RE: JSF vs Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Matthias Wessendorf
personaly i like the jsf-guys for tables (, ) there is NO need for adding table-specific-html (eg. ) during the loop, like ... see http://www.exadel.com/tutorial/jsf/jsftags-guide.html#column and http://www.exadel.com/tutorial/jsf/jsftags-guide.html#panel same with display-tag (http://display

Re: JSF vs Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Jeff Stewart
I've been monitoring this discussion. I for one like using the struts html tags over the JSTL/JSF semantically strange tags. For one thing, feedback from the HTML developers I work with, prefer html:interate this over the {c:jstl } garboono. I mean, isn't this a big motivation why Struts was cr

Re: JSF vs Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Craig McClanahan
On Sun, 18 Jul 2004 23:56:55 -0400, Rick Reumann <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Craig McClanahan wrote: > > > For applications you are about to start on, if it is your intent to > > use the Struts HTML tags for your view tier, you should review that > > decision in the light of the developments of t

Re: [OT] JBoss, Jaas and Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Craig McClanahan
On Sun, 18 Jul 2004 21:50:19 -0400, Erik Weber <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > So, I am trying to use the JAAS implementations that JBoss provides, > which are configurable via login-config.xml. Now, if you configure that > file appropriately and create a login page that follows the J2EE specs > for c

Re[2]: Question on parameterizing action attribute to html:form

2004-07-18 Thread Andrey Rogov
Hi Rick, there is another way to work with parameter form:action. If you use Tiles in your applications create one reusable tiles lay with elements of design, control buttons and page control. In this case you can use the page with many forms. Then solution can be replaced with . What do you

Re: JSF vs Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Rick Reumann
Craig McClanahan wrote: For applications you are about to start on, if it is your intent to use the Struts HTML tags for your view tier, you should review that decision in the light of the developments of the last few months, since the JSF spec went final, to say nothing of the availability of alte

Re: Question on parameterizing action attribute to html:form

2004-07-18 Thread Rick Reumann
Erik Weber wrote: if you have a single JSP that houses a form that is used for different commands (add, update), you are still going to need two separate form elements in validation.xml, causing redundancy (until "field inheritance" is implemented at least), correct? That is correct, although i

Re: Question on parameterizing action attribute to html:form

2004-07-18 Thread Erik Weber
Rick, thank you for your thoughtfulness and generosity. You made me realize that I can set the form action URI as a form bean attribute in my setup Action class, and then, instead of implementing a c:choose switch on a "command" request attribute in my JSP to set the form action URI, I can just

[OT] JBoss, Jaas and Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Erik Weber
Kindly let me know if this is too off-topic. I ask here for reasons I think probably go without mention: Smart and helpful people participate on this list, and I'm sure many are producing Struts apps that run on JBoss. I am using JBoss 3.2.4. I am trying to integrate my app with JAAS. I have fol

Re: MessageUtils and LabelValueBean

2004-07-18 Thread Michael McGrady
At 04:37 PM 7/18/2004, you wrote: http://struts.apache.org/api/org/apache/struts/util/LabelValueBean.html Regards, John Thanks, John. I have that one. That one is easy. Where the heck is MessageUtils? - To unsubscribe, e-ma

Re: MessageUtils and LabelValueBean

2004-07-18 Thread jthompson
http://struts.apache.org/api/org/apache/struts/util/LabelValueBean.html Regards, John [EMAIL PROTECTED] Ph (09) 372-5010 |-+> | | Michael McGrady | | | <[EMAIL PROTECTED]| | | ady.com> | |

MessageUtils and LabelValueBean

2004-07-18 Thread Michael McGrady
Where the heck is this class? Ted Husted refers to it and its method getLabelValueBean to localize LabelValueBeans, but this is a danged elusive class. Michael - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional command

Re: JSF vs Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Craig McClanahan
On Mon, 19 Jul 2004 10:51:01 +1200, Shane Mingins <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > For a new development initiative, why would you choose to use Struts and JSF > over just using JSF? Or is that dumb question? Or is there a link that > answers that question? > Not a dumb question at all ... in fac

RE: JSF vs Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Shane Mingins
> -Original Message- > From: Craig McClanahan [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Monday, 19 July 2004 5:09 a.m. > To: Struts Users Mailing List; [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Subject: Re: JSF vs Struts > > In particular, though, you need to understand that Struts and JSF is > not an either-or decisio

Re: JSF vs Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Craig McClanahan
> > What exactly is officially to be considered a 'corporate developer'? > Honestly, for I don't know. The common VB guy who neither cares > nor even knows much apart from 'point-and-click and it's done, > obviously'? > A corporate developer is more known by what she or he knows, than by what to

Re: struts response character encoding.

2004-07-18 Thread Jason Lea
Olve SÃther Hansen wrote: Now I am saying false things. I thought my baseLayout.jsp had this entry.. It didn't. So it is enough specifying <%@ page contentType="text/html; charset=UTF-8"%> in the base tiles file if that architecture is used. I think it that should work. But I think I ran into

Re: JSF vs Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Christian Bollmeyer
On Sunday 18 July 2004 19:08, Craig McClanahan wrote: +1. But one thing I always wondered about, and as you brought the term into play here: > I suspect Bryan might be confusing particular tools (i.e. Sun Java > Studio Creator, deliberately aimed at corporate developers) with the > underlying te

VAGRANCY of org.apache.scaffold.text.MessageUtils

2004-07-18 Thread Michael McGrady
Where the heck is this class? Ted Husted refers to it and its method getLabelValueBean to localize LabelValueBeans, but this is a danged elusive class. Michael - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional command

Re: JSF vs Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Craig McClanahan
On Sun, 18 Jul 2004 17:04:44 +0200, Bryan Hunt <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > struts exists and has existed for a long time. jsf is yet another naf > sun inspired attempt to mimic microsoft. > I suspect Bryan might be confusing particular tools (i.e. Sun Java Studio Creator, deliberately aimed at c

Re: JSF vs Struts

2004-07-18 Thread Bryan Hunt
struts exists and has existed for a long time. jsf is yet another naf sun inspired attempt to mimic microsoft. --b Martin Gainty wrote: Sorry for the simplistic question Starting a new project and trying to get a handle on 2 different approaches What does Struts have to offer over JSF? Thanks, ma

Re: struts response character encoding.

2004-07-18 Thread Olve Sæther Hansen
Now I am saying false things. I thought my baseLayout.jsp had this entry.. It didn't. So it is enough specifying <%@ page contentType="text/html; charset=UTF-8"%> in the base tiles file if that architecture is used. -- Olve SÃther Hansen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Intermedia/Aksis - Unifob AS --

Re: struts response character encoding.

2004-07-18 Thread Olve Sæther Hansen
Thanks a lot. I was under the misconception that it was sufficient to encode the baseLayout.jsp I use in tiles with this line. Now I understand that tiles has to knwo the encoding of every file in which it has control over.. I guess the other solution also works well, but I use xdoclet, and henc

populating html:select using string[]

2004-07-18 Thread RamKumar
Hi All, I am a newbie to struts. I want to populate a list box using String[]. This is the code i used in my jsp fileHeaders is a String[] object. When i tried to execute the above, i am getting the following exception javax.servlet.jsp.JspException: Property fileHeaders retu