Re: [vdr] Not good behaviour from vdr

2007-10-03 Thread jori.hamalainen
What is point to that, that VDR do restart IF there is no stream what it should record.. That affected to all other recordings too because vdr was restarting itself constantly. Not good! Is there setting somewhere where you can say that do not restart if there is no stream. This has been

Re: [vdr] Not good behaviour from vdr

2007-10-03 Thread Jouni Karvo
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: How does that sound? Complicated. And you did not even consider cases such as: The card is receiving perfectly another channel on the same mux, so tuning to another mux would not be an option. Although it is easy to add conditions like this to the code, it would mean

Re: [vdr] Not good behaviour from vdr

2007-10-03 Thread jori.hamalainen
How does that sound? Complicated. And you did not even consider cases such as: The card is receiving perfectly another channel on the same mux, so tuning to another mux would not be an option. This was the FIX1. Transponder = mux = 'kanavanippu'. The tests was for VDR to better

Re: [vdr] Not good behaviour from vdr

2007-10-03 Thread Jouni Karvo
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: How does that sound? Complicated. And you did not even consider cases such as: ... Because I've seen this restart cycle many times, and only way out of it is editing via [your favorite editor] the timers.conf file. I have seen the problem too. Just removing

Re: [vdr] Not good behaviour from vdr

2007-10-03 Thread Walter Koch
Moin, The solution with three options sounds best: restart always, if no other (working) recordings, never. But this doesn't stop the VDR started to restart itself every minute- problem completely. If there was already one emergency exit shortly before and the stream didn't come back, it

Re: [vdr] Not good behaviour from vdr

2007-10-03 Thread Steffen Barszus
Walter Koch schrieb: Moin, The solution with three options sounds best: restart always, if no other (working) recordings, never. But this doesn't stop the VDR started to restart itself every minute- problem completely. If there was already one emergency exit shortly before and

Re: [vdr] Not good behaviour from vdr

2007-10-03 Thread Stone
Maybe a solution for all the ideas in here ? Let vdr call a command and decide based on exit status ? This could be simply set to /bin/false for never restart or any sophisticated logic for everything else ? The main problem for me is that my reception is not that great. During bad

Re: [vdr] Not good behaviour from vdr

2007-10-03 Thread VDR User
There are some great suggestions in the beginning of this thread, please let's not create a complicated solution where it's unnecessary to have one. Let the user decide the behavior he wants and leave it at that. No need/want for vdr to try auto-tuning this channel or that transponder, or

Re: [vdr] Not good behaviour from vdr

2007-10-03 Thread Rainer Zocholl
[EMAIL PROTECTED](VDR User) 30.09.07 13:37 On 9/30/07, Jouni Karvo [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: VDR User wrote: I like these ideas... NO SIGNAL image in recording during no signal. Or that if no signal then no writing to disk. And a warning in the log about a possible incomplete recording cuz

Re: [vdr] Not good behaviour from vdr

2007-10-03 Thread Rainer Zocholl
[EMAIL PROTECTED](Ludwig Nussel) 01.10.07 14:28 Klaus Schmidinger wrote: On 09/29/07 09:30, Timothy D. Lenz wrote: I don't know about it restarting. The crashing with loss of signal is suposed to be a safe guard against creating blank recordings. Seems like a bad idea to me to. Just delete

[vdr] FTA channel with DVB subtitles

2007-10-03 Thread jdobry
Hi, Klaus want to have FTA channel with DVBsubtitles. A have 2 messages: good message: channel CT24 have it during news session (19:00-19:30) and many other times bad message: Transponder is Astra3A at 23.5E (12525/V SR:27500 FEC:3/4 SID:8006 VPID:165 APID:100) Transponder on Astra 19.2E don't