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/576724 You received this bug notification because you are a member of

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-08 Thread Takkat
To add a suggestion that can be included very quickly and easily and may well be sufficient to unexperienced user: #5: Change the help text from the tickbox when asked where to install grub: It should recommend unexperienced users to keep the default setting rather than mislead users to install

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-08 Thread Erick Brunzell
@ Takkat, from what I've seen the default is that nothing is ticked and in my experience most novices simply don't know what the various alpha-numerical symbols mean in a drive/partition designation. Surprisingly there is still confusion over the h or s at the beginning and the need for UUID's

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-08 Thread Peter Lenny
Noob sez: It's torture reading this thread! The agony of hindsight. From an existing two-disk, two-OS dual-boot setup - and as a newcomer to Ubuntu - I followed the kindly (over-kindly?) advice - if in doubt select all - not because I was unaware of what the partition names mean, but because I

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-08 Thread Erick Brunzell
Peter, for what it's worth my Ubuntu forum name is kansasnoob. I in no way meant the noob shoes comment to seem derogatory. I had not looked at Linux since Lindows until just over two years ago so I am a noob. But since I'm retired this has become my main hobby and I do sometimes forget that

[Bug 576724] Re: Ubuntu grub2 dist-upgrades result in confusion

2010-05-08 Thread Peter Lenny
Kansasnoob (capitalised as a mark of respect) I wasn't taking umbrage, just hooking in - and following your posts with interest. Yes, the week of head-banging has included taking your advice, but at testdisk Screen 3, I got a non-standard response, which I have posted at: