Re: Apache Tomcat 8.0.22 server on different machines

2015-06-22 Thread Christopher Schultz
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-
Hash: SHA256

André,

On 6/20/15 7:34 AM, André Warnier wrote:
 André Warnier wrote:
 Christopher Schultz wrote:
 -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA256
 
 Prarthana,
 
 On 6/19/15 5:08 AM, Prarthana Agwania wrote:
 We have a requirement wherein we would like to know the urls
 of each of the tomcat instance running on different servers.
 The scenario is somewhat like,
 
 1. There are multiple servers running on different machines
 say Server1, Server2, Server3
 
 2. There are multiple Tomcat instances running on each of
 the machines as independent instances say, Server1--
 Tomcat1, Tomcat2, Tomcat3.Server2-- Tomcat5, Tomcat6, 
 Tomcat7.Server3--Tomcat8, Tomcat9, Tomcat10 P.S. -
 Tomcat servers are not clustered
 
 Now, is there a way that an external user who does not have
 access to the servers can know the urls for each Tomcat
 running under different servers? Or, is it possible that
 Server1 or Tomcat1 can act as the master and have the
 information about other servers(remember they are not
 clustered)?Can this information be made available under one
 hood and used further to deploy wars or modify any
 configuration etc?
 
 This is something you will have to build yourself. You may be
 able to build something using components Tomcat provides (e.g.
 Tribes), but there is nothing like this that exists already.
 
 Usually, people want to mask the size of their cluster from
 external users. What's your use case here?
 
 
 I think that the OP just explained it above, at the end of his
 message.
 
 Prarthana, you may want to have a look at something like Bonjour 
 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonjour_%28software%29).
 
 Each Tomcat would have to register with the service when it
 starts up, and de-register when it stops.  And then some client
 could find out about the available Tomcats. Looks like something
 for a LifeCycleListener..
 
 
 Add-on : as a matter of fact, someone seems to have a similar idea
 : http://www.floop.org.uk/projects/tomcat-registry Not much there
 yet, but it may be worth talking to them.

Also: https://wiki.apache.org/tomcat/TomcatGridDesign

Note: that's a design and not a product.

- -chris
-BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-
Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org
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=Qiie
-END PGP SIGNATURE-

-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@tomcat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@tomcat.apache.org



Re: Apache Tomcat 8.0.22 server on different machines

2015-06-20 Thread André Warnier

Christopher Schultz wrote:

-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-
Hash: SHA256

Prarthana,

On 6/19/15 5:08 AM, Prarthana Agwania wrote:

We have a requirement wherein we would like to know the urls of
each of the tomcat instance running on different servers. The
scenario is somewhat like,

1. There are multiple servers running on different machines say 
Server1, Server2, Server3


2. There are multiple Tomcat instances running on each of the
machines as independent instances say, Server1-- Tomcat1,
Tomcat2, Tomcat3.Server2-- Tomcat5, Tomcat6, 
Tomcat7.Server3--Tomcat8, Tomcat9, Tomcat10 P.S. - Tomcat

servers are not clustered

Now, is there a way that an external user who does not have access
to the servers can know the urls for each Tomcat running under
different servers? Or, is it possible that Server1 or Tomcat1 can
act as the master and have the information about other
servers(remember they are not clustered)?Can this information be
made available under one hood and used further to deploy wars or
modify any configuration etc?


This is something you will have to build yourself. You may be able to
build something using components Tomcat provides (e.g. Tribes), but
there is nothing like this that exists already.

Usually, people want to mask the size of their cluster from external
users. What's your use case here?



I think that the OP just explained it above, at the end of his message.

Prarthana, you may want to have a look at something like Bonjour 
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonjour_%28software%29).


Each Tomcat would have to register with the service when it starts up, and de-register 
when it stops.  And then some client could find out about the available Tomcats.

Looks like something for a LifeCycleListener..

-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@tomcat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@tomcat.apache.org



Re: Apache Tomcat 8.0.22 server on different machines

2015-06-20 Thread André Warnier

André Warnier wrote:

Christopher Schultz wrote:

-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-
Hash: SHA256

Prarthana,

On 6/19/15 5:08 AM, Prarthana Agwania wrote:

We have a requirement wherein we would like to know the urls of
each of the tomcat instance running on different servers. The
scenario is somewhat like,

1. There are multiple servers running on different machines say 
Server1, Server2, Server3


2. There are multiple Tomcat instances running on each of the
machines as independent instances say, Server1-- Tomcat1,
Tomcat2, Tomcat3.Server2-- Tomcat5, Tomcat6, 
Tomcat7.Server3--Tomcat8, Tomcat9, Tomcat10 P.S. - Tomcat

servers are not clustered

Now, is there a way that an external user who does not have access
to the servers can know the urls for each Tomcat running under
different servers? Or, is it possible that Server1 or Tomcat1 can
act as the master and have the information about other
servers(remember they are not clustered)?Can this information be
made available under one hood and used further to deploy wars or
modify any configuration etc?


This is something you will have to build yourself. You may be able to
build something using components Tomcat provides (e.g. Tribes), but
there is nothing like this that exists already.

Usually, people want to mask the size of their cluster from external
users. What's your use case here?



I think that the OP just explained it above, at the end of his message.

Prarthana, you may want to have a look at something like Bonjour 
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonjour_%28software%29).


Each Tomcat would have to register with the service when it starts up, 
and de-register when it stops.  And then some client could find out 
about the available Tomcats.

Looks like something for a LifeCycleListener..



Add-on : as a matter of fact, someone seems to have a similar idea :
http://www.floop.org.uk/projects/tomcat-registry
Not much there yet, but it may be worth talking to them.



-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@tomcat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@tomcat.apache.org



Re: Apache Tomcat 8.0.22 server on different machines

2015-06-19 Thread Christopher Schultz
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-
Hash: SHA256

Prarthana,

On 6/19/15 5:08 AM, Prarthana Agwania wrote:
 We have a requirement wherein we would like to know the urls of
 each of the tomcat instance running on different servers. The
 scenario is somewhat like,
 
 1. There are multiple servers running on different machines say 
 Server1, Server2, Server3
 
 2. There are multiple Tomcat instances running on each of the
 machines as independent instances say, Server1-- Tomcat1,
 Tomcat2, Tomcat3.Server2-- Tomcat5, Tomcat6, 
 Tomcat7.Server3--Tomcat8, Tomcat9, Tomcat10 P.S. - Tomcat
 servers are not clustered
 
 Now, is there a way that an external user who does not have access
 to the servers can know the urls for each Tomcat running under
 different servers? Or, is it possible that Server1 or Tomcat1 can
 act as the master and have the information about other
 servers(remember they are not clustered)?Can this information be
 made available under one hood and used further to deploy wars or
 modify any configuration etc?

This is something you will have to build yourself. You may be able to
build something using components Tomcat provides (e.g. Tribes), but
there is nothing like this that exists already.

Usually, people want to mask the size of their cluster from external
users. What's your use case here?

- -chris
-BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-
Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org
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=3iko
-END PGP SIGNATURE-

-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@tomcat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@tomcat.apache.org



Apache Tomcat 8.0.22 server on different machines

2015-06-19 Thread Prarthana Agwania
Hi,

We have a requirement wherein we would like to know the urls of each
of the tomcat instance running on different servers. The scenario is
somewhat like,

1. There are multiple servers running on different machines say
Server1, Server2, Server3

2. There are multiple Tomcat instances running on each of the machines
as independent instances say, Server1-- Tomcat1, Tomcat2,
Tomcat3.Server2-- Tomcat5, Tomcat6,
Tomcat7.Server3--Tomcat8, Tomcat9, Tomcat10
P.S. - Tomcat servers are not clustered

Now, is there a way that an external user who does not have access to
the servers can know the urls for each Tomcat running under different
servers? Or, is it possible that Server1 or Tomcat1 can act as the
master and have the information about other servers(remember they are
not clustered)?Can this information be made available under one hood
and used further to deploy wars or modify any configuration etc?

Thanks.

Regards,
Prarthana

-
To unsubscribe, e-mail: users-unsubscr...@tomcat.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: users-h...@tomcat.apache.org