Re: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread francis
Jed, Good points all but I think there has been a long standing "chemical" component involved here ever since the day of Langmuir. There appears to be a need for the hydrogen to go from monatomic to diatomic states -maybe not the simple oscillation proposed with the atomic hydrogen

Re: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
vorl bek wrote: > > First of all, "ignition" is only an analogy here. Nothing is or > > can be ignited or burned in the chemical sense. There is no > > oxygen. There is no fuel. No chemical changes occur in the cells. > > Thanks, I needed that reminder. Now I see that pretty much anything > goes

Re: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread vorl bek
> vorl bek wrote: > > > > > The electric heating power is apparently used to suppress the > > > reaction, not to enhance it. > > > > I have never heard of any material acting that way. If heat > > from the electric heater is used to ignite the nickel, how > > would continuing to heat it after it

Re: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
vorl bek wrote: > > The electric heating power is apparently used to suppress the > > reaction, not to enhance it. > > I have never heard of any material acting that way. If heat from > the electric heater is used to ignite the nickel, how would > continuing to heat it after it ignites suppress

Re: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread vorl bek
> The electric heating power is apparently used to suppress the > reaction, not to enhance it. I have never heard of any material acting that way. If heat from the electric heater is used to ignite the nickel, how would continuing to heat it after it ignites suppress the reaction? And how would n

RE: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Roarty, Francis X
Jed, I totally agree with your assessment of the review and the quibble over the seemingly anomalous heat gain when power is first removed - the anomaly supports the claim of an ongoing LENR reaction in the reactor where control has suddenly been handed over to a secondary agitator / signal gene