Re: [vchkpw] SMTP-AUTH problem with vchkpw

2011-07-27 Thread Peter Palmreuther 
Hi,

On 27.07.2011 at 00:56 a...@ltmd.org wrote:
 
 Just want to add that I tested right now and found that the same fresh
 programs configurations and settings on the clean 32-bit system
 working pretty good. Should I try once again to use recordio program
 on a 64-bit system?

'recordio' only tells what's happening on the outside, which, as you already 
know, is a rejection.
I'd use 'strace -fF -s 4096 -o /tmp/auth.err -p TCPSERVER-PID' to monitor 
what's behind the curtain.
Execute this command immediately before you start your next test and stop it 
immediately after you failed, because it'll gather data from all connections 
and therefore collect a lot.

Within the output (/tmp/auth.err) you might need to sort out information from 
test-unrelated processes.
But you should also see who's gonna be called for actually doing the 
authentication and why it return non-success.
-- 
Regards,

Peter
!DSPAM:4e2faa3332713543020530!

Re: [vchkpw] SMTP-AUTH problem with vchkpw

2011-07-27 Thread Julien Escario 

Hello,
I also have an issue with a base64_decode() function which seems incompatible 
with amd64 arch.


I'm using the patch from milkys (http://www.mcmilk.de/qmail/)

Try to print the return string after base64 decoding has been done to check if 
your auth string is correct. If it's not, that's qmail-smtpd fault, not vpopmail's.


Regards,
Julien Escario


Le 26/07/2011 23:05, a...@ltmd.org a écrit :

Hello Rick,

Sunday, July 3, 2011, 17:15:29, Rick Macdougall wrote:
RM  On 03/07/2011 5:11 AM, a...@ltmd.org wrote:

Hello Rick,

Saturday, July 2, 2011, 16:59:09, Rick Macdougall wrote:

User vpopmail realy exists. I also cannot find the

difference between working x86 server configuration and the new
amd64 one. I tried to reconfigure my system from no-multilib to
multilib and to reemerge netqmail and vpopmail ebuilds, but still no
success. :( Is there some way to debug that plain SMTP-AUTH to figure
out what is really happening?


RM   You can use recordio (part of one of djb's packages) to log everything
RM   that happens within an smtp conversation.

RM   http://cr.yp.to/ucspi-tcp/recordio.html

Thank you for your assistance, Rick. I tried to use that nice tool.
And here goes the result:

@40004e1029d019fc59f4 22218   220 mail.domain.com ESMTP
@40004e1029d035004684 22218   EHLO [10.1.1.177]
@40004e1029d035017b1c 22218   250-mail.domain.com
@40004e1029d03501b1cc 22218   250-STARTTLS
@40004e1029d03501e494 22218   250-PIPELINING
@40004e1029d03502175c 22218   250-8BITMIME
@40004e1029d03502463c 22218   250-SIZE 0
@40004e1029d035027904 22218   250 AUTH LOGIN PLAIN
@40004e1029d10834940c 22218   AUTH PLAIN
@40004e1029d108356ecc 22218   334
@40004e1029d109252dcc 22218   c2VuZGVyLmNvbXBhc3N3b3Jk
@40004e1029d6092f863c 22218   535 authentication failed (#5.7.1)
@40004e1029d60994146c 22218   RSET
@40004e1029d60994e374 22218   250 flushed
@40004e1029d60b8495e4 22218   AUTH LOGIN
@40004e1029d60b85ca7c 22218   334 VXNlcm5hbWU6
@40004e1029d60c5eadec 22218   c2VuZGVyLmNvbQ==
@40004e1029d60c5ff9f4 22218   334 UGFzc3dvcmQ6
@40004e1029d60d4acf24 22218   cGFzc3dvcmQ=
@40004e1029db0d59619c 22218   535 authentication failed (#5.7.1)
@40004e1029db0e782f7c 22218   RSET
@40004e1029db0e78cbbc 22218   250 flushed
@40004e1029db10ef51cc 22218   MAIL FROM:sen...@domain.com   SIZE=524
@40004e1029db10f0f3c4 22218   250 ok
@40004e1029db281154f4 22218   RCPT TO:receip...@domain.com
@40004e1029db2812eb34 22218   250 ok
@40004e1029db2a9afd74 22218   DATA
@40004e1029db2aa021dc 22218   354 go ahead
@40004e1029db2b9f619c 22218   Date: Sun, 3 Jul 2011 11:35:32 +0300
@40004e1029db2ba00d7c 22218   From: Name Surnamesen...@domain.com
@40004e1029db2ba08e64 22218   Reply-To: Name Surnamesen...@domain.com
@40004e1029db2ba10b64 22218   X-Priority: 3 (Normal)
@40004e1029db2ba1847c 22218   
Message-ID:86092590.20110703113...@domain.com
@40004e1029db2ba1fd94 22218   To: receip...@domain.com
@40004e1029db2ba276ac 22218   Subject: test
@40004e1029db2ba2efc4 22218   MIME-Version: 1.0
@40004e1029db2ba364f4 22218   Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
@40004e1029db2ba3de0c 22218   Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
@40004e1029db2ba45724 22218
@40004e1029db2ba5ba9c 22218   test
@40004e1029db2ba9f88c 22218   .
@40004e1029db376d0894 22218   250 ok 1309682129 qp 2
@40004e1029db3888d4ec 22218   RSET
@40004e1029db3889cb04 22218   250 flushed
@40004e1029db3982d104 22218   QUIT
@40004e1029db398a79f4 22218   221 mail.domain.com
@40004e1029db398a81c4 22218   [EOF]
@40004e1029db399445c4 tcpserver: end 22217 status 0
@40004e1029db39944d94 tcpserver: status: 0/40

Right now I see that there is something goes wrong with a
authentication process in qmail and this dump is not very useful for
me. :( Are there any other ideas I can try?



RM  Hi,

RM  I'd trying asking on a spamdyke mailing list.  If it was plain
RM  qmail-smtpd then you'd see in the logs why it failed.

RM  Rick

I was done fresh clean install on gentoo amd64 netqmail and vpopmail
with mysql support. No any clamav, spamassassin, spamdyke and others.
SMTP-AUTH still not working. Trying to figure out what is really
happening.







--
---
 __   ___   Julien Escario
/\  _  \ /\_ \   esca...@azylog.net
\ \ \L\ \  __  __\//\ \ ___  __   Tél. : +33.677583199
 \ \  __ \/\_ ,`\ /\ \/\ \ \ \ \   / __`\  /'_ `\
  \ \ \/\ \/_/  /_\ \ \_\ \ \_\ \_/\ \L\ \/\ \L\ \ Azylog
   \ \_\ \_\/\\\/` \/\\ \/\ \ \ Rte de Champagnole
\/_/\/_/\// `/___/ \//\/___/  \/___L\ \ F-39300 Les Nans
   /\___//\/ SIRET 49130560300020
   \/__/ \_/__/
Hébergement mutualisé