Re: [OT] Request for comments on DAO pattern implementation

2004-10-09 Thread Michael McGrady
Not sure why, but I have never had the difficulty of maintenance being held up because of appropriate uses of interfaces. I have had the opposite happen lots of times. I am a stickler for the interface approach to most classes. I am even thinking of foregoing entirely the use of the System c

Re: [OT] Request for comments on DAO pattern implementation

2004-10-09 Thread Rick Reumann
Adam Hardy wrote the following on 10/9/2004 7:34 AM: However I have never come across a situation where anybody has changed the implementation when doing an upgrade to their application. It sounds good, but IMHO, never happens. Would be interested to find out otherwise :) All of my classes implem

Re: [OT] Request for comments on DAO pattern implementation

2004-10-09 Thread Adam Hardy
cents.. go for the interface... it will make your life Easier for the future when you want to change implementation Regards marco -Original Message- From: atta-ur rehman [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 08 October 2004 15:13 To: Struts Users Mailing List Subject: [OT] Request

RE: [OT] Request for comments on DAO pattern implementation

2004-10-08 Thread Freddy Villalba A.
nsaje original- De: Marco Mistroni [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Enviado el: viernes, 08 de octubre de 2004 16:21 Para: 'Struts Users Mailing List'; 'atta-ur rehman' Asunto: RE: [OT] Request for comments on DAO pattern implementation Hello, My 2 cents.. go for the inter

RE: [OT] Request for comments on DAO pattern implementation

2004-10-08 Thread Marco Mistroni
Subject: [OT] Request for comments on DAO pattern implementation Dear all, I've contemplated two ways of implementing DAO pattern; and I'm unable to decide which is better :) Any comments on pros and cons of these two approaches will be greatly appericiated. Implementation 1: Have IDAO

[OT] Request for comments on DAO pattern implementation

2004-10-08 Thread atta-ur rehman
Dear all, I've contemplated two ways of implementing DAO pattern; and I'm unable to decide which is better :) Any comments on pros and cons of these two approaches will be greatly appericiated. Implementation 1: Have IDAO interface and let all the DAO objects implement this interface; with probab