Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-15 Thread Len Ovens
On Mon, November 12, 2012 9:48 am, Len Ovens wrote: Well, this has turned into a mess. It started with a simple question. Should our text version of plymouth be versioned. The general response seems to be it should be the same (way) as vanilla. Vanilla has the graphic theme with no version and

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-12 Thread Scott Lavender
On Sun, Nov 11, 2012 at 9:51 PM, Emmet Hikory per...@ubuntu.com wrote: Ho Wan Chan wrote: no no no I mean to abolish the text theme ONLY. The graphical one should remain. This means that we have no output multiplexor when booting on devices that are in VGA fallback mode: as it turns

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-12 Thread Ho Wan Chan
Hmm wait a minute, Ububtu Desktop's own Plymouth theme has version numbers too. Then it means we have to resync every release. That is not better than just changing the version number. On 2012-11-12 下午9:09, Scott Lavender scottalaven...@gmail.com wrote: On Sun, Nov 11, 2012 at 9:51 PM, Emmet

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-12 Thread Len Ovens
On Mon, November 12, 2012 10:28 am, lukefro...@hushmail.com wrote: The long blank screen is because of plymouth not loading when the initramfs loads. This was an intentional decision by Ubuntu to avoid slowing down the boot process by including the necessary video modules, a font , etc in the

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-12 Thread Len Ovens
On Mon, November 12, 2012 10:45 am, lukefro...@hushmail.com wrote: There are other ways to make plymouth start quickly than installing cryptsetup, but that's the easiest way for an end user and least likely to get reverted by some update. The first question for studio is do we want to fix

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-12 Thread ttoine
I think that we should (if possible) let plymouth like in Vanilla Ubuntu. And only changing lighdm. Antoine THOMAS Tél: 0663137906 2012/11/12 Len Ovens l...@ovenwerks.net On Mon, November 12, 2012 10:45 am, lukefro...@hushmail.com wrote: There are other ways to make plymouth start

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-12 Thread Len Ovens
On Mon, November 12, 2012 12:45 pm, ttoine wrote: I think that we should (if possible) let plymouth like in Vanilla Ubuntu. And only changing lighdm. Just to be clear, You are talking about how and when plymouth is started rather than the artwork for plymouth? 2012/11/12 Len Ovens

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-12 Thread Antoine Thomas
Both. For me Ubuntu Studio should behave the same way than Vanilla with our artwork. I don't see why we should do something different. And I guess that most of end users don't care, if it works well. If it can save time too for other more important stuff then it is good too. Le 12 nov. 2012

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-12 Thread lukefromdc
One thing about installing cryptsetup by default as a means of starting plymouth early: it does not require any changes from a vanilla install of Ubuntu, as an early start to plymouth is then the normal behavior in Ubuntu. Nothing to maintain but the theme, the rest is upstream Ubuntu,

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-12 Thread Len Ovens
On Mon, November 12, 2012 3:18 pm, lukefro...@hushmail.com wrote: One thing about installing cryptsetup by default as a means of starting plymouth early: it does not require any changes from a vanilla install of Ubuntu, as an early start to plymouth is then the normal behavior in Ubuntu.

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-12 Thread Emmet Hikory
Len Ovens wrote: On Mon, November 12, 2012 10:28 am, lukefro...@hushmail.com wrote: Interesting. I was not aware plymouth started so late on installs. I was under the assumption it still started in initramfs. In short, there are two cases where plymouth actually works right: live

Plymouth text version

2012-11-11 Thread Len Ovens
As we are starting a new cycle, The text version of plymouth needs to be updated. There was some discussion and it was noted that the graphics version of plymouth has no version displayed. We are wondering if we should just drop the versioning on the text version as well or not. The text version

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-11 Thread Ho Wan Chan
As we are starting a new cycle, The text version of plymouth needs to be updated. There was some discussion and it was noted that the graphics version of plymouth has no version displayed. We are wondering if we should just drop the versioning on the text version as well or not. The text

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-11 Thread Kaj Ailomaa
On Sun, 11 Nov 2012 16:05:08 +0100, Len Ovens l...@ovenwerks.net wrote: As we are starting a new cycle, The text version of plymouth needs to be updated. There was some discussion and it was noted that the graphics version of plymouth has no version displayed. We are wondering if we should just

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-11 Thread Ho Wan Chan
Maybe then we should just completely abolish the themeBut is that possible? 2012/11/11 Kaj Ailomaa zeque...@mousike.me On Sun, 11 Nov 2012 16:05:08 +0100, Len Ovens l...@ovenwerks.net wrote: As we are starting a new cycle, The text version of plymouth needs to be updated. There was

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-11 Thread Len Ovens
On Sun, November 11, 2012 7:13 am, Ho Wan Chan wrote: Maybe then we should just completely abolish the themeBut is that possible? 2012/11/11 Kaj Ailomaa zeque...@mousike.me Since we hardly have time to see it (which is a shame cause it's very nice looking), I barely see the point in

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-11 Thread Len Ovens
On Sun, November 11, 2012 7:41 am, Len Ovens wrote: The boot image maybe able to be made persistent. That is it may be possible to get grub to leave some background up Just some thoughts on this... it would mean customizing grub and the maintenance that goes with that. I don't know how

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-11 Thread Ho Wan Chan
no no no I mean to abolish the text theme ONLY. The graphical one should remain. smartboyhw On 2012-11-11 下午11:41, Len Ovens l...@ovenwerks.net wrote: On Sun, November 11, 2012 7:13 am, Ho Wan Chan wrote: Maybe then we should just completely abolish the themeBut is that possible?

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-11 Thread Antoine Thomas
I am for having the version number in loging screen, even if it is only in a corner. Because when logged, users will note know clearly wich version they are using. Le 11 nov. 2012 16:44, Len Ovens l...@ovenwerks.net a écrit : On Sun, November 11, 2012 7:41 am, Len Ovens wrote: The boot image

Re: Plymouth text version/graphics version ideas

2012-11-11 Thread lukefromdc
Plymouth isn't that hard to customize, though it can take a day or so of work to debug a new or radically modified theme from scratch. Since Jan 2011 I have used the same image for the desktop, plymouth, and grub, so that the desktop background comes up as soon as GRUB starts. My own work with

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-11 Thread lukefromdc
Version numbers on installer Plymouth help people know which version they are using. This is especially handy for a live image on a flash drive, which unlike a CD does not have space to write on and may be frequently rewritten. I think they should be used. On 11/11/2012 at 10:05 AM, Len Ovens

Re: Plymouth text version

2012-11-11 Thread Emmet Hikory
Ho Wan Chan wrote: no no no I mean to abolish the text theme ONLY. The graphical one should remain. This means that we have no output multiplexor when booting on devices that are in VGA fallback mode: as it turns out, in addition to some virtual environments, this is also true for lots of