Re: [Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-11-01 Thread James Gibbins
Hi David,This ticket is for the source-list, which is for dns resolver and the config is as follows.   version: 1   config:   - type: physical     name: eth0   - type: nameserver     address: ['xx.xx.xx.xx']    sortlist: ['xx.xx.xx.xx', 'xx.xx.xx.xx'] I believe the only thing that is needed for

[Bug 1698181] Re: Switch to netplan renderer in Artful

2017-10-31 Thread James Gibbins
** Also affects: openvswitch Importance: Undecided Status: New -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1698181 Title: Switch to netplan renderer in Artful To manage notifications

Re: [Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-31 Thread James Gibbins
Hi Scott,I know you're aware of and dealing with netplan issues, but not if you're directly involved with it.  But netplan has serious deficiencies and nowhere near as inclusive or as capable as the current system.  Functions such as source-based routing, open vswitch support, etc.  One release

[Bug 1698181] Re: Switch to netplan renderer in Artful

2017-10-31 Thread James Gibbins
For 17.10 forward, due to netplan being incomplete and lacking too many features, it is unsuitable for production use. What packages need to be added/removed to drop netplan and restore full network functionality as it existed in 16.04? -- You received this bug notification because you are a

[Bug 1664818] Re: Not possible to render pre-up, pre-down, post-up, or post-down snippets

2017-10-27 Thread James Gibbins
You mention that all the examples can already be done by netplan, yet one, he mentioned was modifying iptables, something I use myself, and have yet to find that anywhere in netplan. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-27 Thread James Gibbins
Hey Scott, Been taking a deep dive into the netplan package, a la 17.10. Less than 20 minutes review, and can already see 1/2 dozen things that aren't implemented and will completely break networking in just my environment. Given its current state, I can't believe they even allowed it into

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-18 Thread James Gibbins
Damn, I just realized, netplan doesn't use ifup and ifdown now, does it? That's going to completely break my source-based routing. The important part is as follows: IF_GATEWAY="$(echo "$IF_ADDRESS" | cut -d. -f1-3).254" ip route flush table "$IFACE" ip route add default via "$IF_GATEWAY" table

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-18 Thread James Gibbins
Hey Scott, was going back and forth a bit with Stephane. Something goofy stil, as I was using ubuntu-daily:artful, which should have actually failed, cause daily doesn't have artful, but has 17.10, and images:, is the opposite. so even though I specified ubuntu-daily, it seemed to still be using

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-18 Thread James Gibbins
Well, build with the ubuntu-daily, and there weren't even any files at /var/lib/cloud. I put up a post in lxc/lxd to inquire whether the image actually supports cloud-init under lxd with the new version. network- config, user-data, vendor-data, etc were all missing and non-functioning under lxd.

Re: [Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-18 Thread James Gibbins
Appreciate that.  I always forget about daily.  So spun it up, and due to netplan, everything networking broke, as in network-config was ignored, and cloud-init couldn't use any of it.  I'm guessing that netplan is supported using Networking Config Version 2 — Cloud-Init 17.1 documentation?  I

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-18 Thread James Gibbins
Hi Scott,Not sure if launchpad sends you notice of updates or not.  Let me know if it does.  Was surprised that this message came from your actual address, so you sent, or that's just how launchpad works, but added some comments on the ticket for you to see.  I might be able to use packer to

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-18 Thread James Gibbins
hmm...launchpad doesn't let me edit, so adding this from systemd-resolve docs: Alternatively, /etc/resolv.conf may be managed by other packages, in which case systemd-resolved will read it for DNS configuration data. In this mode of operation systemd-resolved is consumer rather than provider of

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-18 Thread James Gibbins
While I joked about it on github, it looks like sortlist from resolv may very well be superceded by RFC 3484 when falling under systemd-resolve. -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1704402

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-18 Thread James Gibbins
Trying to do some testing real quick and research on systemd-resolve. Unfortunately it doesn't seem there is a cloud-init enabled version of artful yet on ubuntu: to really test. I have looked at what systemd- resolve is doing with it on 16.10 and earlier, and systemd-resolve seems to be

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-10-09 Thread James Gibbins
3 months and not a single response? -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1704402 Title: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config To manage notifications about this bug go to:

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-09-07 Thread James Gibbins
Is this site even monitored? -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1704402 Title: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config To manage notifications about this bug go to:

[Bug 1704402] Re: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-08-20 Thread James Gibbins
Beuller? -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1704402 Title: dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config To manage notifications about this bug go to:

[Bug 1704402] [NEW] dns-sortlist not recognized in network-config

2017-07-14 Thread James Gibbins
Public bug reported: I'm using LXD with Ubuntu images, and cloud-init to do initial setup of container. I'm not sure, but I believe the issue is in cloud-init, but would appreciate a pointer to the right location if not. Currently using network-config meta data, cloud-init takes the following