Re: Groovy with OpenJDK 10 and IntelliJ Build - Solved

[Paul King]

The CORBA dependency is nothing to do with Groovy as you point out.

A minor clarification about JAXB. Other Groovy 2.5.0 users on JDK9+ might
also need the JAXB dependency (or a --add-modules switch) but from Groovy
2.5.1 that module is optional and only users of the groovy-jaxb extensions
should be affected. The --add-modules switch won't help from JDK11, so I'd
recommend (only for groovy-jaxb users) to add the JAXB dependency you
mention on their compile classpath and 3 related JAXB jars on their runtime
classpath. See the release notes for more details or have a look at the
build.gradle file for groovy-jaxb if you are using gradle and need a build
that works on 8 and above.

Cheers, Paul.


On Mon, Jul 30, 2018 at 9:17 PM mg  wrote:

> Hi,
>
> we recently had a little bit of time to revisit the OpenJDK 10 build
> problem: As it turns out, it has nothing to do with Groovy, module support,
> or OpenJDK - instead the missing JARs have simply been removed from JDK 10
> (they had only been deprecated in JDK 9 - quick removal after deprecation
> in the Java world will need some getting used to ;-) ).
>
> All one needs to do to remedy the situation is add external dependencies
> replacing the removed JDK functionality to ones project, in our case:
>
> OJDK 10: glassfish-corba-omgapi-3.2.0-b005.jar (for Notes 9)
>
> OJDK 11: jaxb-api-2.3.0.jar (for Vaadin 7)
>
> (All these removals come from the same JEP:
>
> JDK Extension Proposal (no longer a proposal, alreday happening in JDK
> 9/10/11 - e.g. JAXB is gone in 11) betreffend das java.corba Problem, das
> wir gerade gelöst haben:
>
> http://openjdk.java.net/jeps/320  )
>
> Chhers,
> mg
>
>
> On Wed, Jul 4, 2018 at 9:28 AM MG  wrote:
>
>> Hi,
>>
>> does anyone allready have experience compiling a Groovy project under
>> IntelliJ and OpenJDK 10 ?
>> We are currently using OpenJDK 8 and would need to evaluate (if
>> possible) if our Groovy framework has any problems building & running
>> under OpenJDK 10. We are using IntelliJ modules as our build system, and
>> with OpenJDK 10 the Groovy build throws an internal compiler error that
>> NotesException requires a base class from the java.corba module, which
>> can no longer be found. Is there a (quick) way to make Groovy code
>> module compatible under IntelliJ 2018.1.5 ?
>>
>> Cheers,
>> mg
>
>

Groovy with OpenJDK 10 and IntelliJ Build - Solved

[mg]

Hi,
we recently had a little bit of time to revisit the OpenJDK 10 build problem: 
As it turns out, it has nothing to do with Groovy, module support, or OpenJDK - 
instead the missing JARs have simply been removed from JDK 10 (they had only 
been deprecated in JDK 9 - quick removal after deprecation in the Java world 
will need some getting used to ;-) ).
All one needs to do to remedy the situation is add external dependencies 
replacing the removed JDK functionality to ones project, in our case:
OJDK 10: glassfish-corba-omgapi-3.2.0-b005.jar (for Notes 9) 

OJDK 11: jaxb-api-2.3.0.jar (for Vaadin 7) 

(All these removals come from the same JEP:

JDK Extension Proposal (no longer a proposal, alreday happening in JDK 9/10/11 
- e.g. JAXB is gone in 11) betreffend das java.corba Problem, das wir gerade 
gelöst haben: 

http://openjdk.java.net/jeps/320 )
Chhers,mg

On Wed, Jul 4, 2018 at 9:28 AM MG 
  wrote:


Hi,

  

  does anyone allready have experience compiling a Groovy
  project under 

  IntelliJ and OpenJDK 10 ?

  We are currently using OpenJDK 8 and would need to evaluate
  (if 

  possible) if our Groovy framework has any problems building
  & running 

  under OpenJDK 10. We are using IntelliJ modules as our build
  system, and 

  with OpenJDK 10 the Groovy build throws an internal compiler
  error that 

  NotesException requires a base class from the java.corba
  module, which 

  can no longer be found. Is there a (quick) way to make Groovy
  code 

  module compatible under IntelliJ 2018.1.5 ?

  

  Cheers,

  mg

Re: Groovy with OpenJDK 10 and IntelliJ Build

[MG]

No, you pick the JDK for the project/module independently from the IDE. 
One problem is that IntelliJ does not (afaikt - I never had the need to 
do so before) support passing parameters to the Groovy compiler (you can 
supply a Groovy configscript).


On 04.07.2018 01:35, Paul King wrote:
Does the JDK you run Intellij under need to be the same as what your 
project settings point to?


On Wed, Jul 4, 2018 at 9:28 AM MG > wrote:


Hi,

does anyone allready have experience compiling a Groovy project under
IntelliJ and OpenJDK 10 ?
We are currently using OpenJDK 8 and would need to evaluate (if
possible) if our Groovy framework has any problems building & running
under OpenJDK 10. We are using IntelliJ modules as our build
system, and
with OpenJDK 10 the Groovy build throws an internal compiler error
that
NotesException requires a base class from the java.corba module,
which
can no longer be found. Is there a (quick) way to make Groovy code
module compatible under IntelliJ 2018.1.5 ?

Cheers,
mg

Re: Groovy with OpenJDK 10 and IntelliJ Build

[Paul King]

Does the JDK you run Intellij under need to be the same as what your
project settings point to?

On Wed, Jul 4, 2018 at 9:28 AM MG  wrote:

> Hi,
>
> does anyone allready have experience compiling a Groovy project under
> IntelliJ and OpenJDK 10 ?
> We are currently using OpenJDK 8 and would need to evaluate (if
> possible) if our Groovy framework has any problems building & running
> under OpenJDK 10. We are using IntelliJ modules as our build system, and
> with OpenJDK 10 the Groovy build throws an internal compiler error that
> NotesException requires a base class from the java.corba module, which
> can no longer be found. Is there a (quick) way to make Groovy code
> module compatible under IntelliJ 2018.1.5 ?
>
> Cheers,
> mg
>
>
>
>