Hi all, There is a fierce discussion on E-cat world http://www.e-catworld.com/2014/06/17/discrete-breathers-in-lenr-paper/#comment-1440220909
I tried to answer with what I was aware off, but there is new claims that I was not ware of, and I would like to know if it is pure BS or real, or simply biased among the question there is He4 measurement. the skeptic says that Miles/Bush He4/heat correlation was judged inconclusive finally... that McKubre dis a similar measurement inconclusive too. is there a synthetic document on He4/heat measurement, qualitative and quantitative another is on Morrison personality, which according to the Titanic paper of Jed seems to be incompetent and stubborn. the skeptic claims that he was initially supportive ... he claims also tha tritium is very near background... It seems totally false, but maybe not in peer reviewed papers... his problem is that his world stop at PR papers, and I agree that the best papers are more recent and cannot be published because of the Berlin wall agains cold fusion... this is an interesting debate to clear out arguments, and eventually clear bad claims, or reinforse argumentation... thanks for your help.
