Re: Is it possible to build multi cloud cluster for Cassandra
I will recommend against this idea. And here is why (at a higher level of abstraction) 1. This means the cloud services aren't reliable in the first place. That itself is a big problem. Else with reliability guarantees and multi-region/zone it should be pretty safe to stay in one place. 2. Devil is in the details. None of the current cloud providers behave in a similar manner of operation. Maintenance will become a nightmare. 3. Setting up security and addition/removal of nodes will be tough if not irritating. 4. Huge cost involved in data transfer across different platforms if not inherent delay in replication as well. 5. Potential risk of getting into chase situation amounting up to node failure due to network delays. Regards Devopam
Re: Is it possible to build multi cloud cluster for Cassandra
Hello all I've given a thought to this multi-cloud marketing buzz with Cassandra Theoretically feasible (with GossipingPropertyFileSnitch) but practically a headache if you want a minimum of performance and security The problem comes from the network "devils in the details" Suppose DC1 in AWS inside a VPC and DC2 in Azure inside a VNet One needs to allow traffic between both DCs. Of course, apart from obvious networking stuff like allowing traffic on Security Group, there is much more to consider. If your C* nodes have all public IPs, then the inter-node traffic can go through the Internet, with unpredictable latency and connection bandwidth. Also you need to encrypt this traffic with SSL and manage certificates on each node (and more importantly certificates ROTATION, imagine the surprise after one year when they expire, your production is down ...). Exposing your C* node with public IPs is also risky (hacking, DDoS ) A better solution is to have all your nodes in private VPC and VNet with private IPs and the big question is how to route the traffic between 2 cloud providers using their network backbone without going through the Internet As far as I know (some may correct me if I'm wrong) there is no direct backbone connection between AWS and Azure so you may need to ask a 3rd party ISP like Equinix to provide this kind of link. Basically from the AWS VPC you have a Direct Connect to Equinix, then from Equinix an Express Route to Azure VNet. This is technically possible, complex to implement, and especially very expensive... Of course, the SSL certificates are also required in this scenario unless you absolutely trust your ISP (which you shouldn't) Another thing to consider is the outgoing traffic. Indeed when running repair, if you have a lot of de-synchronized data between both DCs or if you undergo a lot of over-streaming, the bill for network traffic can also be substantial. Most cloud providers don't charge for Data In, but for Data Out :-) All this blabla is about inter-node traffic, I'm not even talking about client/server traffic, good luck! Regards On Thu, Sep 5, 2019 at 8:22 PM Goutham reddy wrote: > Thanks Jon that explained me everything. > > On Thu, Sep 5, 2019 at 10:00 AM Jon Haddad wrote: > >> Technically, not a problem. Use GossipingPropertyFileSnitch to keep >> things simple and you can go across whatever cloud providers you want >> without issue. >> >> The biggest issue you're going to have isn't going to be Cassandra, it's >> having the expertise in the different cloud providers to understand their >> strengths and weaknesses. You'll want to benchmark every resource, and >> properly sizing your instances to C* is now 2x (or 3x for 3 cloud >> providers) the work. >> >> I recommend using Terraform to make provisioning a bit easier. >> >> On Thu, Sep 5, 2019 at 9:36 AM Goutham reddy >> wrote: >> >>> Hello, >>> Is it wise and advisable to build multi cloud environment for Cassandra >>> for High Availability. >>> AWS as one datacenter and Azure as another datacenter. >>> If yes are there any challenges involved? >>> >>> Thanks and regards, >>> Goutham. >>> >>
Re: Is it possible to build multi cloud cluster for Cassandra
Thanks Jon that explained me everything. On Thu, Sep 5, 2019 at 10:00 AM Jon Haddad wrote: > Technically, not a problem. Use GossipingPropertyFileSnitch to keep > things simple and you can go across whatever cloud providers you want > without issue. > > The biggest issue you're going to have isn't going to be Cassandra, it's > having the expertise in the different cloud providers to understand their > strengths and weaknesses. You'll want to benchmark every resource, and > properly sizing your instances to C* is now 2x (or 3x for 3 cloud > providers) the work. > > I recommend using Terraform to make provisioning a bit easier. > > On Thu, Sep 5, 2019 at 9:36 AM Goutham reddy > wrote: > >> Hello, >> Is it wise and advisable to build multi cloud environment for Cassandra >> for High Availability. >> AWS as one datacenter and Azure as another datacenter. >> If yes are there any challenges involved? >> >> Thanks and regards, >> Goutham. >> >
Re: Is it possible to build multi cloud cluster for Cassandra
Technically, not a problem. Use GossipingPropertyFileSnitch to keep things simple and you can go across whatever cloud providers you want without issue. The biggest issue you're going to have isn't going to be Cassandra, it's having the expertise in the different cloud providers to understand their strengths and weaknesses. You'll want to benchmark every resource, and properly sizing your instances to C* is now 2x (or 3x for 3 cloud providers) the work. I recommend using Terraform to make provisioning a bit easier. On Thu, Sep 5, 2019 at 9:36 AM Goutham reddy wrote: > Hello, > Is it wise and advisable to build multi cloud environment for Cassandra > for High Availability. > AWS as one datacenter and Azure as another datacenter. > If yes are there any challenges involved? > > Thanks and regards, > Goutham. >
Re: Is it possible to build multi cloud cluster for Cassandra
you can build cassandra under multi cloud environment ,but there network can be connect with each other.☺ Goutham reddy 于2019年9月6日周五 上午12:36写道： > Hello, > Is it wise and advisable to build multi cloud environment for Cassandra > for High Availability. > AWS as one datacenter and Azure as another datacenter. > If yes are there any challenges involved? > > Thanks and regards, > Goutham. > -- you are the apple of my eye !
Is it possible to build multi cloud cluster for Cassandra
Hello, Is it wise and advisable to build multi cloud environment for Cassandra for High Availability. AWS as one datacenter and Azure as another datacenter. If yes are there any challenges involved? Thanks and regards, Goutham.
