Re: [QE-users] Problem with PBE0 calculation

2023-01-13 Thread Rameswar Bhattacharjee
Dear Giuseppe and M.V Kondrin, Thank you very much for your suggestion and such a fruitful discussion. Looks like there is no direct way to plot the band structure using a hybrid functional. However, as you suggested this can be done with some tricks and techniques. I never heard about the scissor

Re: [QE-users] Problem with PBE0 calculation

2023-01-12 Thread mkondrin
Dear Giuseppe, Thank you for very pertinent comment. Of course, I have meant stoichiometric materials, not the defect structures. Indeed, in the latter case band structure is not well defined notion, but probably DOS for some supercell approximation of defect structure is more robust.

Re: [QE-users] Problem with PBE0 calculation

2023-01-12 Thread Giuseppe Mattioli
Dear M. V. Kondrin The "scissors operator" strategy can be appropriate in the case of stoichiometric materials, but it may be not when you investigate defects or dopants in a host matrix, where the band structure (and the DOS) can depend on the localization of electronic charge on defects

Re: [QE-users] Problem with PBE0 calculation

2023-01-12 Thread mkondrin
I also performed calculations using HSE06 functional for obtaining electron DOS (using projwfc.x). It is compatible with hybrid functionals and usually provide correct values of electron bandgaps. After that I just used "scissors" operation on electron band structure obtained using standard

Re: [QE-users] Problem with PBE0 calculation

2023-01-12 Thread Giuseppe Mattioli
AFAIK, nscf calculations are not compatible with EXX functionals. There are a few workarounds, like manually adding the band path as "fake" k-points with weight=0 to the regular grid obtained by the automatic distribution used in the scf calculation. I generally perform EXX calculations

Re: [QE-users] Problem with PBE0 calculation

2023-01-11 Thread Rameswar Bhattacharjee
Hi Giuseppe, Thank you very much for your detailed reply. I followed the instructions and was able to complete the SCF calculation. Also, I did an NSCF calculation using the same combination you suggested as a pre-step to perform the band calculation. My ultimate aim is to get the band gap using a

Re: [QE-users] Problem with PBE0 calculation

2023-01-11 Thread Giuseppe Mattioli
Dear Rameswar Bhattacharjee I don't know if this is the actual source of error, but I strongly recommend to use norm-conserving pseudopotentials when performing EXX calculations. You have generally no speed-up with US because ecutrho is more or less often the same, and in your case you

[QE-users] Problem with PBE0 calculation

2023-01-10 Thread Rameswar Bhattacharjee
Hi Everyone, I am trying to get a band structure using a hybrid functional. As suggested previously in this forum I choose PBE0 functional with pbe-ultrasoft pseudopotential. The calculation starts fine and scf iteration converges smoothly. But the job is stuck and does not complete with the last