Re: [DISCUSS] contribute maven-bundle-plugin to Apache Maven

2013-03-01 Thread Filippo Balicchia
IMHO I think that is good thing Regards --Filippo 2013/2/28 Stuart McCulloch mccu...@gmail.com During the [DISCUSS] rename maven-bundle-plugin to bnd-maven-plugin thread Marcel and Guillaume came up with counter-suggestions involving contributing the maven-bundle-plugin to Apache Maven.

Re: [DISCUSS] contribute maven-bundle-plugin to Apache Maven

2013-03-01 Thread Mark Derricutt
On the surface this sounds like a good idea, I was just wondering about the rest of the felix related maven plugins, such as SCR etc. Currently it's very handy to just hit that main felix page and see the list of felix updates, and felix maven updates, tho I suppose is maven-bundle-plugin

Re: [DISCUSS] contribute maven-bundle-plugin to Apache Maven

2013-03-01 Thread Richard S. Hall
On 3/1/13 14:39 , Mark Derricutt wrote: Also, since the maven-bundle-plugin is technically OSGi not felix only it makes sense moving it away from felix core ( but then, that kinda goes for the other plugins as well ). It's hard to believe this misperception still exists after all these

Re: [DISCUSS] contribute maven-bundle-plugin to Apache Maven

2013-03-01 Thread Mark Derricutt
Personally, I don't think it does - but for those still new to OSGi/modularity it -may- be. It doesn't really matter if it moves or not really, other than the potential added benefit of not having to mention the groupId, and maybe getting the packaging recognized by default ( which afaik

[DISCUSS] contribute maven-bundle-plugin to Apache Maven

2013-02-28 Thread Stuart McCulloch
During the [DISCUSS] rename maven-bundle-plugin to bnd-maven-plugin thread Marcel and Guillaume came up with counter-suggestions involving contributing the maven-bundle-plugin to Apache Maven. This idea has certain advantages - the plugin name would not be an issue (assuming the Maven team