Re: Checking preconditions/changes in models

2021-02-02 Thread Sven Meier
Hi Bas, > The thread local is probably to store the component + exception, so the listener can access it? yes, it allows the exception handler to identify the when and where of a problem. A redirect to a full page render is possible, after removing/replacing the offending component.

Re: Checking preconditions/changes in models

2021-01-29 Thread Bas Gooren
Hi Sven, Thank you for explaining in detail, it helps a lot :-) Part of your steps I have already implemented, but I never thought about marking optional components or relying on Behavior#onException. Since some components can be replaced in AJAX request, I guess you add an exception-catching

Re: Checking preconditions/changes in models

2021-01-20 Thread Sven Meier
Hi Bas, >E.g. do you handle exceptions within the model itself, or with a RequestCycleListener? a requestCycleListener is my preferred solution: - I've used Spring interceptors to wrap all exceptions from the service layer for easier identification of the origin of the problem - check the

Re: Checking preconditions/changes in models

2021-01-20 Thread Bas Gooren
Hi Sven, Thank you for your reply. On catching failure “when it happens”: can you explain what that looks like for you? E.g. do you handle exceptions within the model itself, or with a RequestCycleListener? I think the tricky part is handling exceptions thrown by models, unless I guard every

Re: Checking preconditions/changes in models

2021-01-14 Thread Sven Meier
Hi Bas, in my experience is is very hard to check every possible failure upfront in preconditions (whether from page or models). There's always a corner-case waiting to hunt you. Therefore I prefer using option 1: catch the failure when it happens. Worked fine for me (most of the time), but