[Pw_forum] Problem With Total-Energy Convergence vs. ecutwfc

2011-11-21 Thread Eduardo Ariel Menendez Proupin
As Nicola said, what matters are the energy differences. Please, check that the forces and stresses are converged. From a practical point of view that is enough. To be happy, I prefer that the energy also converge. I think the non convergence is the (frequent) fault of the pseudopotential. If you

[Pw_forum] Problem With Total-Energy Convergence vs. ecutwfc

2011-11-21 Thread Nicola Marzari
Dear Vic, as you correctly point out, differences in total energy are very well converged in your calculations. This is all what matters. Absolute total energies are not yet converged, but those are not relevant or useful - if you think about, what you'll need will always be differences in

[Pw_forum] Problem With Total-Energy Convergence vs. ecutwfc

2011-11-21 Thread Vic Bermudez
Hello, I seem to be having some serious trouble getting total energies to converge as I vary "ecutwfc" and "ecutrho". This is for a slab-model calculation, using PBE and USPP's, for an HF molecule reacting with the surface of Si3N4. The total energy results I get in representative