[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2012-09-07 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
** Description changed: - Binary package hint: software-center + Ubuntu Software Center 5.3.11, Ubuntu Q + 1. Search for files. + 2. Select Files (nautilus), and choose Remove. - After removing Evolution I wanted to get rid of all the related packages - to Evolution, which I would imagine alot

[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2011-02-15 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
The next step, to make *this* bug fixable, is for someone to come up with a way where USC can tell that it is dangerous to remove libcamel1.2-14 but not dangerous to remove evolution. Any omissions in the list of packages that will be removed should be a separate bug report, please. -- You

[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2011-02-15 Thread Eemil Lagerspetz
The issue I described in the other bug https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/software-center/+bug/680385 was slightly different: The problem was caused because software center did apt-get autoremove. The packages removed before the autoremove operation were not critical. -- You received

[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2011-02-04 Thread Ben McCann
I removed evolution-data-server and evolution-data-server-common because I use gmail, so I didn't want any email software on my system. However, that removed gnome-panel with no notice whatsoever. I would like to suggest that we show what packages are being removed regardless of whether it's

[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2011-02-04 Thread mac9416
I agree, USC should definitely let you know what packages are being removed. I had thought that it already did, but perhaps not. But I think it should go a step further for users who don't know what packages are important (my example in Bug #653293 had no idea what gnome-panel was) by giving them

[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2011-02-01 Thread mac9416
If I understand you correctly, Matthew, we have a couple of problems. 1) This message fails to appear when a dependency of ubuntu-desktop is marked for removal: “{title} is a core item in Ubuntu. Removing it may cause future upgrades to be incomplete.” 2) When a very important package is

[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2011-01-31 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
The error message David quotes is defined in step 4 of https://wiki.ubuntu.com/SoftwareCenter#removing. However, The Ubuntu desktop system is the title of ubuntu-desktop, and that is supposed to be special-cased with its own error message in step 3. So, that much is a bug in USC. Removing

[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2011-01-23 Thread David Stevenson
I have just tried this in Natty alpha. If you try and uninstall Cups you get the following message. If you uninstall Cups, future updates will not include new items in The Desktop system set. Ar you sure you want to continue. And if you scroll down the bottom item on the list is The Ubuntu

[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2011-01-23 Thread mac9416
I guess The Ubuntu desktop system is the ubuntu-desktop package. I'm glad Natty warns before removing that. Obviously the warning should be more strong considering the effect of continuing. I had thought this sort of thing was caused by APT's dependency calculation going weird, so the same thing

[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2010-11-28 Thread Eemil Lagerspetz
gdebi-gtk does warn about removing ubuntu-desktop and libsdl1.2-debian- pulseaudio. However, software center does NOT warn that it's going to do autoremove and start removing their dependencies too. -- No warning before removing important packages!! https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/668382 You

[Bug 668382] Re: No warning before removing important packages!!

2010-11-27 Thread Kiwinote
Confirming. The current implementation of warning which packages will be removed returns incomplete lists. ** Changed in: software-center (Ubuntu) Importance: Undecided = Medium ** Changed in: software-center (Ubuntu) Status: New = Triaged -- No warning before removing important