[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-12-06 Thread Mark Abene
Are people actually reading this whole thread, or just coming here to complain? It's broke! Help me! Seriously, people. The underlying problem behind these issues is with GRUB2. We've already discussed this at length. A workaround solution has been described in detail at least TWICE. If you

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-12-06 Thread Mark Abene
This thread has become completely absurd, and I'll no longer be checking it. People who know how to read have already recovered their installs, so my work here is done. Good day. -- Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/477169 You received this bug

[Bug 477104] Re: After 9.10 grub update can not boot into Wubi install

2009-12-02 Thread Mark Abene
You need to be following bug #477169 for the most up to date info on this problem, as well as a workaround solution. -- After 9.10 grub update can not boot into Wubi install https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/477104 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-12-02 Thread Mark Abene
Agostino: I know for a fact that when I originally discovered the problem, booting into Windows and then trying to boot back into the Wubi install made no difference. Files that read as corrupted in grub2 were still read as corrupted. As per your theory, it is true that if you look through the

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-12-02 Thread Mark Abene
Agostino: really? That's very interesting. The fact that I now have two installs on the exact same machine, one had the problem after updates and was repaired with a separate /boot filesystem, and the other a fresh install with all updates and no problems at all, makes me wonder... Could it

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-12-01 Thread Mark Abene
Agostino: although older versions of Wubi installs made use of rootflags=syncio as mount options for mounting the root filesystem, the current version doesn't. Bug #204133, comment #59 would tend to support this, at least in theory. HOWEVER, my root filesystem is in fact the default ext4, which

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-11-27 Thread Mark Abene
In response to my own previous message, it was actually the /etc/grub.d/10_lupin script called by update-grub which I needed to patch so that running update-grub properly creates grub.cfg with boot.disk for the grub loopback device, and root.disk for the kernel's loopback root device. This and my

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-11-27 Thread Mark Abene
I finally had a chance to test the -15 kernel update. There was absolutely no problem whatsoever with this kernel, as I expected. The only underlying problem is the aforementioned grub2 problem, which I'm now considering worked around with a separate /boot filesystem as a solution, plus my two

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-11-26 Thread Mark Abene
I see two problems evident from some of your grub.cfg files, if in fact you're attempting to make use of a separate /boot filesystem as I recommended: 1) The loopback line should be referencing boot.disk, *not* root.disk. I'm pretty sure that grub is doing this in /usr/lib/grub

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-11-26 Thread Mark Abene
Not to be rude, but the only reason I'm checking this ticket is to help people work around a critical grub2 bug that occurred as a result of a recent major update. I was affected by the problem, immediately came up with a workaround solution, and that's what I'm trying to help people with. We

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-11-25 Thread Mark Abene
Response to 82: if you properly created the separate boot.disk filesystem containing grub, your kernel(s) and initrd(s), it must BE MOUNTED before you run grub-install hd0 (assuming we're talking about your primary hard drive). You didn't mention any error messages after running grub-install, so

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-11-25 Thread Mark Abene
Is this with the newer -15 kernel update? Can you confirm the same problem occurs with -14? Using my method I've successfully restored normal booting ability for -14 and any kernels I've built from the sources associated with that kernel version. I have not yet tested -15, so I'd like to rule

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-11-25 Thread Mark Abene
Alex, can you please upload your current grub.cfg file? If you can in fact boot your -14 kernel by editing the grub boot command line, there's no reason why it shouldn't also work from the menu, unless your grub menu entry for the -14 kernel is somehow wrong or isn't properly being updated. --

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-11-24 Thread Mark Abene
Everyone go back and read #69 and #70, which is a workaround solution to all this mess. Now go read it again. -- Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/477169 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is

[Bug 477104] Re: After 9.10 grub update can not boot into Wubi install

2009-11-24 Thread Mark Abene
As was already commented on, go to bug report 477169, and read #69 and #70. Complete workaround solution to the problem. If it doesn't work, go read it again. -- After 9.10 grub update can not boot into Wubi install https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/477104 You received this bug notification

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-11-23 Thread Mark Abene
You saved me the trouble of typing all this up. :) I would add that it isn't necessary for you to define a loop0 *and* a loop1 in grub, as grub only needs to know about your new boot.disk in order to boot. The loop= kernel parameter referencing root.disk is unrelated, and has nothing to do

[Bug 477104] Re: After 9.10 grub update can not boot into Wubi install

2009-11-19 Thread Mark Abene
It isn't the kernel update that broke anything, it's grub2 losing the ability to see the new kernel file. In all my tests (I've been able to reproduce every single error everyone has gotten), grub2 was always the root cause. As a test, I created a complete duplicate of my Wubi install as ext3

[Bug 477104] Re: After 9.10 grub update can not boot into Wubi install

2009-11-13 Thread Mark Abene
Fresh Ubuntu 9.10 wubi install here. And here's the deal: After updating and regenerating /boot/grub/grub.cfg (which is the same as original), a fresh boot drops me to the grub prompt. Grub2 is unable to read any text files at all now, which is the obvious reason for being dumped to the grub

[Bug 477104] Re: After 9.10 grub update can not boot into Wubi install

2009-11-13 Thread Mark Abene
A few more observations: I mentioned that running grub-install modifies c:\wubildr and deposits a tons of files into /boot/grub on the linux side. The files are being copied from /usr/lib/grub/i386-pc. I have no idea why they're being copied, as a stock install does not locate these files in

[Bug 477169] Re: Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS

2009-11-13 Thread Mark Abene
*** This bug is a duplicate of bug 477104 *** https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/477104 ** This bug has been marked a duplicate of bug 477104 After 9.10 grub update can not boot into Wubi install -- Wubi/Karmic boot: kernel panic - not synching: VFS https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/477169

[Bug 477104] Re: After 9.10 grub update can not boot into Wubi install

2009-11-13 Thread Mark Abene
Adding bug #477169 as a duplicate, because it is. That's exactly what happened to my first install if initrd is updated. If the kernel is updated, it's invalid magic number. In fact it looks like any file which is updated from the original stock install reads as garbage from within grub2. For