Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread alan c
On 23/03/12 21:06, Daniel Case wrote: I'm not saying don't evolve, just evolve in a way that most users agree is a good idea Catch 22. Unfortunately the vocal people who do not like something have plenty of placard space and ability to dampen a new flame. Evolution is a risk, a real risk.

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread alan c
On 23/03/12 21:06, Alan Bell wrote: On 23/03/12 20:16, Hakan Koseoglu wrote: soap box Treating users as idiots is not a policy, it's a mistake. As soon as I find a distribution worth installing everywhere, I'll be switching. Mint doesn't cut the mustard. I'm a Kubuntu/Lubuntu user on desktop

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread alan c
On 23/03/12 22:11, scoundrel50a wrote: On 23/03/2012 22:04, Alan Pope wrote: On 23/03/12 21:45, Daniel Case wrote: On 23 March 2012 21:21, Neil Greenwood neil.greenwood@gmail.com wrote: They spent lots of money testing different behaviours In my opinion, this is where the problem lies.

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread alan c
On 23/03/12 22:51, scoundrel50a wrote: .I never once since 11.04 have seen anything about testing, being involved, but I see people on here and have had to ask myself, and there is a tendency to either ignore or react the way you have, and you wonder why people get angry...first I have

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread scoundrel50a
On 25/03/2012 10:18, alan c wrote: On 23/03/12 22:11, scoundrel50a wrote: On 23/03/2012 22:04, Alan Pope wrote: On 23/03/12 21:45, Daniel Case wrote: On 23 March 2012 21:21, Neil Greenwood neil.greenwood@gmail.com wrote: They spent lots of money testing different behaviours In my

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread Alan Bell
On 25/03/12 10:48, scoundrel50a wrote: I am glad that he has been helpful to you, but this thread has shown a different side, one that says, if you dont like it go elsewhere, is that helpful, that is effectively telling people he has no time for them, that isnt consistent.if he keeps

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread scoundrel50a
On 23/03/2012 22:44, Alan Pope wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 23/03/12 22:11, scoundrel50a wrote: oooh and who took your dummy away... Actually my patience is somewhat thin today because we cremated my best friends Mum. Perhaps that has a bearing on my response,

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread alan c
On 25/03/12 10:48, scoundrel50a wrote: On 25/03/2012 10:18, alan c wrote: On 23/03/12 22:11, scoundrel50a wrote: On 23/03/2012 22:04, Alan Pope wrote: On 23/03/12 21:45, Daniel Case wrote: On 23 March 2012 21:21, Neil Greenwood neil.greenwood@gmail.com wrote: They spent lots of money

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread alan c
On 25/03/12 11:08, Alan Bell wrote: little stopping you from actually dragging it in the direction you want to go. Really. Participate remotely online in the developer summit that Oh I perhaps should mention. I had an idea for a minor improvement (I think 'significant' ) in how Launcher

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread Alan Bell
On 23/03/12 21:06, Daniel Case wrote: I'm not saying don't evolve, just evolve in a way that most users agree is a good idea, so how do we define what most users want? Perhaps by doing rather a lot of user testing http://davidplanella.wordpress.com/2011/08/02/looking-for-testers-in-london/

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread alan c
On 23/03/12 22:23, Daniel Case wrote: I've been in the Ubuntu community for 5 years already and don't plan on leaving any time soon, but I think there needs to be some representation of the hacker culture that Ubuntu has built up over the years so that we can find the middle ground, it seems

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread alan c
On 24/03/12 01:38, Liam Proven wrote: However, I do think that Unity in general is not /nearly/ as customisable as Linux users tend to be used to. I would expect more customisable options as time goes on. I have read a statement which said that it was not policy to lack customise options, but

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread alan c
On 25/03/12 11:11, scoundrel50a wrote: its taking me forever to get used to Ubuntu, trying another distro isnt going to workplus, from what I can see, a lot of you are members of other distros too.this distro is enough (I do wish you well with the health problems) I find that

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread Avi Greenbury
Liam Proven wrote: Unity is getting quite mature now. None of what I'm proposing is new code - this is all either restoring features that were one present, or things that have been accomplished by hacks, config tweaks and so on. It's all doable. But it's not getting any more configurable - in

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-25 Thread Alan Pope
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 25/03/12 10:48, scoundrel50a wrote: I am glad that he has been helpful to you, but this thread has shown a different side, one that says, if you dont like it go elsewhere, is that helpful, that is effectively telling people he has no time for

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-24 Thread Neil Greenwood
Well, you can volunteer to support it, and put the option back in. Or pay someone to do it if you don't have the skills yourself. That's the joy of free software. However, Canonical decided they weren't going to keep paying to support it. That's their right too. Neil. P.S. Sorry for the

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-24 Thread Chris Penston
I came late to Computing (in my late thirties as a mature student at University, I'm 56 now). I've been mucking about with Linux since around 1998 when it took me about four days to get a Red Hat release partially working on a laptop. I've been looking with interest at the posts on here for a

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-24 Thread Barry Drake
On 24/03/12 01:38, Liam Proven wrote: However, I do think that Unity in general is not /nearly/ as customisable as Linux users tend to be used to. At the moment, yes. When Unity first came out I was disappointed to discover that it was not based on simple text conf files as is usual in

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-24 Thread Pete Smout
On 24/03/12 11:58, Barry Drake wrote: On 24/03/12 01:38, Liam Proven wrote: However, I do think that Unity in general is not /nearly/ as customisable as Linux users tend to be used to. At the moment, yes. When Unity first came out I was disappointed to discover that it was not based on simple

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-24 Thread Sean Miller
On 24 March 2012 19:41, Pete Smout psmo...@live.com wrote: It is about personal choice but Unity is not mine! Xubuntu here I come! That's how I feel too. Do Canonical take any notes of these lists? Sean -- ubuntu-uk@lists.ubuntu.com https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-uk

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-24 Thread Alan Pope
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 24/03/12 20:20, Sean Miller wrote: On 24 March 2012 19:41, Pete Smout psmo...@live.com wrote: It is about personal choice but Unity is not mine! Xubuntu here I come! That's how I feel too. Do Canonical take any notes of these lists?

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-24 Thread Avi Greenbury
Neil Greenwood wrote: Well, you can volunteer to support it, and put the option back in. Or pay someone to do it if you don't have the skills yourself. That's the joy of free software. However, Canonical decided they weren't going to keep paying to support it. That's their right too. I

[ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Barry Drake
Hi there ... I used to like the way that the launcher used to slide away when there was a window over it and re-appear when there wasn't. Now in Precise, we seem only to be able to have autohide or permanently in place. The Compiz configurator and MyUnity both seem to suggest that I can

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Neil Greenwood
It's policy. The decision was made after usability testing, where users got confused when first maximising a window. where's the launcher gone now? And because the option was being removed, the decision was also made to remove the code to reduce the maintenance requirements. Neil. P.S. Sorry for

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Hakan Koseoglu
On 23 March 2012 19:54, Neil Greenwood neil.greenwood@gmail.com wrote: It's policy. The decision was made after usability testing, where users got confused when first maximising a window. where's the launcher gone now? And because the option was being removed, the decision was also made to

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Alan Bell
On 23/03/12 20:16, Hakan Koseoglu wrote: soap box Treating users as idiots is not a policy, it's a mistake. As soon as I find a distribution worth installing everywhere, I'll be switching. Mint doesn't cut the mustard. I'm a Kubuntu/Lubuntu user on desktop and Ubuntu server but I don't want to

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Daniel Case
On 23 March 2012 20:16, Hakan Koseoglu ha...@koseoglu.org wrote: But the new users don't discover Linux all by themselves, in most cases someone shows them and I don't want to show and talk about Ubuntu to anyone anymore. I discovered it myself, but I agree that the launcher should not

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Colin Law
On 23 March 2012 21:06, Daniel Case danielcas...@gmail.com wrote: On 23 March 2012 20:16, Hakan Koseoglu ha...@koseoglu.org wrote: But the new users don't discover Linux all by themselves, in most cases someone shows them and I don't want to show and talk about Ubuntu to anyone anymore. I

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Daniel Case
On 23 March 2012 21:11, Colin Law clan...@googlemail.com wrote: It doesn't have to be there all the time, there is an option to hide it.  It then appears when the mouse is pushed against the edge of the screen (on 12.04) I noticed this, however it often comes out when I go for the close button

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Neil Greenwood
I know some find it a bit annoying, but Canonical didn't just decide this. They spent lots of money testing different behaviours with users with a range of experience of computers. I believe all the users tested had little experience of Linux. Mark Shuttleworth even had to say that the results

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Colin Law
On 23 March 2012 21:16, Daniel Case danielcas...@gmail.com wrote: On 23 March 2012 21:11, Colin Law clan...@googlemail.com wrote: It doesn't have to be there all the time, there is an option to hide it.  It then appears when the mouse is pushed against the edge of the screen (on 12.04) I

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Colin Law
On 23 March 2012 21:25, Colin Law clan...@googlemail.com wrote: On 23 March 2012 21:16, Daniel Case danielcas...@gmail.com wrote: On 23 March 2012 21:11, Colin Law clan...@googlemail.com wrote: It doesn't have to be there all the time, there is an option to hide it.  It then appears when the

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Daniel Case
On 23 March 2012 21:21, Neil Greenwood neil.greenwood@gmail.com wrote: They spent lots of money testing different behaviours In my opinion, this is where the problem lies. The main people Linux attracts, no matter which way you look at it, are hackers (in the general sense). The reason

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Alan Pope
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 23/03/12 21:45, Daniel Case wrote: On 23 March 2012 21:21, Neil Greenwood neil.greenwood@gmail.com wrote: They spent lots of money testing different behaviours In my opinion, this is where the problem lies. The main people Linux

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread scoundrel50a
On 23/03/2012 22:04, Alan Pope wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 23/03/12 21:45, Daniel Case wrote: On 23 March 2012 21:21, Neil Greenwood neil.greenwood@gmail.com wrote: They spent lots of money testing different behaviours In my opinion, this is where the problem

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Daniel Case
Hi Alan, I appreciate what the design teams are trying to do and I appreciate that it is very difficult (or even impossible -as I have never seen it done effectively) to provide the same operating system that works for both new users and hackers alike. New users like the OS to guide them through

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Barry Drake
On 23/03/12 22:04, Alan Pope wrote: Personally I am in this for the long haul. Each 6 monthly release is fantastic, but I'm thinking years away from now, and I'm happy to persevere through the rough times because I think the long term goal is worth it. Alan - well said! Folk who really want

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Daniel Case
On 23 March 2012 22:34, Barry Drake ubuntu-advertis...@gmx.com wrote:  Anyone who still has doubt, start testing Windows 8 .  'shoot' and 'foot' spring to mind. That's certainly true. But I can't help feeling that everything is heading towards the post-PC era too early. For example, I can

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread scoundrel50a
On 23/03/2012 22:34, Barry Drake wrote: On 23/03/12 22:04, Alan Pope wrote: Personally I am in this for the long haul. Each 6 monthly release is fantastic, but I'm thinking years away from now, and I'm happy to persevere through the rough times because I think the long term goal is worth it.

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Alan Pope
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 23/03/12 22:11, scoundrel50a wrote: oooh and who took your dummy away... Actually my patience is somewhat thin today because we cremated my best friends Mum. Perhaps that has a bearing on my response, but it puts things in perspective. Life

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread John Oliver
Personally, I think that the code should continue to be maintained. The argument being put forth sounds to me like It is not the default, therefore no-one can have it. This argument does not work - look at Windows - the taskbar has an autohide option. Look at OS X; the much gone-on-about full

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Alan Pope
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 23/03/12 22:23, Daniel Case wrote: New users like the OS to guide them through the process, whereas hackers want it to get out of their way so they can be more productive. Two very different approaches, you either confuse one or annoy the

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread scoundrel50a
On 23/03/2012 22:44, Alan Pope wrote: -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 23/03/12 22:11, scoundrel50a wrote: oooh and who took your dummy away... Actually my patience is somewhat thin today because we cremated my best friends Mum. Perhaps that has a bearing on my response,

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Alan Pope
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 23/03/12 22:41, Daniel Case wrote: On 23 March 2012 22:34, Barry Drake ubuntu-advertis...@gmx.com wrote: Anyone who still has doubt, start testing Windows 8 . 'shoot' and 'foot' spring to mind. That's certainly true. But I can't help

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Daniel Case
On 23 March 2012 22:44, Alan Pope alan.p...@canonical.com wrote: Actually my patience is somewhat thin today because we cremated my best friends Mum. Perhaps that has a bearing on my response, but it puts things in perspective. Life is short. I'm sorry to hear that Alan, my thoughts are with

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Alan Pope
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 23/03/12 22:55, Daniel Case wrote: I was just trying to highlight the general problem I've been having and have a constructive discussion on the mailing list to see what others thought, I'm not attacking Ubuntu or Unity in any way and I think

Re: [ubuntu-uk] Unity launcher ....

2012-03-23 Thread Liam Proven
On 23 March 2012 20:16, Hakan Koseoglu ha...@koseoglu.org wrote: On 23 March 2012 19:54, Neil Greenwood neil.greenwood@gmail.com wrote: It's policy. The decision was made after usability testing, where users got confused when first maximising a window. where's the launcher gone now? And