Re: [strongSwan] Reporting Issue:Old CHILD_SA not getting cleared

2012-04-13 Thread Tobias Brunner
Hi Anurag, We have added reauth=no to the ipsec.conf and retested our scenario once. We could observe from the tcpdump on the node triggering the traffic that even now an INFORMATIONAL message (with Next Payload: Delete) is sent just before IKE_SA re-keying [behaviour is same as was with

Re: [strongSwan] Reporting Issue:Old CHILD_SA not getting cleared

2012-04-13 Thread Ghosh, Anurag (EXT-Aricent - IN)
Hi Tobias, We agree with you that this delete may be for the CHILD_SA. We have tested a couple of times again and it looks like the redundant CHILD_SA are not getting created anymore. :) We would still want to understand that what happens if I want the reauth to happen [reauth=yes] each time

Re: [strongSwan] Reporting Issue:Old CHILD_SA not getting cleared

2012-04-13 Thread Tobias Brunner
Hi Anurag, We would still want to understand that what happens if I want the reauth to happen [reauth=yes] each time for the IKE_SA. In such a case there is always a possibility that during the downtime of the IKE_SA, traffic matching the installed policies will trigger a new CHILD_SA to be

Re: [strongSwan] Reporting Issue:Old CHILD_SA not getting cleared

2012-04-12 Thread Ghosh, Anurag (EXT-Aricent - IN)
Hi Tobias, We have added reauth=no to the ipsec.conf and retested our scenario once. We could observe from the tcpdump on the node triggering the traffic that even now an INFORMATIONAL message (with Next Payload: Delete) is sent just before IKE_SA re-keying [behaviour is same as was with

Re: [strongSwan] Reporting Issue:Old CHILD_SA not getting cleared

2012-04-11 Thread Ghosh, Anurag (EXT-Aricent - IN)
Hi Tobias, Provided below is the ipsec.conf file used during one of the runs [in case it helps in analysing the issue better]. As per the below conf file I assume that reauth is set to yes, even though I do not set it explicitly. Can you please confirm this? # ipsec.conf config setup

Re: [strongSwan] Reporting Issue:Old CHILD_SA not getting cleared

2012-04-11 Thread Tobias Brunner
Hi Anurag, As per the below conf file I assume that reauth is set to yes, even though I do not set it explicitly. Can you please confirm this? Yes, reauth=yes is currently the default. And by using auto=route you created the same problem as recently discussed on this mailing list with Anand

Re: [strongSwan] Reporting Issue:Old CHILD_SA not getting cleared

2012-04-10 Thread Ghosh, Anurag (EXT-Aricent - IN)
Hi Tobias, Thanks a lot for the response. We are looking into the possibilities of upgrading to the latest charon version but it looks unlikely until we are able establish that the issue is really linked to old the charon version. In the mean time we have analysed the charon logs and have an

[strongSwan] Reporting Issue:Old CHILD_SA not getting cleared

2012-03-30 Thread Ghosh, Anurag (EXT-Aricent - IN)
Hi, We have encountered some issues while using StrongSwan charon on our Linux server and would request you to help us out on this. Setup: 1) We are using StrongSwan charon [Linux strongSwan 4.3.1] on our server [we call it NODE A] to establish an IKEv2 IPSec tunnel with a Cisco

Re: [strongSwan] Reporting Issue:Old CHILD_SA not getting cleared

2012-03-30 Thread Tobias Brunner
Hi Anurag, 1) We are using StrongSwan charon [Linux strongSwan 4.3.1] Just let me tell you that we don't really like to support such old releases. It would great if you could try if this issue is still present in 4.6.2. 3) After around 600 sec. from the start, IKE_SA re-keying